The NFL coaching carousel isn't just a game of musical chairs anymore. Honestly, it’s more like a high-stakes poker game where half the players are bluffing and the owners are desperate to find the next Sean McVay before their fan base revolts. You've probably seen the usual names floating around. But the reality on the ground in early 2026 is way more chaotic than the "top head coach candidates NFL" lists you'll find on most corporate sports sites.
The 2026 cycle is unique. We’ve seen titans fall. Mike Tomlin is out in Pittsburgh after nearly two decades. John Harbaugh was shown the door in Baltimore—though he didn't stay unemployed for long, basically sprinting to the New York Giants to replace Brian Daboll.
When you have legends like that hitting the market, it changes the gravity for everyone else. It makes the "young genius" archetype a harder sell for some owners who are tired of the volatility.
The Defensive Resurgence: Why the "Next McVay" Search is Slowing Down
For years, every owner wanted the young offensive play-caller. They wanted the guy who could draw up a touchdown on a napkin. But look at the names getting the most traction right now. It's the defensive minds.
💡 You might also like: New England Revolution vs. SJ Earthquakes: Why This Cross-Country Rivalry Is Kinda Weird
Jesse Minter is the name everyone is whispering about. He followed Jim Harbaugh from Michigan to the Los Angeles Chargers and immediately turned that defense into a top-five unit in 2025. People love his versatility. He doesn't just run a "system"; he breaks the opponent's will. The Atlanta Falcons and Baltimore Ravens have already finished interviews with him. He’s 42, sharp, and has that "it" factor that makes players run through brick walls.
Then there is Jeff Hafley.
The Green Bay Packers defensive coordinator is a fascinating case. He left a head coaching gig at Boston College because he was sick of the NIL/Transfer Portal mess and just wanted to coach pro ball.
Smart move.
In 2025, his Packers defense was top 10 in both yards and scoring for the first time since their 2010 Super Bowl run. He’s already sat down with the Raiders and Dolphins.
Does experience actually matter anymore?
Some teams think so. That’s why Kevin Stefanski and Robert Saleh are still very much in the mix despite getting fired. Stefanski is a two-time Coach of the Year. He survived the absolute dumpster fire of the Deshaun Watson era in Cleveland. Owners look at him and see a guy who can provide a "high floor."
Saleh is different.
His Jets tenure was... well, it was the Jets.
But as the 49ers defensive coordinator this past season, he reminded everyone why he got the job in the first place. He’s high energy. He’s a leader. The Arizona Cardinals are reportedly looking at him because they need someone to fix a culture that’s been sliding for years.
The Offensive Wildcards You Aren't Following Closely Enough
If a team is going offensive, they aren't looking for the grizzled vet. They want the guy who can maximize a rookie contract QB.
Matt Nagy (Kansas City Chiefs OC): I know, I know. Bears fans just rolled their eyes so hard they saw their own brains. But the "Andy Reid Rehab Clinic" is real. Nagy has been instrumental in keeping Patrick Mahomes playing at an MVP level even as the roster shifts. The Tennessee Titans are reportedly very close to making him their guy. He’s been through the fire in Chicago and supposedly learned from his mistakes.
Klint Kubiak (Seattle Seahawks OC): The son of Gary Kubiak has turned Sam Darnold into a Pro Bowler in Seattle. Think about that for a second. That alone deserves a Head Coaching job. He’s 38 and runs that Shanahan-style zone-run scheme that every owner dreams about at night.
Joe Brady (Buffalo Bills OC): He’s finally matured. The "wunderkind" label from his LSU days is gone, replaced by a guy who actually knows how to manage a game. He’s added structure to Josh Allen’s chaos, which is like trying to put a saddle on a hurricane.
What Really Happened with the Openings?
The 2026 landscape shifted because of the sheer volume of vacancies. Nine teams. That is over a quarter of the league. When the Steelers, Ravens, and Browns all have openings at the same time, the AFC North basically becomes the epicenter of the coaching world.
The Raiders are doing their usual "wide net" search. They've interviewed everyone from Vance Joseph to Davis Webb.
Yes, Davis Webb.
The former QB is only 31 but he’s been the "it" coaching prospect since he was a backup for the Giants. It’s probably too early for him to get a HC job, but his name being on these lists tells you how much teams value "quarterback whisperers."
The Mike McDaniel Factor
The Miami Dolphins firing Mike McDaniel was a shock to some, but not to those inside the building. There were rumors of a "CEO personality" deficit. Basically, he’s a brilliant play-caller but maybe not the guy to run a $3 billion corporation.
This is the biggest misconception about top head coach candidates NFL searches: fans want the best coordinator, but owners are hiring a manager.
That’s why someone like Brian Flores keeps getting interviews. He’s polarizing, sure. But he has a "commanding aura" that guys like McDaniel sometimes lack. The Vikings defense under Flores was a nightmare to play against in 2025, and he’s been linked to the Raiders and Ravens.
Actionable Insights for the 2026 Cycle
If you’re trying to figure out who your team is going to hire, stop looking at the stats and start looking at the connections.
- Follow the GM: If a GM worked with a coordinator at a previous stop, that’s your favorite. Example: Jeff Hafley to the Dolphins makes sense because their new GM, Jon-Eric Sullivan, was with him in Green Bay.
- The Quarterback Rule: If a team has a young QB (like the Browns with Shedeur Sanders), they will almost certainly hire an offensive-minded coach or a "CEO" type who can bring a top-tier OC with him.
- Don't ignore Special Teams: John Harbaugh proved for 18 years that special teams coordinators make great head coaches. Keep an eye on Chris Banjo (Jets) or Michael Clay (Eagles) as dark horse candidates for coordinator-to-HC jumps in future years.
The next few weeks will be a blur of private jets and "sources say" tweets. The Giants already landed their big fish in John Harbaugh. Now the rest of the league has to decide if they want to gamble on the next Jesse Minter or play it safe with a retread like Matt Nagy.
If you want to stay ahead of the curve, keep an eye on the second-round interviews. That’s where the real hiring happens. When a guy gets flown in for a second time, the contract is usually already being drafted. Check the local beat reporters for the Falcons and Raiders specifically; those two jobs are the "hinge" of this entire cycle and will determine where the rest of the dominos fall.