Draft day is pure chaos. You spend months looking at mock drafts, analyzing 40-yard dash times, and convincing yourself that your team has a crystal-clear path to a franchise quarterback. Then the clock starts. Roger Goodell walks out. Suddenly, a team trades up from the twenties into the top five, and every single projection for the draft picks in order goes straight into the trash can. It’s glorious. It's also incredibly frustrating if you're trying to actually predict how the talent flows from the college ranks to the pros.
The truth? Teams don't draft the best players. They draft for "fit," which is often just a polite way of saying they're terrified of getting fired.
The Logic (And Lack Thereof) Behind Draft Picks in Order
Most fans think the draft is a linear progression of talent. You take the best guy, then the next best guy. Simple, right? Except it’s not. The sequence of draft picks in order is governed by a mix of the "Value Chart"—famously popularized by Jimmy Johnson in the 90s—and sheer, unadulterated desperation.
Take the 2024 NFL Draft, for instance. We saw a record-breaking run on offensive players. The first 14 selections were all on the offensive side of the ball. That had never happened in the common draft era. If you were looking for a pass rusher or a shutdown corner, you had to wait nearly two hours before the first defensive name was called. Laiatu Latu finally broke the streak at pick 15. This wasn't because there were no good defensive players; it was because the league-wide panic over finding the next C.J. Stroud or Patrick Mahomes forced every quarterback-needy team to reach.
Teams like the Chicago Bears and Washington Commanders didn't just pick players; they picked hope. Caleb Williams going number one was the least surprising thing in the world, but the way the rest of the draft picks in order tumbled after him was a masterclass in positional scarcity.
✨ Don't miss: Simona Halep and the Reality of Tennis Player Breast Reduction
Why the "Best Player Available" is Usually a Lie
You hear GMs say it every year. "We just took the best player on our board." Honestly, they’re usually lying to you. If the best player is a tight end but you already have an All-Pro at that position and your left tackle is a human turnstile, you aren't taking the tight end.
The draft order is a puzzle where the pieces change shape while you’re trying to fit them together.
- The Quarterback Tax: If a QB is even 70% as good as a generational defensive end, he’s probably going higher.
- Medical Red Flags: A guy like Michael Penix Jr. had the talent to be a top-five lock, but his injury history made his spot in the draft picks in order a massive guessing game until the Falcons shocked everyone at number eight.
- The Run on a Position: Once three wide receivers go in a row, the teams at picks 15 through 20 start sweating. They’ll often trade up or "reach" for the fifth-best receiver just because they’re scared of being left with nothing.
The Trade Market: Flipping the Script
The order isn't static. It's a marketplace. When you look at the draft picks in order on a spreadsheet, it looks fixed. But in the "War Room," those picks are currency.
Think back to the 2021 draft. The San Francisco 49ers gave up a king's ransom—three first-round picks—just to move up to the third spot. They wanted Trey Lance. It was a massive swing that ultimately didn't work out for them, but it illustrates how much teams value the opportunity to pick in a specific slot. They aren't just buying a player; they're buying the right to choose before anyone else can.
🔗 Read more: NFL Pick 'em Predictions: Why You're Probably Overthinking the Divisional Round
Then you have the masters of the "trade back." The Seattle Seahawks under John Schneider or the Ravens under Eric DeCosta often look at the draft picks in order and decide that having more bites at the apple is better than one big bite. They’ll trade a mid-first-round pick for a second and a third. They know that the draft is, at its heart, a lottery. The more tickets you have, the better your chances of hitting a jackpot.
Small School Sleepers and the "Second Wave"
Once you get past the first 32 picks, the narrative shifts. The names become less familiar to the casual fan. But this is where Super Bowls are actually won.
The draft picks in order through rounds four, five, and six are where scouts earn their paychecks. Look at Jared Allen (4th round), Richard Sherman (5th round), or the most obvious example ever, Tom Brady (6th round). These guys weren't "bad" prospects; they just didn't fit the physical prototypes that GMs obsess over in the first round.
The Psychological Toll of the Order
We don't talk enough about what the order does to the players. Being the "First Overall Pick" comes with a mountain of pressure and a massive paycheck. But being the "Last Pick"—the "Mr. Irrelevant"—comes with its own weird fame. Brock Purdy changed the way we look at the very end of the draft picks in order. He went from a guy just hoping to make a practice squad to starting in a Super Bowl in two years.
💡 You might also like: Why the Marlins Won World Series Titles Twice and Then Disappeared
It proves that while the order matters for contracts and ego, it means nothing once the pads go on in August.
Real Talk: How to Evaluate Your Team's Draft
If you want to know if your team actually did a good job, don't look at the grades on ESPN the next morning. Nobody knows anything yet. Instead, look at the "Value Over Replacement." Did they get a guy at pick 50 who was projected to go at pick 25? That’s a win. Did they trade away next year’s first-rounder for a guy who might not even start? That’s a massive gamble that usually ends in a coaching staff getting fired two years later.
The draft picks in order are essentially a snapshot of a team’s internal fears and aspirations.
Actionable Steps for Following the Next Draft
Forget the mock drafts that come out in January. They’re useless. If you want to actually understand how the draft picks in order will play out, do this instead:
- Watch the Trenches: Don't just look at the QB rankings. See how many elite tackles and edge rushers are available. If that pool is shallow, expect those players to go much higher than "experts" predict.
- Follow the Money: Look at which teams have the most "Dead Cap" space. Teams that are broke in free agency are forced to fill holes through the draft, making their picks much more predictable.
- Ignore the "Draft Grade": Wait at least three seasons before judging a draft class. A "D+" grade for a team taking an unheralded linebacker looks pretty stupid three years later when that guy is an All-Pro.
- Track the Trade Charts: Use a standard draft value chart (like the Rich Hill model) to see if your team is winning or losing trades in real-time. It's the best way to see if your GM is being aggressive or getting fleeced.
The draft isn't a science. It’s a high-stakes poker game played by people who are under immense pressure to win now. The sequence of draft picks in order is just the paper trail of those decisions. Understand the desperation, and you'll understand the draft.