You’ve seen it a hundred times. A wide receiver drags a toe along the white paint of the sideline, the ref signals incomplete, and the camera pans immediately to the head coach. He’s fumbling with his pocket, looking for that little red piece of weighted cloth. But have you ever noticed how hesitant they are? It’s not just about being unsure of the catch. It’s about the math.
If you're wondering how many challenges nfl coaches actually get, the answer is simpler than the rulebook makes it sound, though the league recently threw a massive bone to the guys on the sideline.
The Magic Number: Two (With a Bonus)
Basically, every NFL team starts a game with two challenges. That’s your baseline. You can’t just go around throwing the red flag every time a holding call gets missed (actually, you can't challenge holding at all, but we’ll get to that). You get two shots to tell the refs they messed up.
Here is where it gets interesting for the 2025 and 2026 seasons. For years, the rule was a bit of a "perfectionist" trap. If a coach used both challenges and won both of them, the league rewarded them with a third. But if you went 1-for-2? You were done. Out of luck. No more flags.
The NFL owners finally realized that was kinda dumb. In 2024, they changed the rule. Now, if you win just one of your first two challenges, you get a third one. It’s a huge shift. It means coaches don't have to be quite as terrified of losing that second challenge and being "locked out" for the rest of the game.
Why the Replay Assistant is Changing the Game
Honestly, the "how many challenges" question is starting to matter less because of something called Replay Assist. If you've watched a game lately and noticed a call get fixed without a flag being thrown or the ref even going to the "hood" (that little monitor on the sideline), that’s the SkyJudge at work.
The replay official in the booth and the Art McNally GameDay Central in New York can now "advise" the refs on objective stuff. We’re talking about:
- Whether a runner was out of bounds.
- The spot of the ball relative to the first down marker.
- Whether a pass was touched by a defender.
- If a player’s foot was on the line.
Because this "expedited review" happens so fast, coaches aren't forced to burn their limited challenges on obvious mistakes. It saves their flags for the subjective "bang-bang" plays that need a closer look.
When You Can't Throw the Flag
You can have three challenges left and three timeouts in your pocket, but it won't matter if the clock shows 1:59.
In the final two minutes of either half, the red flag stays in the coach's pocket. It’s illegal to throw it. If a coach forgets and hurls it anyway, they actually get hit with a penalty—usually a 15-yard unsportsmanlike conduct foul or a loss of a timeout. During this "two-minute warning" period and all of overtime, every single review is initiated by the booth.
👉 See also: Santos vs Atl. San Luis: Why This Matchup Keeps Defying the Odds
The same goes for scoring plays and turnovers. Since 2011 and 2012 respectively, the NFL has automatically reviewed every touchdown and every interception or fumble. If you see a coach throw a flag after a touchdown, he's basically just venting or he's forgotten the rules, because New York is already looking at it.
The Timeout Tax
There is a catch to all of this. To challenge a play, you must have at least one timeout.
If you challenge and the ruling on the field stands (meaning you lost), you lose that timeout. If you have no timeouts left, you cannot challenge. Period. This is why you’ll often see coaches screaming at the refs to wait while they talk to their "eye in the sky" assistant in the booth. They need to be sure. Losing a timeout in the fourth quarter just to find out a catch was actually a catch is a recipe for getting fired.
What's Actually Reviewable?
This is where fans get the most frustrated. You see a blatant pass interference, the coach is livid, but the flag stays in his pocket. Why? Because you can't challenge pass interference anymore. They tried it for one year after that infamous Saints-Rams NFC Championship debacle, and it was a total disaster. The league went back to the old way almost immediately.
Here is a quick rundown of what you can actually challenge:
📖 Related: What Really Happened With the 2024 NBA Finals: Why the Celtics Dominance Felt Different
- Possession: Did he catch it? Did he fumble before he was down?
- Sidelines/End Zone: Was he in or out? Did the ball cross the plane?
- The Spot: Did the ball reach the line to gain (the first down marker)?
- Legal/Illegal passes: Was the QB past the line of scrimmage? Was it a forward pass or a fumble?
- Number of players: Did the defense have 12 guys on the field? (Surprisingly, this is challengeable if the refs miss it).
How the Process Actually Works
When that red flag hits the turf, the referee goes to the sideline. He has 60 seconds to look at the footage. He’s looking for "clear and obvious" evidence. If it’s even slightly blurry or ambiguous, the "Ruling on the Field Stands."
There is a subtle difference between "Confirmed" and "Stands."
- Confirmed: The video proved the ref was right.
- Stands: The video was too messy to prove him wrong.
In both cases, if the coach was trying to overturn the call, he loses the challenge. But "Stands" is the one that really grinds a coach's gears because it usually means they were probably right, but the camera angle sucked.
Practical Steps for Following the Rule
If you're at a game or watching on Sunday, keep an eye on these three things to stay ahead of the broadcast:
💡 You might also like: Los Angeles Angels vs Seattle Mariners: What Most People Get Wrong
- Check the Timeout Count: If a team is out of timeouts, stop looking for the red flag. It's not coming.
- Watch the Clock: If it's under two minutes, the booth has total control. The "how many challenges" count effectively resets to zero for the coaches.
- Look for the "Reset": If a coach challenges a play in the first quarter and wins, remember he now only needs one more "win" or even a "loss" to potentially have used his allotment, but thanks to the new rules, winning that first one already guarantees he keeps his options open for a third later.
The evolution of how many challenges nfl teams get shows a league trying to balance two things: getting the call right and keeping the game moving. With the addition of Replay Assist and the more forgiving "win one to get a third" rule, we're seeing fewer game-breaking officiating errors, even if it feels like we spend half the game watching commercials while a guy in New York looks at a blade of grass.