So, it’s January 2026. You’re staring at your screen, your heart rate is doing things it shouldn't for a Friday morning, and you’re paralyzed by a single question: nfl who would you start?
We’ve all been there. The regular season is a distant memory, and now every single point feels like life or death. But here's the thing—most of the "expert" advice you're reading right now is fundamentally broken. They’re still looking at season-long averages as if that matters when a coach like Mike Macdonald is dialing up a defensive scheme designed specifically to turn your WR1 into a ghost.
Honestly, starting the "better" player isn't always the right move. Sometimes, you have to start the situation.
The Matthew Stafford Paradox: Chasing Stats vs. Chasing Wins
Look at the numbers from this just-finished 2025-26 regular season. Matthew Stafford finished as the passing leader with 4,707 yards. Forty-six touchdowns. Think about that for a second. In an era where everyone says the "old guard" is dead, Stafford just put up a clinic.
But if you’re asking "nfl who would you start" in a playoff matchup against a rejuvenated Seahawks defense, the math changes. Remember Week 18? Seattle held the 49ers to 3 points. Three.
If you started Stafford because he’s the yardage king, you’re playing the name, not the matchup.
Why the Rookie Surge Changes Everything
This year wasn't supposed to be the "Year of the Rookie QB," but then Drake Maye happened. 4,394 yards. 31 touchdowns. He didn't just play well for a rookie; he played like an MVP candidate for a Patriots team that literally flipped the script from 4-13 last year to 14-3 this year.
📖 Related: Why Netball Girls Sri Lanka Are Quietly Dominating Asian Sports
If you have a choice between a fading veteran like Baker Mayfield (who, let’s be real, hit a wall late in the season) and a guy like Maye, you start the hot hand.
- Drake Maye: High-efficiency, low-turnover, massive upside in Mike Vrabel's system.
- Jaxson Dart: Proved he’s more than just a college system guy by tearing up the Cowboys' secondary in the finale.
- Caleb Williams: Scrappy, high-volume, but the 24 sacks he took down the stretch should make you nervous.
Running Backs: The Volume Trap
We need to talk about Saquon Barkley. My favorite stat from this season? Saquon saw a "usage decrease" to 275 carries, and people actually complained. He still nearly took the rushing title.
When you're deciding nfl who would you start at RB, stop looking at "yards per carry" for a single game. Look at the red zone touches.
- James Cook: The actual rushing leader of 2025 with 1,621 yards. He’s the engine of that Bills offense now, not just a change-of-pace guy.
- Bijan Robinson: He finally got the workload we’ve been screaming for. 1,488 yards isn't a fluke.
- Chase Brown: If you didn't see his breakout coming in Cincinnati, you weren't watching. He’s the reason the Bengals stayed afloat while Burrow was banged up.
Wait. Don't ignore the "landmines" either. Ashton Jeanty had a historic college career, but his rookie season with the Raiders showed that even a generational talent can't outrun a bad offensive line. He averaged 2.8 yards per carry over a three-week stretch in December. If you started him based on "potential," you probably lost your matchup.
The Wide Receiver Hierarchy Has Shifted
Forget what you knew about 2024. This year, Jaxon Smith-Njigba became the alpha. 1,793 yards. He didn't just lead the league; he broke the Seahawks' franchise records.
When you're asking nfl who would you start at WR, you have to weigh targets against "defensive focus." Puka Nacua is still a god, but defenses started triple-teaming him because Stafford literally won't look anywhere else. Meanwhile, guys like Ja’Marr Chase are still consistent, but they're touchdown-dependent in a way JSN isn't.
👉 See also: Why Cumberland Valley Boys Basketball Dominates the Mid-Penn (and What’s Next)
Honestly? You start the guys who get the "garbage time" looks too. In the playoffs, no lead is safe, and teams will sling it until the final whistle.
The Mistake You’re Probably Making Right Now
Most people treat fantasy football like a spreadsheet. It's not. It's a psychological war between coaches.
Take the Lions. Jared Goff had a monster year (4,564 yards). But Dan Campbell is a maniac—he’ll go for it on 4th and Goal from the 8-yard line instead of taking the easy field goal. That’s great for Goff’s stats if it works, but it's a zero-point disaster if it doesn't.
When you're deciding nfl who would you start, you have to account for "Coach Variance."
- High Floor: Patrick Mahomes. Even in a "down" year, he’s going to give you 18-22 points.
- High Ceiling: Lamar Jackson. He can give you 40 or he can give you 10. Can your lineup survive the 10?
- The "Safety" Pick: Brock Purdy. He’s the ultimate "don't-mess-it-up" starter.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Lineup
Stop overthinking the "superstar" status. If a guy is questionable with a hamstring injury on a Saturday, and he’s playing in a 10-degree game in Buffalo? Bench him. I don't care if his name is Tyreek Hill.
Check the "Sacked Yards Lost" stats. It sounds boring, but look at Cam Ward. He lost 410 yards to sacks this year. If your league penalizes for sacks or lost yardage, a "stat-stuffer" like Ward can actually be a net negative against a pass rush like the Texans' Will Anderson.
✨ Don't miss: What Channel is Champions League on: Where to Watch Every Game in 2026
Finally, look at the weather. It sounds like a cliché, but 2025 saw three games decided by literal wind gusts.
Evaluate your roster based on three things:
- Target Share: Does he get the ball at least 8 times a game?
- Red Zone Role: Is he the one they look to inside the 10?
- Defensive Matchup: Is he facing a "shut-down" corner or a backup safety?
If the answer to two of those is "yes," that's your starter. Forget the projections. Trust the volume.
Next Steps for Your Fantasy Success
To make the most of this data, you should immediately cross-reference your current roster against the Red Zone Target Share rankings from the last four weeks of the season. Momentum in January is more valuable than total stats from September. Additionally, identify which of your players are facing defenses that rank in the bottom five for Yards Allowed per Completion, as these are the primary targets for explosive, game-winning plays in high-stakes matchups.