You're sitting on the edge of your couch, wings getting cold, and the clock hits zero with the score deadlocked. It’s the moment every football fan simultaneously loves and hates. Overtime. But honestly, if you haven’t brushed up on the rulebook since about 2022 or 2024, you're probably going to be yelling at the TV for the wrong reasons. The NFL has fundamentally shifted how "extra football" works, moving away from that old "first touchdown wins" era that used to drive everyone crazy.
The biggest thing to wrap your head around is that the NFL overtime rules are no longer a total "sudden death" sprint from the jump. Whether it's a random Sunday in October or the Super Bowl in February, the league has tried to fix the massive advantage once held by the team that won a simple coin toss.
💡 You might also like: THE Podcast Ohio State: What Most Fans Get Wrong About Buckeye Media
The Current State of NFL Overtime Rules
Basically, the old way was simple but felt unfair: win the toss, score a touchdown, game over. The other team’s high-paid quarterback never even touched the grass. Fans hated it. Networks hated it. After the Buffalo Bills lost a legendary shootout to the Kansas City Chiefs in 2022 without Josh Allen getting a chance in OT, the league finally buckled.
Here is how it works now for the regular season. If the game is tied after four quarters, there’s a three-minute break followed by a coin toss. The winner chooses to kick, receive, or pick a side of the field.
Now, both teams are guaranteed a possession. Even if the team that gets the ball first marches down and scores a touchdown, the other team gets their shot. If that second team scores a touchdown too? Then we move into true sudden death where the next score of any kind—field goal, safety, whatever—ends it.
Timing and the Regular Season Clock
It’s a 10-minute period. That’s it.
In the regular season, there is no second overtime. If the clock hits zero and the score is still tied, the game ends in a tie. Coaches hate it because it feels like half a win, but the league prioritizes player safety and getting the game over with so the next broadcast can start.
You get two timeouts. That's a drop from the three you have in a normal half. Also, there are no coach’s challenges. Every single reviewable play is handled by the replay official upstairs. If you see a coach reaching for a red flag in OT, they’ve forgotten the rules and are about to lose a timeout for their trouble.
Why the Playoffs Are a Different Beast
When January rolls around, the stakes go up and the rules change again. You can't have a tie in the playoffs. Someone has to move on to the next round, so the 10-minute "one and done" clock from the regular season is tossed out the window.
In the postseason, overtime periods are 15 minutes long. If nobody has won by the end of that first 15 minutes, you just keep going. It’s essentially a brand-new game starting from scratch.
✨ Don't miss: Finding Your Seat: A Map of Bengals Stadium and the Best Places to Watch a Game
If a game is still tied after two overtime periods (which is essentially a full "overtime half"), there is a tiny two-minute intermission. Then they play a third and fourth period if necessary. If, by some miracle of fatigue and defense, it’s still tied after four overtime periods, they do another coin toss and start all over again.
The "New Game" Strategy
Because both teams are guaranteed the ball in the playoffs, the strategy has flipped. In the past, you always wanted the ball first. Now? Some coaches, like Kyle Shanahan during Super Bowl LVIII, have faced heavy scrutiny for taking the ball first.
The logic for kicking off (taking the ball second) is that you know exactly what you need. If the first team kicks a field goal, you know you can go for it on every fourth down to get a touchdown and win. If they score a touchdown, you know you have to score one too, or the game is over. It turns the second possession into a four-down-territory marathon.
Small Wrinkles You Might Miss
There are a few "hidden" ways the game can end instantly that people often forget during the chaos of a broadcast.
- The Safety Factor: If the team that receives the opening kickoff of overtime gives up a safety on that very first drive, the game is over immediately. The kicking team wins. This is the only way a game ends without the "second team" getting an offensive possession.
- The Defensive Touchdown: If the defense intercepts a pass or recovers a fumble and returns it for a touchdown on the first drive, it’s over.
- The "Point After" Rule: In the regular season, if a game ends on a touchdown, they don't even bother kicking the extra point. Everyone just goes home. However, in the playoffs, if the second team scores a touchdown to tie or win, the sequence of the game might dictate whether an extra point or two-point conversion is even attempted.
The Evolution of Fairness
The NFL didn't just wake up one day and decide to make things complicated. This was a response to data. Between 2010 and 2021, teams that won the coin toss in the playoffs won about 86% of the time. Ten out of twelve teams won the game, and seven of them won on the very first drive.
It was essentially a game of "heads or tails" deciding who went to the Super Bowl.
👉 See also: Detroit Tigers World Series Titles: Why They Only Happen Once Every 20 Years (And Why That’s Okay)
The current 2026 ruleset aims to balance that. It forces the defense to actually make a stop rather than just sitting on the sidelines watching their season end. It also puts a massive premium on conditioning. Playing a full 60 minutes and then potentially another 15 or 30 minutes of high-intensity football is a brutal ask for the human body.
Actionable Takeaways for Fans
If you're watching a game go into the extra frame, keep these three things in mind to stay ahead of the announcers:
- Check the Clock: If it’s regular season, remember it’s a 10-minute sprint. If it’s 15 minutes, you’re watching a playoff game.
- Watch the Toss: Pay attention to whether the winner chooses to receive or kick. Under these rules, kicking off isn't the "surrender" it used to be; it’s a strategic choice to have the "final say" in the scoring sequence.
- Forget the Flags: Don't wait for a coach to challenge a bad spot or a catch. The "booth" is in total control once the fourth quarter ends.
Ultimately, these rules make the game longer and more stressful, but they also ensure that the winner is decided by the players on the field rather than a coin in the air. Next time you're arguing with a friend at a bar about why the game didn't end after that first field goal, you'll be the one with the right answer.