Look, the Garden is loud again. That’s the first thing you notice. But if you’re just looking at the 25-16 record the New York Knicks are carrying into mid-January 2026, you’re missing the actual drama unfolding on 33rd Street. This isn’t the grit-and-grind, defensive-slugfest team of the early Tom Thibodeau era. Honestly, it’s the exact opposite, and that’s what has everyone kind of freaking out.
We’re halfway through the 2025-26 season, and the Knicks are sitting at 3rd in the East. On paper? Great. In reality? It’s complicated. Leon Rose didn't just "tweak" the roster; he blew up the foundation to build an offensive juggernaut that currently ranks 3rd in the league in offensive rating ($120.7$). But there’s a massive "but" here. The defense—the thing that was supposed to be the Knicks' identity—has slipped to 18th.
You’ve got Jalen Brunson playing like a legitimate MVP candidate, Karl-Anthony Towns trying to find his soul in the MSG bright lights, and Mikal Bridges trying to remember how to be a "Nova Knick" while his jumper occasionally goes on vacation. It’s a wild ride.
The Jalen Brunson MVP Reality Check
Let’s get one thing straight: Jalen Brunson is the best thing to happen to this franchise since the 70s. Period. He’s averaging roughly 28 points and 6 assists, and he’s doing it with a target on his back every single night.
In a recent win over the Trail Blazers, he dropped 26 while looking like he was playing at a different speed than everyone else. He’s topped 20 points in 18 straight games. That’s not just a "hot streak." That’s sustained, elite-level production. But here’s the kicker: the Knicks are 2-3 in their last five, and Brunson is currently day-to-day with a nagging ankle injury.
When he’s off the floor, the offense doesn’t just slow down. It hits a wall. The "Nova" chemistry with Bridges and Josh Hart is real, but it’s also put a massive load on Brunson’s shoulders. He’s the engine, the transmission, and the driver.
The Karl-Anthony Towns Dilemma
When the New York Knicks traded Julius Randle for KAT, the vibe was clear: "We need more space." And they got it. Towns is a nightmare to guard because he’s a 7-footer who can shoot the lights out.
However, the "Minnesota KAT" has occasionally reared its head lately. He’s currently in a brutal slump, averaging only 16.7 points over his last seven games while shooting a measly 28% from deep. Fans are getting restless. You see it on social media—the comparisons to the Julius Randle "bad days."
Is it fair? Not really. Towns is still grabbing 11.5 boards a game and giving them a verticality they haven't had. But under new coach Mike Brown, the system requires KAT to be more than just a floor spacer. He needs to be a rim protector, especially with Mitchell Robinson still sidelined with that recurring ankle issue.
"KAT has been too focused on the officials this season and it’s affected his play at times," some analysts have noted. It’s true. You see him chirping at the refs instead of getting back on defense. In New York, that stuff gets you booed.
✨ Don't miss: Manchester United v AC Milan: What Really Happened in Football's Purest Rivalry
Why the New York Knicks Defense is Leaking
If you told a Knicks fan two years ago that this team would be "soft" on defense, they’d laugh at you. But the metrics don't lie. They’re allowing 115.1 points per game. That’s 13th in the league, which sounds okay until you realize they were bottom-tier for most of January.
The issues are basically:
- Point of Attack: Without a lockdown perimeter defender outside of OG Anunoby, teams are blowing past the first line of defense.
- Interior Rotations: KAT isn't a natural shot-blocker in the way Mitchell Robinson is. When OG has to help off his man to stop a drive, the corner three is almost always open.
- The Road Blues: They are 16-4 at home but a shaky 9-11 on the road. That’s an identity crisis if I’ve ever seen one.
OG Anunoby remains the x-factor here. When he’s healthy and playing, the Knicks are a different beast. He just dropped 25 against the Warriors in a loss where Brunson was out. He’s the glue. But he can’t be everywhere at once.
The Front Office's Next Move
Leon Rose and Gersson Rosas aren't the types to sit on their hands. They’ve already won the NBA Cup this season (the "In-Season Tournament" for those still adjusting to the name), which was a nice trophy for the cabinet. But they want the big one.
Rumors are already swirling as the February trade deadline approaches. The Knicks have a "war chest" of sorts—not in picks anymore, thanks to the Bridges trade—but in tradable salary and young assets like Miles McBride, who has had a breakout year.
They need a backup big. Period. Ariel Hukporti and Guerschon Yabusele have had their moments, but in a playoff series against Embiid or Giannis? That’s a nightmare waiting to happen.
🔗 Read more: Iowa vs Wisconsin 2024 Explained: Why the Heartland Trophy Stayed in Iowa City
Actionable Insights for the Second Half
If you’re betting on the Knicks or just trying to sound smart at the bar, keep an eye on these specific things:
- The 3-Point Percentage vs. Wins: The Knicks are 3rd in the league in offensive rating because they shoot nearly 40% as a team. When that drops below 35%, they almost always lose. They don’t have the defensive floor to win "ugly" games right now.
- Mikal Bridges’ Aggression: Watch his free throw attempts. He had 33 in his first 17 games but only seven in the 15 games after that. If he’s just settling for jumpers, the offense becomes predictable.
- Mitchell Robinson’s Return: His health is the single biggest factor for their playoff ceiling. If he can give them 15-20 minutes of elite rim protection, the defensive rating will climb back into the top 10.
- The Rotation Squeeze: Mike Brown is still tinkering. Watch how he uses Tyler Kolek and Landry Shamet. They need bench scoring to survive the minutes Brunson sits.
The New York Knicks are no longer the "lovable losers" or the "scrappy underdogs." They are a high-priced, high-expectation contender. The window is open right now, but it’s amazing how quickly a championship pursuit can turn into a "what if" season if the defense doesn't find its teeth before April.
What you can do now: * Monitor the injury reports for Jalen Brunson’s ankle; his mobility dictates the entire offensive flow.
- Watch the trade wire for a "true" backup center; Leon Rose is likely hunting for rim protection as we speak.
- Focus on the home-heavy schedule in late January to see if they can build enough cushion to survive their road struggles.