NFL Week 1 Predictions 2025: Why Most People Are Getting These Matchups Wrong

Look, everyone thinks they know how September is going to go when they're staring at the schedule in May. But honestly? Week 1 is a total coin flip. Last season taught us that much. By the time we hit the 2025 kickoff, the rosters we’re looking at right now will have been through the meat grinder of training camp and the chaos of a very weird trade deadline.

The Philadelphia Eagles are walking into the season as defending Super Bowl LIX champions. That puts a massive target on their back starting Thursday night, September 4. If you’re looking for a safe bet, history says the home team with a new banner usually holds court, but this is the NFC East. Logic doesn't always apply here.

The NFL Week 1 Predictions 2025 Experts are Missing

The biggest trap on the board is the Friday night special in São Paulo. The Kansas City Chiefs and the Los Angeles Chargers are heading to Brazil, and most people are just penciling in Patrick Mahomes for a win because, well, he’s Mahomes. But look at the Chargers' roster under the second year of the new regime. They've retooled that run game with Najee Harris and Keenan Allen is back in the fold.

Travel matters. Humidity matters. The Chargers have a roster built for a slog, and if this game turns into a muddy defensive struggle in South America, the "better" team on paper might leave 0-1.

Why the Cowboys Could Stun Philly

The Thursday night opener is Cowboys at Eagles. It’s the classic rivalry. Philly swept them last year, but Dallas just snagged George Pickens to give Dak Prescott a legitimate vertical threat alongside CeeDee Lamb. The Eagles' secondary is elite, but they're dealing with the departure of some key veterans.

🔗 Read more: Liverpool FC Chelsea FC: Why This Grudge Match Still Hits Different

Don't sleep on the "Super Bowl Hangover." It’s a real thing. While the Eagles are raising a banner, Dallas has been stewing for months. I’m leaning toward a high-scoring affair where the over (currently sitting around 46.5) feels safer than the spread.

The Return of the Bengals Slow Start?

Every year, we do this. We talk about how Joe Burrow and the Cincinnati Bengals are going to light the league on fire, and every year they trip over their own shoelaces in September. This time they’re heading to Cleveland.

The Browns have a defensive front that makes life miserable for stationary quarterbacks. Even with the Bengals' staff reportedly forcing starters to play more in the preseason this year, that Huntington Bank Field crowd is going to be feral. If the Bengals don't move the ball early, the "Fade the Bengals in Week 1" trend is going to hit for the fourth year in a row.

Matchups You Actually Need to Watch

It isn't just about the primetime games. Some of the most interesting nfl week 1 predictions 2025 are buried in the 1:00 PM ET window.

💡 You might also like: NFL Football Teams in Order: Why Most Fans Get the Hierarchy Wrong

• Steelers at Jets: Aaron Rodgers is basically the villain of East Rutherford now, but he’s playing against his former squad. Meanwhile, the Steelers are bringing in a defense that ranked top-five in EPA per play last season. It’s going to be ugly. It’s going to be low-scoring. Take the under.
• Lions at Packers: This is basically for the early lead in the NFC North. Detroit is the darling of the media, but Green Bay at Lambeau in September is a nightmare. Jordan Love has the continuity that Ben Johnson’s Detroit offense might lack after some coaching turnover.
• Texans at Rams: Matthew Stafford’s back is the biggest question mark in the league. If he’s healthy, the Rams are a playoff lock. If not, CJ Stroud and the Texans are going to feast on a young Rams secondary that's still finding its identity.

The New Quarterback Reality

We’ve got a lot of "Year 2" guys trying to prove they weren't flashes in the pan. Drake Maye in New England is the one I’m watching closest. He’s got Mike Vrabel as his head coach now. That’s a massive culture shift. They face the Raiders in Week 1. The Raiders’ defense was quietly top-10 in the second half of last year, and now they have Geno Smith under center.

Is Maye ready for that kind of pressure? Honestly, probably not. New England is being favored by some books, but the Raiders +3 feels like the smartest play on the board.

How to Handle Your Betting Slip

If you're actually putting money on these nfl week 1 predictions 2025, stop looking at last year's records. They don't matter. Look at the trenches.

The Denver Broncos are hosting the Tennessee Titans, and the line is nearly 8 points. That is massive for a Week 1 game. Bo Nix has a year of experience now, and the Titans are starting over with a new coaching staff after Brian Callahan was let go. But 8 points? In the NFL? That's asking a lot from a Denver offense that struggled to find the endzone consistently last December.

📖 Related: Why Your 1 Arm Pull Up Progression Isn't Working (And How to Fix It)

Final Strategy for Week 1

1. Monitor the Injury Report: By late August, we'll know if the Achilles injuries to guys like George Kittle are going to keep them out of the opener.
2. Fade the Public: If everyone is talking about the "Lock of the Century," it’s usually a trap.
3. Watch the Weather: Especially for those early-season games in the South. Dehydration and cramps flip more Week 1 games than actual talent does.

The 2025 season is shaping up to be one of the most unpredictable in recent memory. Between the international games, the massive coaching carousel (nine vacancies filled this offseason!), and some wild trades like DK Metcalf to the Steelers, the league looks completely different than it did six months ago.

Keep your eye on the line movements as we get closer to September. The smart money usually waits until the final preseason game to move, so don't get married to any of these picks too early.

Actionable Next Steps:

• Check the updated weather reports for the São Paulo game 48 hours before kickoff.
• Track the "over/under" trends for the Bengals vs. Browns matchup, as divisional games in Week 1 historically lean toward the under.
• Verify the status of the Eagles' secondary depth before betting against the Cowboys' new-look receiving corps.