Drafting a tight end is basically the worst part of any fantasy football draft. You've got the guys who are essentially wide receivers with a "TE" tag, and then you have a massive, terrifying wasteland of blockers who might catch two passes for nine yards. It's frustrating. If you look at nfl te rankings fantasy lists from three years ago compared to now, the names at the top haven't actually changed as much as we’d like to think, which tells you everything you need to know about the scarcity of the position.
Look at Travis Kelce. Even when people said he was "declining" in 2024, he was still the guy Patrick Mahomes looked for when the season was on the line. But in fantasy? If you spent a first-round pick on him, you probably felt like you got robbed for half the year. That's the tight end trap. You're chasing a ghost of production that usually belongs to the elite Tier 1, while the rest of the league is just trying to find someone who won't give them a zero.
The Reality of nfl te rankings fantasy and the "Elite" Tier
We need to be honest about Sam LaPorta and Trey McBride. These guys didn't just "break out"; they fundamentally changed how we look at the second year of the tight end lifecycle. Historically, tight ends took three to four years to learn how to pass protect before they were allowed to run routes. Mike Ditka once famously joked about how hard it was to teach the position, and that sentiment stuck for decades. But the "New Guard" doesn't care about that.
When you’re looking at nfl te rankings fantasy for the upcoming stretch, you have to separate the volume hogs from the touchdown-dependent streamers. Volume is king. If a guy isn't seeing at least six targets a game, he’s basically a lottery ticket.
Take Mark Andrews. For years, he was the only show in town for Baltimore. Then Isaiah Likely showed up and proved he could do the exact same thing—sometimes better. Suddenly, Andrews isn't a lock for a 25% target share. This is the kind of nuance that gets lost in generic rankings. You have to look at the personnel around them. If a team adds a high-end WR2 in the draft, your "elite" tight end just became a very expensive security blanket who might only see the ball on third-and-long.
👉 See also: Last Match Man City: Why Newcastle Couldn't Stop the Semenyo Surge
Why Athletic Testing Data is Lying to You
Everyone loves a workout warrior. We see a 6'5" guy run a 4.5-second forty at the combine and we immediately think "The next Kyle Pitts." But Pitts himself is the perfect example of why physical tools don't equal fantasy points. Coaching matters more. If Arthur Smith—or whoever is calling the plays—decides that your 1,000-yard athlete is better used as a decoy to clear space for a random backup running back, your fantasy team dies.
Kyle Pitts' career has been a rollercoaster of "almost." He has the highest "off-target throw rate" against him of almost any elite tight end in recent memory. It doesn't matter if you can outjump a linebacker if the ball is sailing three feet over your head. When evaluating nfl te rankings fantasy, you have to factor in QB accuracy. A mediocre tight end with Jared Goff or Joe Burrow is often more valuable than a superstar with a rookie QB who can't read a zone defense yet.
The Middle Class is a Scam
There is a group of tight ends—think Dalton Schultz, Dallas Goedert, or Cole Kmet—who always sit in that 7th to 12th range. They are fine. They are "safe." They will also never win you a league.
Buying into the middle class of the nfl te rankings fantasy is essentially admitting you’re playing for third place. These players have a ceiling that is capped by their offense's primary options. If you aren't getting one of the top three guys, you might as well wait until the 12th round and grab a high-upside flyer like Dalton Kincaid was in his rookie year.
✨ Don't miss: Cowboys Score: Why Dallas Just Can't Finish the Job When it Matters
The Brock Bowers Effect and Rookie Expectations
Brock Bowers entered the league with more hype than almost any tight end in history. He's a "unicorn." But even unicorns get stuck in bad offenses. In Las Vegas, the quarterback situation has been a revolving door of "meh."
If you're looking at rookie tight ends, remember the "Rookie Wall." It’s real. These guys are used to 12-game college seasons. By Week 14 of the NFL season, they’ve played more football than ever before, and their production almost always dips right when you need it most for the fantasy playoffs.
Strategy: How to Actually Use nfl te rankings fantasy
You have two real options.
- The Nuclear Option: Spend the high draft capital. Get the guy who is the #1 or #2 target on his team (Kelce, LaPorta, Andrews). You do this so you don't have to think about the position for 17 weeks.
- The Late-Round Stream: Wait. Completely ignore the position until the very end. Take two guys with high "Average Depth of Target" (aDOT) and play the matchups.
The biggest mistake people make is grabbing a TE in the 5th or 6th round. That's the dead zone. You're passing up on starting wide receivers who could give you 15 points a week for a tight end who will likely give you 8. The math just doesn't work.
🔗 Read more: Jake Paul Mike Tyson Tattoo: What Most People Get Wrong
Honestly, the most successful fantasy managers I know are the ones who are aggressive on the waiver wire in Week 2. There is almost always a tight end who wasn't on the radar in August but becomes a favorite of a new offensive coordinator. Look for the guy who is on the field for 90% of snaps. Snap count is the "leading indicator" of fantasy success. If they are on the field, eventually the ball will find them.
Don't Ignore the "Old Guys"
We get obsessed with youth. We want the next big thing. But George Kittle is still out there obliterating people. People fade Kittle every year because he gets banged up, but on a "points per game" basis, he remains a monster. The San Francisco offense is so efficient that Kittle can have three catches for 80 yards and two touchdowns on any given Sunday.
He’s the ultimate "frustration" player, but in nfl te rankings fantasy, efficiency sometimes beats raw volume.
Actionable Takeaways for Your Draft
- Check the "Slot" Percentage: If a tight end is lining up in the slot or out wide more than 50% of the time, they aren't a tight end. They are a wide receiver you can play in your TE spot. These are gold.
- Red Zone Targets are Variable: Don't chase last year's touchdowns. Touchdowns fluctuate wildly. Chase targets. Targets are "sticky" from year to year; touchdowns are mostly luck and scheme.
- The "Handcuff" Tight End: In deep leagues, if an elite TE goes down, their backup often steps into 80% of that role for zero cost. Keep an eye on Isaiah Likely (Ravens) or Luke Musgrave/Tucker Kraft (Packers) situations where two talented guys share a room.
- Bye Week Management: Never carry two tight ends unless one is an absolute superstar. That bench spot is better used for a high-upside running back.
Stop treating the tight end position like it’s a required burden. It’s an opportunity to exploit your league-mates' obsession with big names. If you miss out on the top three, stop reaching. Take the value elsewhere and figure it out on the moves list. The "perfect" rankings don't exist because the position is inherently volatile. Trust the volume, ignore the combine highlights, and watch the snap counts.