Look, the NFL is weird. Every year we reach October and think we’ve finally figured out which teams are elite and which are destined for a top-five draft pick. Then a week like this hits and everything flips. Honestly, if you’re looking at nfl week 5 predictions 2024, you have to stop betting on "narratives" and start looking at the actual matchups on the grass.
People love to talk about momentum. It’s a comfortable word. But in a league with a hard salary cap and weekly injury reports that look like CVS receipts, momentum is often just a mask for a lucky schedule.
This week is particularly spicy because we’ve got some massive travel schedules and divisional grudge matches that usually throw the "expert" consensus into a blender. Let’s get into why the common wisdom is probably going to let you down this Sunday.
Why the Vikings-Jets London Game is a Trap
Everyone is riding the Minnesota high right now. Sam Darnold has gone from "ghost-seeing" backup to an MVP candidate in what feels like fifteen minutes. Kevin O’Connell is basically a wizard at this point. But London is where good vibes go to die.
The travel alone is a nightmare. It’s not just a game; it’s a logistics exercise.
The Jets are desperate. Aaron Rodgers is playing like a guy who knows the clock is ticking, and even though that offense has looked clunky, their defense is still elite. People are predicting a Vikings blowout, but this feels like a 17-13 slog where nobody really wins, even the person who gets the "W."
Predicting a Minnesota win is the "safe" play, but don't be shocked if the Jets' pass rush makes Darnold look like the 2018 version of himself again for a few drives.
👉 See also: NFL Fantasy Pick Em: Why Most Fans Lose Money and How to Actually Win
The Ravens and Bengals Shootout (That Might Not Happen)
This is the game everyone circled on their calendar. Lamar Jackson vs. Joe Burrow. It’s the high-octane AFC North battle that usually ends with someone kicking a 50-yard field goal in the rain.
Defensive Adjustments Nobody Talks About
- Lamar's legs are still the x-factor, but Cincinnati has been playing "contain" sets more than ever.
- The Bengals' secondary is young and prone to big-play lapses.
- Derrick Henry is finally looking like the King again in Baltimore’s system.
People expect 40 points from each side. I'm not so sure. Usually, when the world expects a shootout, Lou Anarumo (the Bengals' DC) finds a way to turn it into a wrestling match.
The Ravens are favored, and honestly, they probably should be. Henry is averaging massive yards after contact, and if Baltimore can keep the chains moving, Burrow won't even get enough possessions to keep up. It's a ball-control game disguised as a track meet.
NFL Week 5 Predictions 2024: The Underdogs with Real Teeth
The Jaguars are in trouble. Let's be real. Trevor Lawrence is under a mountain of pressure, and the Colts are coming to town with Joe Flacco potentially at the helm if Anthony Richardson isn't 100%.
You know what’s funny? The Jaguars have dominated this specific home matchup against Indy for years. Like, since the Obama administration. It’s one of those weird NFL hexes.
Even though the Jags look broken, this is the spot where they usually find their pulse. If you're making nfl week 5 predictions 2024, don't just look at the record. Look at the history. Jacksonville is desperate, and a desperate team at home in a divisional game is a dangerous animal.
✨ Don't miss: Inter Miami vs Toronto: What Really Happened in Their Recent Clashes
The Buffalo-Houston Collision
This is the "main event" for most of us. Stefon Diggs against his old team. C.J. Stroud against Josh Allen. It’s got all the drama.
Houston’s offensive line is... let's say "porous." Josh Allen, on the other hand, is playing some of the most efficient football of his career because he's finally stopped trying to do everything himself.
The Texans have the flashy weapons, but Buffalo has the better structure right now. Most "sharp" bettors are leaning Bills here because of the mismatch in the trenches. If Stroud is running for his life, it doesn't matter how good Nico Collins or Tank Dell are.
The NFC West Mess: Cardinals vs. 49ers
San Francisco is finally getting some bodies back, but they still aren't the juggernaut we saw last year. Kyler Murray is basically a human joystick, and the Cardinals are play-calling like they have nothing to lose.
Basically, the Niners should win. They have more talent. They have Kyle Shanahan. But the Cardinals have a way of sticking around like a bad cold.
If San Francisco doesn't clean up the special teams errors that have plagued them the first month, Arizona is going to keep this within one score. I wouldn't touch that spread with a ten-foot pole.
🔗 Read more: Matthew Berry Positional Rankings: Why They Still Run the Fantasy Industry
Hard Truths for Your Picks
Stop picking teams based on what they did in Week 1. This is Week 5. The tape is out.
Every defensive coordinator in the league has four games of film on these new-look offenses. This is usually the week where the "innovative" stuff starts getting shut down and we get back to basic football: who can run the ball and who can stop the run.
Look at the Chicago Bears. Caleb Williams is getting better, but the defense is the real reason they stay in games. They’re playing a Carolina team that found some life with Andy Dalton. It's not a "sexy" game, but it’s a perfect example of why you can't just look at the quarterback names.
Actionable Strategy for This Slate
If you want to actually win your office pool or just sound smart at the bar, focus on these three things.
First, look at the offensive line vs. defensive line matchups. The Giants, for example, have a sneaky good pass rush that could give Seattle fits, even though Seattle is the "better" team.
Second, ignore the London hype. The team that adapts to the time zone fastest usually wins, and that’s a coin flip every single time.
Third, watch the injury reports for the "boring" positions. Losing a starting center is often more impactful than losing a WR2.
Your Next Steps:
- Check the final injury status of Anthony Richardson and Malik Nabers before locking in anything.
- Look at the weather report for the outdoor games in the Northeast; wind is picking up this time of year.
- Fade the public on at least one "guaranteed" blowout; there's always one massive upset in Week 5.
- Watch the line movement on the Bills/Texans game—if it moves toward Houston late, the "sharps" know something about the Buffalo secondary.