If you asked a casual fan who the greatest point-producers in football history were, they’d probably start rattling off names like Tom Brady, Jerry Rice, or maybe Emmitt Smith. It makes sense. Those guys are the faces of the league. But if you actually look at the list of all time leading scorers nfl record books, you’re going to find a very different story.
The reality? It’s a kicker’s world.
The top of the leaderboard isn't filled with quarterbacks throwing bombs or running backs bruising through the line. Instead, it’s a long line of guys who spent their careers waiting on the sidelines for fourth down. Honestly, it’s kinda wild. You have to scroll all the way down to the 40s before you even see a wide receiver.
The Unmatched Longevity of the Foot
Kicking is the ultimate "low impact, high reward" job in professional sports. While a star running back is lucky to survive eight seasons before his knees give out, a kicker can basically play until they’re eligible for AARP.
💡 You might also like: Why 2013 NBA Championship Stats Still Keep Spurs Fans Up at Night
Take Adam Vinatieri. He’s the gold standard.
Vinatieri didn't just play; he endured. He racked up 2,673 points over a career that spanned from 1996 to 2019. Think about that. He was playing when Independence Day was the biggest movie in the world, and he was still kicking when TikTok took over. That kind of longevity is why he sits at the absolute peak of the all time leading scorers nfl rankings. He didn't just have a strong leg; he had a career that refused to end.
Then you’ve got Morten Andersen, the "Great Dane."
Andersen put up 2,544 points. He played 25 seasons. Most NFL players are lucky to make it to 25 years old before they're out of the league. He played for five different teams, but mostly the Saints and Falcons, and he just kept swinging that left leg until he was 47.
Why Don't Quarterbacks Count?
This is the part that trips most people up. "Wait," you might say, "Tom Brady has hundreds of touchdowns. How is he not the leader?"
It’s all about the technicalities of the stat sheet.
In the NFL, "points scored" are credited to the person who physically carries the ball into the end zone or kicks it through the uprights. When a quarterback throws a 50-yard touchdown to a receiver, the receiver gets the 6 points. The quarterback gets the passing yards and the "passing touchdown" stat, but zero actual points for his career scoring total.
If we changed the rules to give QBs 6 points for every touchdown they threw, the all time leading scorers nfl list would be a purely quarterback-driven ranking. Brady would have over 3,800 points. Peyton Manning would be way up there too. But the record books are strict. Unless you’re running it in yourself, you aren't "scoring" in the eyes of the official historians.
The Weird Case of George Blanda
There is one major exception to the "kickers only" rule at the top, and that’s George Blanda. He’s sitting at number 7 all-time with 2,002 points.
Blanda was a freak of nature. He played 26 seasons, which is a record in itself. But what makes him special is that he was a legit quarterback and a kicker. In 1961, he was the AFL Player of the Year. He’d throw for 3,000 yards and then trot out to kick the extra point. He retired at 48. Most 48-year-olds are worried about their cholesterol; Blanda was worried about his hang time.
The Non-Kicker Wall: Jerry Rice and Everyone Else
If you filter out the guys wearing single-bar facemasks, the list of all time leading scorers nfl becomes much more familiar.
Jerry Rice is the king of the "skill" players. He’s 45th on the overall list with 1,256 points.
He scored 208 touchdowns. That is an insane number. Most Hall of Fame receivers finish with half that. But because he "only" gets 6 points at a time, he’s still more than 1,400 points behind Vinatieri.
Here is how the top of the non-kicker list looks:
📖 Related: Over the Cap Chiefs: How Brett Veach Navigates the NFL Salary Cap Minefield
- Jerry Rice: 1,256 points (WR)
- Emmitt Smith: 1,052 points (RB)
- LaDainian Tomlinson: 972 points (RB)
- Randy Moss: 950 points (WR)
- Terrell Owens: 942 points (WR)
It takes a truly legendary career to even crack 1,000 points as a runner or receiver. You basically have to be the best to ever do it at your position for 15 years straight. Meanwhile, an average kicker on a decent offense can sleepwalk into 100 points a season.
Active Players to Watch in 2026
The list isn't static. We have some active legends who are still climbing.
Matt Prater and Nick Folk are the two old guards still moving up the ranks. As of the start of the 2025-26 cycle, Prater has climbed over the 1,900-point mark. He’s the guy who held the record for the longest field goal (64 yards) for years before Justin Tucker broke it. He’s a lock for the Top 10 by the time he hangs them up.
Speaking of Justin Tucker, he’s the most accurate kicker in the history of the game. He’s currently sitting in the 1,700s. He’s younger than Prater and Folk, so if his leg holds up, he has a legitimate shot at chasing down Vinatieri’s throne. He’s the only guy currently playing who has the "per-game" scoring average to really make a run at the #1 spot.
What Most People Get Wrong
The biggest misconception is that the leading scorer is the "best" player.
Scoring is largely a product of your environment. If you’re a kicker on a team that stalls out in the red zone every drive, you’re going to have a lot of opportunities. If you play for a team that goes for it on 4th down constantly or has a terrible offense that never moves the ball, your scoring will crater.
The all time leading scorers nfl list is as much a testament to being on good offenses as it is to individual talent. Stephen Gostkowski (1,875 points) spent his best years with the Brady-led Patriots. Mason Crosby (1,939 points) had Aaron Rodgers moving the sticks for over a decade. You need the opportunities to get the points.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Historians
If you're looking to understand the future of this record, keep an eye on these factors:
- The "Go For It" Meta: Modern NFL coaches are going for it on 4th down more than ever. This is bad for kickers. If teams stop settled for 3 points, the current scoring records might never be broken.
- Kicker Accuracy: While opportunities might be slightly down, accuracy is at an all-time high. Kickers in the 70s were lucky to hit 60% of their kicks. Today, anything under 85% is considered a bad season.
- Active Leaders: Watch Derrick Henry (766 points) and Davante Adams (712 points). They are the current active leaders for non-kickers. They won't catch the kickers, but they’re chasing Jerry Rice's "skill player" crown.
Check the live stats at the end of this season to see where Prater and Tucker land. The record for all time leading scorers nfl is a marathon, not a sprint, and we are currently watching a few players run the final miles of that race.
To track these changes yourself, you can use the Pro Football Reference "Leaders" page which updates weekly during the season. If you're a fantasy player, remember that "points scored" is a pure stat—it doesn't care about "Passing TDs" or "Assists." It only cares about who crossed the white line.
Next Steps for Your Research
- Compare Career Lengths: Look up the average career length of the top 10 scorers versus the top 10 quarterbacks. You'll see a massive gap that explains the scoring disparity.
- Analyze Red Zone Efficiency: Research how team red zone "failure" (kicking field goals instead of scoring TDs) directly correlates to a kicker's rise on the all-time list.
- Study George Blanda's 1970 Season: He won the MVP award largely due to his dual-threat scoring at age 43, a feat that will likely never happen again.