Hockey is weird. You can have a team like the Winnipeg Jets fall off a cliff for eleven straight games, only to suddenly look like world-beaters again. Tonight, January 15, 2026, we have a massive ten-game slate that’s basically a minefield for anyone just looking at the "L10" column on a standings page. If you're hunting for nhl hockey picks tonight, you've got to look past the surface-level streaks and find where the value is actually hiding.
Most people see a "heavy favorite" and think it’s easy money. It’s not. In the NHL, the "puck line" is where dreams go to die, especially when you’re dealing with backup goalies and teams playing their second game in twenty-four hours. Let’s break down the chaos and find some actual winners.
The Marner Revenge Game: Leafs at Golden Knights
This is the one everyone is talking about. Mitch Marner facing Toronto for the first time after spending nearly a decade in a blue and white sweater. Honestly, the atmosphere at T-Mobile Arena is going to be electric, but emotion doesn't always translate to a win. The Golden Knights are coming off a gritty 3-2 overtime win against the Kings just last night. They're tired.
Toronto, meanwhile, got absolutely embarrassed by the Utah Mammoth earlier this week. A 6-1 loss usually lights a fire under a team like the Leafs. With Adin Hill potentially returning for Vegas after missing 38 games, there’s a massive question mark in the crease. Is he rusty? Probably. Joseph Woll is expected to start for Toronto, and while he’s been up and down, he’s rested.
The Pick: Take the Maple Leafs Moneyline (+115). Vegas is on a five-game winning streak, but they’re gassed and the narrative surrounding Marner usually leads to the visiting team playing with an extra chip on their shoulder.
Why the Wild Are the "Get-Right" Play
Minnesota is playing host to those aforementioned Winnipeg Jets. The Jets have won three straight, which sounds great until you realize they just escaped a double-digit losing streak. Their power play is currently a disaster, clicking at a measly 14.3%. You can't win in today's NHL if your special teams are that stagnant.
📖 Related: Ryan Suter: What Most People Get Wrong About the NHL's Ultimate Survivor
The Wild have dropped two in a row, but their underlying numbers are actually solid. Kirill Kaprizov and Matt Boldy are still creating high-danger chances at an elite rate. Minnesota is starting Jesper Wallstedt, who has been a revelation this season with a 2.04 GAA. On the other side, Connor Hellebuyck—despite his legendary status—hasn't had a save percentage over .900 in ten straight games.
The Pick: Minnesota Wild Moneyline (-140). The goaltending mismatch here is too big to ignore. Wallstedt is the future, and Hellebuyck is struggling to find his form behind a Jets defense that gives up way too many odd-man rushes.
Desperation in the Atlantic: Sabres vs. Canadiens
Buffalo is currently sitting in a Wild Card spot, but it’s a fragile lead. They played last night, which means they’re turning to James Ellis in net. The Canadiens are rested and have a weirdly dominant record against the Sabres lately, winning five straight head-to-head matchups.
Montreal is a young, fast team that thrives on transition play. Juraj Slafkovsky and Ivan Demidov have found some serious chemistry on the top line. Because Buffalo is on the tail end of a back-to-back, their legs are going to go heavy in the third period. That's when the Habs usually pounce.
The Pick: Montreal Canadiens Moneyline (-130). The "rest vs. rust" argument usually favors the rested team when the opponent played the night before. Plus, the Canadiens' team total Over 3.5 looks like a sneaky good play.
👉 See also: Red Sox vs Yankees: What Most People Get Wrong About Baseball's Biggest Feud
Under the Radar: Stars at Utah Mammoth
Don't sleep on the Mammoth. They’ve been one of the biggest surprises of the 2025-26 season. They just thumped Toronto and now they welcome a Dallas Stars team that is arguably the most consistent squad in the Western Conference.
The Stars are missing Tyler Seguin (ACL), but their depth is insane. However, Utah is a different beast at home. Mikhail Sergachev has been a monster on the blue line, and Clayton Keller is playing like a Hart Trophy candidate. This game feels like it’s going to be a defensive grind.
The Pick: Under 6.0 Total Goals (-115). Both teams play a very structured, playoff-style game. Don't expect a track meet here.
Expert Prop Bets to Watch
If you aren't into betting the outcomes, the player props tonight are actually where the "sharp" money is going.
- Connor McDavid Over 1.5 Points (-125): The guy has 82 points already. He’s on a 20-game point streak. Betting against McDavid right now is like betting against the sun rising. He faces an Islanders team that struggles with elite speed.
- David Pastrnak Over 3.5 SOG (-115): The Bruins are facing the Kraken. Pastrnak treats the Kraken like a personal shooting gallery, averaging 6 shots on goal in his last eight games against them.
- Zach Werenski Over 3.5 SOG (+105): Werenski is basically a fourth forward for Columbus. He’s averaging nearly 3.7 shots per game and Vancouver’s defensive structure has been leaky lately.
Understanding the "Back-to-Back" Trap
When looking for nhl hockey picks tonight, always check who played yesterday. Teams like Buffalo, Philadelphia, and Seattle are all on the second half of a back-to-back. Historically, teams in this position win less than 45% of the time. The fatigue isn't just physical; it's mental. Lapses in coverage lead to power play opportunities, and that's where games are lost.
✨ Don't miss: OU Football Depth Chart 2025: Why Most Fans Are Getting the Roster Wrong
Pittsburgh is hosting Philadelphia tonight. The Flyers are starting Samuel Ersson, who has lost seven of his last eight starts. The Penguins are starting Stuart Skinner, who has been nearly perfect over his last four games with a 1.03 GAA. It seems like a lock, right? Just be careful with the puck line (-1.5). Rivalry games like the Battle of Pennsylvania often stay closer than the stats suggest.
How to Build a Smart Parlay
If you're going to parlay, keep it small. Two or three legs max. A decent "safety" parlay for tonight would be:
- Capitals Moneyline (hosting a struggling Sharks team).
- Bruins Moneyline (Seattle is tired and Swayman is coming off a shutout).
- Oilers Moneyline (McDavid is simply too hot to fade).
This pays out at roughly +173. It’s not a lottery ticket, but it’s a lot more realistic than a 10-leg "shot in the dark" that falls apart because some backup goalie has the game of his life in Columbus.
Actionable Betting Steps
- Confirm Goalies: Never place a bet until the morning skate is over and the goalies are "confirmed" on sites like Daily Faceoff. A late switch from a starter to a backup can swing the odds by 30 cents.
- Check the Injury Report: The Golden Knights are missing William Karlsson and Brayden McNabb. Those are huge pieces of their defensive identity. If you see late-scratch news, pivot immediately.
- Shop the Lines: Don't just use one sportsbook. If the Wild are -140 on one app and -132 on another, that difference adds up over a long season.
Start by focusing on the rest advantage. Look at the Canadiens over the Sabres and the Bruins over the Kraken. Those are the spots where the situational math heavily outweighs the "gut feeling." Use the player props as a hedge if you're nervous about a moneyline upset. Stick to the data, watch the line movement, and don't chase losses on the late-night Vegas/Toronto game.