If you’ve been watching the NHL this season, you know the vibe in the arenas is shifting. It's January 2026. The holiday hangovers are gone, the Winter Classic in Miami is in the books, and we’re staring down a trade deadline that feels like it’s going to be absolute chaos. Everyone wants to talk about the same three or four teams, but honestly, the traditional "favorites" list is kinda falling apart under the weight of some massive injuries and weird mid-season slumps.
Most people just look at the standings and assume the top seed is the lock. That's a mistake. The NHL Stanley Cup favorites aren't always the teams with the most points right now—they’re the teams that aren't currently held together by athletic tape and prayer.
The Colorado Avalanche: A Wagon or a Glass Cannon?
Let’s be real for a second. The Colorado Avalanche are playing like they’re in a video game. As of mid-January, they’re sitting on a record that looks like a typo (33-4-8). Nathan MacKinnon is doing Nathan MacKinnon things, and Cale Makar is essentially a fourth forward who happens to play defense better than anyone on the planet. They are the betting favorites for a reason, often sitting around +260 to +300 depending on where you’re looking.
But here is what nobody talks about: depth and health.
Captain Gabriel Landeskog’s health is still this giant question mark hanging over the locker room. If the Avs don't add a gritty scoring forward or a stay-at-home defenseman by the March 6 deadline, can they survive a seven-game grind against a team that just beats the hell out of them? They’ve relied heavily on Scott Wedgewood in net, who has been surprisingly elite (Vezina conversation elite, actually), but playoff pressure is a different beast than a Tuesday night in November.
Why the Lightning Refuse to Die
Everyone—literally everyone—said the Tampa Bay Lightning’s window was closed. Then they went and won 11 games in a row recently.
🔗 Read more: Caitlin Clark GPA Iowa: The Truth About Her Tippie College Grades
What's wild is they did it without Victor Hedman and Ryan McDonagh for chunks of that stretch. You’ve got Nikita Kucherov still playing at an MVP level, and Andrei Vasilevskiy is... well, he’s Vasilevskiy. When he’s on, you’re not scoring. It’s that simple.
Tampa is currently the second favorite at around +700. They have the "been there, done that" energy that scares the living daylights out of younger teams like the Devils or the Sabres. If they can get a right-handed defenseman to pair with Hedman before the deadline, they might actually be the smartest bet on the board.
The Disaster in Florida and the Edmonton Curse
We have to talk about the Florida Panthers. They were the "it" team, the back-to-back champs looking for a three-peat. But man, the injury bug didn't just bite them; it moved in and started charging rent.
- Aleksander Barkov: Out with a torn ACL/MCL.
- Matthew Tkachuk: Missed a massive chunk of the early season.
- The Standings: They’re struggling to stay in a playoff spot in the Atlantic.
Can they turn it around? Sure. But betting on a three-peat when your star center is on the shelf is a bold move.
Then there’s the Edmonton Oilers. They finally got a "real" goalie in Tristan Jarry, hoping to fix the Stuart Skinner heartbreak of the last two Finals. It’s sorta working. Jarry has been steady, and McDavid and Draisaitl are still the most terrifying duo in sports. But they’re still hovering around +975 because, let’s face it, we’ve seen this movie before. They score five, but sometimes they give up six.
💡 You might also like: Barry Sanders Shoes Nike: What Most People Get Wrong
The Teams Nobody is Watching (But Should Be)
If you want a real sleeper, look at the Minnesota Wild. They pulled off the trade of the century by landing Quinn Hughes from Vancouver. Yes, it cost them a king's ransom—Zeev Buium, Marco Rossi, and a first-round pick—but it transformed their blue line overnight.
Pairing Hughes with Kirill Kaprizov gives them a dynamic they’ve never had. They’re sitting third in the power rankings for a reason. They play a heavy, suffocating game that translates perfectly to playoff hockey.
And don't sleep on the Dallas Stars (+1900). Jim Nill is a wizard. They have this perfect blend of "old man strength" (Jamie Benn, Tyler Seguin) and "young kid speed" (Wyatt Johnston, Logan Stankoven). They’re the most consistent team in the league. They don’t have the flashy 10-game win streaks, but they also don't lose three in a row.
What Most People Get Wrong
The biggest misconception about NHL Stanley Cup favorites is that the President’s Trophy winner (the team with the most regular-season points) is the favorite to win it all.
History hates the President’s Trophy winner.
📖 Related: Arizona Cardinals Depth Chart: Why the Roster Flip is More Than Just Kyler Murray
The playoffs are a completely different sport. The whistles go away. The power plays dry up. It becomes a war of attrition. That’s why teams like Carolina (+850) are so dangerous. Rod Brind'Amour has them playing a system that is basically a 60-minute car crash for the opponent. They lost goalie Pyotr Kochetkov to a long-term injury, which is a massive blow, but if they trade for a veteran netminder, their odds will skyrocket.
How to Actually Evaluate the Contenders
If you’re trying to figure out who’s actually going to hoist the Cup in June, stop looking at the "Goals For" column. Look at these three things instead:
- Penalty Kill Percentage: In the playoffs, your PK is your lifeblood.
- Faceoff Wins in the Defensive Zone: If you can't win a draw when you're tired, you're dead.
- Third-Pairing Defensemen: The stars cancel each other out. The Cup is won by the guys playing 14 minutes a night who don't make mistakes.
The 2026 race is wide open. You’ve got the juggernaut in Colorado, the grizzled vets in Tampa, the desperate stars in Edmonton, and a bunch of hungry "new blood" teams like Detroit and Buffalo actually making noise in the Atlantic for the first time in a decade.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts
- Watch the "Soft" Deadline: February 4 is the unofficial start of trade season. Watch which teams move early to shore up their bottom-six forwards.
- Monitor the Olympics: The Milano Cortina 2026 games in February are going to exhaust the stars. Teams with fewer Olympians might have a massive "stamina advantage" come April.
- Follow the Goalie Carousel: If Carolina or Edmonton makes a move for a disgruntled starter on a losing team (think someone like John Gibson if he's still moving), that's your signal to buy in.
- Check the Atlantic Division Grind: The Red Wings and Sabres are legitimate playoff threats this year. This means the path through the Eastern Conference is much more physical than it was two years ago.
The Stanley Cup remains the hardest trophy in sports to win. Being a favorite in January is a nice ego boost, but as the Florida Panthers are finding out, the crown is heavy, and everyone is trying to knock it off your head.