Week 1 of the NFL season is a beautiful, chaotic lie. We spend seven months obsessing over training camp clips, preseason stat lines that don't matter, and "best shape of his life" puff pieces. Then Sunday hits, and half of what we thought we knew goes right out the window. Betting on the NFL is hard enough, but trying to nail nfl picks against spread week 1 is a specific kind of madness because the lines are built on last year’s ghost.
Vegas is sharp, but in September, they're guessing just like we are. They use power rankings from January and adjust for a few flashy free-agent signings. This creates a massive opportunity for anyone willing to ignore the "helmet value" and look at the actual matchups.
The Public Trap: Overvaluing Last Year's Giants
People love betting on what they just saw. If a team made a deep playoff run, the public hammers them in Week 1. This is why the Philadelphia Eagles, coming off their Super Bowl victory, opened as a massive 7.5-point favorite against the Dallas Cowboys for the Thursday night opener.
Honestly, laying more than a touchdown in a divisional game during Week 1 is usually a recipe for a bad time. The Cowboys are dealing with the fallout of the Micah Parsons trade to Green Bay—a move that still feels surreal—but 7.5 points is a lot of "respect" for an Eagles team that might have some early-season rust on the offensive line.
The data backs this up. Since 2016, underdogs getting 6.5 points or more in Week 1 have covered at a nearly 68% clip. It's the "Pudgy Pup" theory. These teams aren't necessarily better, but the spreads are inflated by public perception. When the New York Giants travel to Washington as 6.5-point underdogs, the "smart" money is looking at that hook. With Russell Wilson now under center for the G-Men and a pass rush featuring Brian Burns and Dexter Lawrence, they’re designed to keep games ugly and close.
🔗 Read more: Inter Miami vs Toronto: What Really Happened in Their Recent Clashes
Divisional Dogs and the "Ugly" Win
If you want to win your nfl picks against spread week 1, you have to be comfortable betting on teams that make you feel slightly nauseous.
Divisional home underdogs are the gold standard of early-season betting. Since 2010, they are 23-7 against the spread. That is a 76.7% success rate. This year, the Atlanta Falcons fit that mold perfectly as 2.5-point home dogs against the Buccaneers. Everyone remembers Baker Mayfield's late-season surge, but the Falcons have a stable of young weapons and a defense that historically plays the Bucs tough at home.
- The Bengals Slow Start: Cincinnati is notorious for stumbling out of the gate. They've lost four of their last five openers. While they are 5.5-point favorites against the Browns, history suggests Joe Burrow takes a few weeks to find his rhythm.
- The "New QB" Tax: Rookie quarterbacks on the road in Week 1 are a combined 8-21 straight up since the merger. If you're looking at Cam Ward and the Titans traveling to Denver, that 7.5-point spread for the Broncos starts to look a lot more reasonable, even with the "big underdog" trend working against it.
Why the Dolphins are the Week 1 "Sharp" Play
There's a lot of noise around the Miami Dolphins visiting the Indianapolis Colts. The Colts are laying 1.5 points, mostly because of the home-field advantage and the fact that they’ve surprisingly turned to Daniel Jones to lead the offense.
But look at the health.
💡 You might also like: Matthew Berry Positional Rankings: Why They Still Run the Fantasy Industry
Miami is a track team. In October and November, the humidity and injuries usually start to sap their speed. In Week 1? They are at 100%. Tua Tagovailoa has Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle at full tilt, and the Indy secondary is... well, it's a work in progress. Getting the Dolphins as a road underdog in a dome where weather isn't a factor is a gift.
Most bettors will see "Colts at home" and "Daniel Jones" and think stability. The sharps see a Miami defense under Anthony Weaver that is finally healthy and a Miami offense that averages nearly 30 points in September.
The Travel Factor: São Paulo and Beyond
We can't talk about Week 1 without mentioning the Chiefs and Chargers playing in Brazil. Kansas City is a 3-point favorite, but international games are a total wildcard for the spread. Jim Harbaugh is 5-0 against the spread in Week 1 games as an NFL head coach. He knows how to prep for the weirdness.
The Chargers have added playmakers, and while betting against Patrick Mahomes feels like a death wish, the Chargers +3 in a neutral-site game with travel fatigue involved is a classic "hold your breath" value play.
📖 Related: What Time Did the Cubs Game End Today? The Truth About the Off-Season
Actionable Strategy for Your Week 1 Slate
To actually make money on nfl picks against spread week 1, you need a checklist that ignores the talking heads on Sunday morning.
- Prioritize the Under: Defenses almost always start the season ahead of offenses. In the last 20 years, the Under hits over 52% of the time in Week 1.
- Fade the "Super Bowl Hangover": Teams that lost the Super Bowl the previous year are 2-9 against the spread in their next Week 1 game. If a team is coming off a heartbreaking February, they are usually overvalued.
- Hunt the 6.5+ Dogs: As mentioned, the ROI on big underdogs in the opening week is a massive 31%. If the spread looks "too big" for a professional football game, it probably is.
- Trust the "Non-Playoff" Bounce: Teams that missed the playoffs last year cover 57% of the time in Week 1. They’ve had longer to prepare, more time to heal, and more motivation to prove the doubters wrong.
Stop looking at the 2024 standings. They are irrelevant now. Focus on the teams with new offensive coordinators, the teams playing at home as divisional dogs, and the teams that the public has already written off. That is where the money is made in September.
Lock in the Giants +6.5, the Falcons +2.5, and look seriously at the Dolphins as a road dog. The board is messy, but the trends are screaming.
Next Step: Check the final injury reports on Friday afternoon specifically for offensive line depth. In Week 1, a single missing starting guard can swing a 3-point spread into a blowout because the communication isn't there yet.