If you’ve spent any time watching the Knicks lately, you know the vibe at Madison Square Garden has shifted. It's no longer just about "grit" or "vibes." It's about a high-wire act of talent that, frankly, is still figuring itself out. As of mid-January 2026, the New York Knicks lineup is arguably the most talented collection of players this franchise has seen in decades, yet everyone seems to be arguing about how they actually fit together.
People see Jalen Brunson and Karl-Anthony Towns and think "instant title." But it’s not that simple. Honestly, the way Mike Brown—who took over the clipboard from Tom Thibodeau—is juggling these rotations is a lot more complex than just putting five stars on the floor and hoping for the best.
The Core Five: Who’s Actually Starting?
Right now, when everyone is healthy (which is a big "if" in New York), the starting unit is pretty terrifying on paper. You have Jalen Brunson at the point, Josh Hart and Mikal Bridges on the wings, OG Anunoby sliding between forward spots, and Karl-Anthony Towns anchoring the middle.
Wait. Did you catch that? Josh Hart is back in the starting lineup.
There was a whole saga earlier this season where Mike Brown tried to bring Hart off the bench to give the second unit some life. It didn't work. The team went 2-6 while Hart was sidelined or limited. Since he’s been back in the starting five, the flow is just... different. He’s averaging about 12.3 points and 8.0 rebounds, but those numbers don't tell the story of the random offensive rebounds or the cross-court passes that jumpstart the break.
Here is what the primary New York Knicks lineup looks like when the lights are brightest:
- Point Guard: Jalen Brunson (The Engine)
- Shooting Guard: Josh Hart (The Connector)
- Small Forward: Mikal Bridges (The Iron Man)
- Power Forward: OG Anunoby (The Lockdown Specialist)
- Center: Karl-Anthony Towns (The Floor Spacer)
Brunson is putting up MVP-caliber numbers—roughly 29.3 points and 6.5 assists per game. But he’s currently dealing with a nagging ankle injury that kept him out of the most recent clash with the Kings. When he’s out, the whole geometry of the floor changes.
📖 Related: Diogo Costa: Why the Portugal National Team Goalkeeper Is Basically Unstoppable
The KAT Problem (And Solution)
The biggest misconception about this version of the Knicks is that Karl-Anthony Towns is just a "big man." In this system, he’s basically a giant shooting guard who happens to grab 11 rebounds a night.
Critics like Kendrick Perkins have been loud about the Knicks "misusing" KAT, but the reality is that his gravity opens everything up for Brunson. When Towns stands at the three-point line, the opposing center has to go with him. That leaves the paint wide open for Brunson to do his mid-range dance.
However, defense is where it gets shaky. The Knicks are currently 27th in the league in perimeter defense, giving up nearly 15 triples a game. Towns is a gifted offensive player, but he isn't Mitchell Robinson when it comes to erasing mistakes at the rim. Speaking of Robinson, he’s been coming off the bench lately, providing a much-needed defensive punch, though he’s also fighting an ankle issue right now.
Why the Bench is the Secret Weapon
For years, the Knicks' bench was where leads went to die. Not anymore.
Leon Rose went out and got Jordan Clarkson to be the "microwave." He’s giving them about 10 points a night in just 20 minutes of action. Then you have "Deuce" McBride. If you’ve been at the Garden, you’ve heard the "DEUCEEEEE" chants. He’s shooting a ridiculous 44% from three.
The rotation usually looks like this:
✨ Don't miss: Al Qadsiah Football Club: Why Everyone Is Suddenly Talking About Saudi Arabia’s Newest Powerhouse
- Miles McBride: First guard off the bench, usually replaces Hart or Brunson.
- Jordan Clarkson: Pure scoring spark.
- Mitchell Robinson: The defensive specialist (when healthy).
- Guerschon Yabusele: The "Dancing Bear" provides some muscle at the 4.
- Tyler Kolek: The rookie point guard who has seen more minutes lately with Brunson's injury.
It’s a deeper team than the one that ran out of gas in the playoffs last year. Mike Brown is much more willing to go 10 deep than Thibodeau ever was. This keeps the "Villanova Boys" (Brunson, Hart, Bridges) from playing 45 minutes a night and hitting a wall by April.
What Most People Get Wrong
The biggest mistake fans make is looking at the New York Knicks lineup and assuming OG Anunoby is just a "3-and-D" guy.
He’s actually becoming a legitimate third scoring option. Before his hamstring injury in December, he was averaging nearly 16 points a game. His ability to cut to the rim while defenders are worried about KAT and Brunson is a cheat code. The Knicks are significantly better defensively when OG is on the floor—his defensive rating is one of the few bright spots on that end of the ball.
Another thing? The "Villanova Connection" isn't just a marketing gimmick. The chemistry between Brunson, Bridges, and Hart is real. They rotate without looking. They know exactly where each other will be on the break. You can’t coach that; you can only build it over years of playing together.
The Injury Factor
We have to talk about the elephant in the room. The Knicks' injury report looks like a CVS receipt right now.
Jalen Brunson's ankle, Mitchell Robinson's ankle, and Landry Shamet's shoulder are all concerns as of mid-January. This is why the New York Knicks lineup feels so inconsistent. Just when they get a rhythm, someone goes down.
When Brunson is out, KAT’s usage rate jumps by over 4%. He becomes the focal point, averaging nearly 34 points in games where Brunson sits. It’s a different style of basketball—slower, more post-up heavy—and while it can win games, it’s not the championship-level "Blender" offense they want to run.
📖 Related: Why Hey Chicago What Do You Say Is Still the Ultimate Victory Anthem
Actionable Insights for Fans and Bettors
If you’re tracking this team or looking at the rotations for fantasy or betting, keep these three things in mind:
- Watch the Hart Minutes: If Josh Hart plays more than 35 minutes, the Knicks almost always win. His energy is the barometer for the entire roster.
- The KAT Usage Trap: Don't assume the Knicks will struggle to score without Brunson. KAT becomes a monster when he’s the primary option, though the team's overall win probability drops because they lose Brunson's late-game poise.
- Corner Three Vulnerability: Since the Knicks struggle with perimeter defense (ranked 27th), keep an eye on opposing shooting guards. If the Knicks are playing a team with elite spacers, the lineup struggles to recover on the wings.
The New York Knicks lineup is a work in progress, but the ceiling is undeniably high. They have the scoring, they have the spacing, and they have the "glue guys." Now they just need to stay healthy long enough to prove the skeptics wrong.
To stay ahead of the next roster move, keep a close eye on the minutes for Tyler Kolek. If the coaching staff continues to trust the rookie during Brunson’s recovery, it might signal a shift in how they view their backcourt depth heading into the trade deadline. Also, watch the defensive rotations between KAT and Mitchell Robinson; if Mike Brown starts closing games with Robinson for defensive stops, it changes the entire offensive spacing in crunch time.