You’re driving through Queens or maybe a quiet stretch in Albany, and suddenly, the car in front of you slams on its brakes for no reason. You tap their bumper. It’s a tiny scratch. But within minutes, four people are climbing out of that car clutching their necks like they’ve just survived a plane crash.
Welcome to the world of New York state insurance fraud. It isn’t just about "bad guys" in movies anymore. Honestly, it’s a massive, invisible tax that every single person in the Empire State is paying right now. If you’ve wondered why your car insurance bill looks like a mortgage payment, this is why.
In her 2026 State of the State address, Governor Kathy Hochul basically drew a line in the sand. She pointed out that New Yorkers are paying an average of $4,000 a year for auto insurance. That is $1,500 more than the national average. Why? Because of 1,729 staged crashes in a single year and over 38,000 reports of suspected motor vehicle fraud. These aren't just accidents; they are orchestrated business moves.
The "No-Fault" Trap and Why It’s Failing
New York is one of only 12 states with "no-fault" insurance. On paper, it sounds great. Your own insurance pays for your medical bills regardless of who caused the wreck. It’s meant to keep people out of court.
In reality? It’s a buffet for scammers.
The New York Department of Financial Services (DFS) reported that no-fault fraud accounted for a staggering 93% of all health care fraud reports in 2024. Organized crime rings set up "pill mills" or sham clinics. They recruit "runners" to find people willing to be in staged accidents. Then, they bill the insurance company for physical therapy, MRIs, and medical equipment that nobody ever used.
Sometimes the medical providers are the ones driving the bus. They sign off on phony diagnoses to hit that "serious injury" threshold, which opens the door for a massive lawsuit. It’s a cycle. The insurer pays, the clinic gets rich, and your monthly premium goes up another twenty bucks.
It’s Not Just Staged Crashes
While auto fraud gets the headlines because it hits our wallets directly, the rot goes deeper. We’re seeing a massive spike in cybersecurity-related insurance issues.
Just recently, in late 2025, Attorney General Letitia James secured $14.2 million from eight different insurance companies. Why? Because their quoting tools were so poorly defended that hackers were able to scrape the personal data of over 825,000 New Yorkers.
🔗 Read more: Happiest Minds Stock Price: What Most People Get Wrong
Think about that.
The very companies meant to protect you from risk were accidentally feeding your driver’s license number and date of birth to fraudsters. This data is then used to file fake unemployment claims or open fraudulent policies. It’s a multi-layered mess.
Common Varieties of the Scam
- The "Swoop and Squat": Two cars work together to trap you. One pulls in front (the squat) and slams the brakes, while the other (the swoop) prevents you from lane-shifting.
- Phantom Passengers: You hit a car with one driver. By the time the insurance claim is filed, there are suddenly four "injured" passengers who were never there.
- Upcoding: A doctor treats you for a scratch but bills the insurance for a complex surgical consultation.
- Rate Evasion: People living in Brooklyn registering their cars in North Carolina or Florida to avoid New York's high rates. This is actually a form of New York state insurance fraud that many people think is just a "life hack." It's not. It's a crime.
The Law is Finally Catching Up
For a long time, the penalties in New York were sort of a joke. If you organized a staged crash but weren't the one driving, you could sometimes wiggle out of the toughest charges. Not anymore.
The 2025-2026 legislative session has brought in some heavy hitters, like Assembly Bill A7305. This bill is designed to hike up the penalties across the board.
Currently, New York Penal Law breaks it down by the dollar amount:
📖 Related: Earnings Per Share News: What Most People Get Wrong About the 2026 Reports
- Fifth Degree: A class A misdemeanor (though new laws are pushing many of these toward felony status).
- Third Degree ($3,000+): Now being treated with much more heat as a class D felony.
- First Degree ($1 Million+): This is a class B felony. You’re looking at up to 25 years in prison.
The DFS isn't just watching from the sidelines. Superintendent Adrienne Harris has been on a tear, recovering hundreds of millions of dollars for consumers and fining companies like GEICO and Travelers for data security failures. The message is clear: if you’re an insurer, protect the data. If you’re a scammer, we’re coming for your bank account.
What You Can Actually Do
You aren't totally helpless. If you get into a fender bender, the most important thing you can do is take pictures of everything.
Take a photo of the other car’s passengers. Why? Because it stops "phantom passengers" from appearing later. Count the heads. Note their names. If the "injured" party is walking around fine and taking selfies, record it.
Also, keep an eye on your Explanation of Benefits (EOB) from your health insurer. If you see a charge for a "neurological assessment" when you only went in for a flu shot, that’s a red flag. Report it to the DFS Frauds Bureau.
💡 You might also like: Gold rate today evening in chennai: What Most People Get Wrong
Next Steps for New Yorkers:
- Document every detail of any traffic incident, including the number of people in the other vehicle.
- Verify your medical bills against the services you actually received; don't just assume the "system" is right.
- Secure your data by using multi-factor authentication on your insurance portals to prevent quote-tool scraping.
- Report suspected fraud directly to the New York Department of Financial Services at 1-888-FRAUDNY.
Staying quiet only keeps the premiums high. By understanding how these schemes work, you stop being an easy target and start helping bring those "too damn high" rates back down to earth.