The New York Giants are a weird franchise. Honestly, if you look at the 100-year timeline of this team, it’s not a steady climb of greatness. It’s more like a series of long, dark tunnels interrupted by sudden, blinding flashes of light. Most of that light? It comes from the guys under center. But when you look at New York Giants QB history, the names people remember aren't always the ones who were actually the most talented.
Fans love to argue about Eli Manning. They debate Phil Simms’ Hall of Fame credentials. Yet, they often forget the guy who basically invented the modern rookie season or the Hall of Famer who played his best football while bleeding through his jersey. It’s a messy history. It’s glorious, frustrating, and occasionally downright hilarious in a "why did he just throw that?" kind of way.
The Early Days: Charlie Conerly and the 1950s Glory
Before the Super Bowl era, there was Charlie Conerly. If you think Joe Namath was the first "celebrity" QB in New York, you're wrong. Conerly was "The Marlboro Man." Seriously. He was a rugged, handsome guy from Mississippi who took over the city in the late 40s and 50s.
Conerly’s 1948 season was ridiculous. As a rookie, he threw 22 touchdowns in just 12 games. To put that in perspective, that’s a pace of about 31 touchdowns in today’s 17-game schedule. For 1948, that was like seeing a spaceship land in the middle of a cow pasture. He led the Giants to the 1956 NFL Championship, a 47-7 blowout of the Bears.
But here’s the kicker: Conerly is the guy many experts, including those at the Pro Football Hall of Fame, consider the best Giant not in Canton. He finished with 173 career touchdowns. He was only 14 scores away from the all-time record when he retired. If he hadn't spent three years fighting in World War II, he probably would have retired as the most prolific passer in the history of the sport.
The Y.A. Tittle Era: Blood and Brilliance
Then came Y.A. Tittle. The Giants traded for him in 1961 when he was 34. Most people thought he was washed up. Instead, he had arguably the greatest three-year run any quarterback has ever had in a Giants uniform.
In 1963, Tittle threw 36 touchdowns. That record stood for over 50 years. He was the NFL MVP. He was a bald, tough-as-nails leader who led the team to three straight title games. But he never won the big one.
📖 Related: NFL Football Teams in Order: Why Most Fans Get the Hierarchy Wrong
You’ve probably seen the photo. It’s the one where Tittle is kneeling on the turf, helmet off, blood dripping down his face after an interception against Pittsburgh in 1964. That image defined the end of an era. The Giants fell into a 15-year pit of despair shortly after.
The Dark Ages and "The Fumble"
You can’t talk about New York Giants QB history without mentioning the 1970s. It was brutal. The team was a revolving door of mediocrity.
Fran Tarkenton was there for five years (1967-1971). He was amazing, but the team around him was garbage. He made five Pro Bowls in New York, yet they never made the playoffs. Then he went back to Minnesota and started winning. Typical Giants.
The absolute bottom was November 19, 1978. Joe Pisarcik. "The Miracle at the Meadowlands." All the Giants had to do was kneel. The Eagles had no timeouts. Instead, offensive coordinator Bob Gibson (who called plays from the booth and didn't trust Pisarcik to breathe without permission) ordered a handoff to Larry Csonka.
Pisarcik botched it. Herm Edwards picked it up and ran it back for a touchdown. Giants fans just call it "The Fumble." It was so bad it led to the firing of the entire front office and the hiring of George Young, which eventually gave us Bill Parcells and Phil Simms.
Phil Simms: The Kentucky Kid Who Wouldn't Quit
Phil Simms didn't have it easy. He was the first draft pick of the George Young era in 1979, coming from tiny Morehead State. Fans booed the pick. He spent the first few years of his career constantly injured or benched.
👉 See also: Why Your 1 Arm Pull Up Progression Isn't Working (And How to Fix It)
By 1984, he finally stuck. Simms wasn't just a "game manager." In 1985, he threw for 513 yards in a single game against Cincinnati. He had a massive arm and zero fear.
His crowning moment, obviously, was Super Bowl XXI. He went 22-of-25. That’s an 88% completion rate. In a Super Bowl! It’s still one of the most efficient postseason games ever played. He finished his career with 33,462 yards and 199 touchdowns. He would have had way more if Parcells didn't love running the ball so much.
The Eli Manning Paradox
Now we get to the big one. Eli.
If you just look at the stats, Eli Manning is a Hall of Famer. He’s top 10 in almost every major passing category. He has two Super Bowl MVPs. He never missed a game due to injury. He started 210 consecutive games.
But if you watched him every Sunday? It was a roller coaster. He led the league in interceptions three different times. He’d look like the best player on earth for three weeks and then throw four picks against the Vikings for no reason.
The 2007 and 2011 playoff runs were magic. In 2011, he set the NFL record with 15 fourth-quarter touchdown passes. He carried a defense that ranked 25th in the league all the way to a ring. That’s the nuance people miss. Eli wasn't just "lucky" to have a defense; in 2011, he was the team.
✨ Don't miss: El Salvador partido de hoy: Why La Selecta is at a Critical Turning Point
He finished with:
- 57,023 passing yards (Franchise leader)
- 366 touchdowns (Franchise leader)
- 8-4 playoff record
- Two wins over Tom Brady in the Super Bowl
That last point usually ends any argument in a New York bar.
The Post-Eli Struggle: Daniel Jones and Beyond
Following a legend is hard. Daniel Jones had the "Danny Dimes" nickname for about a month before reality set in. He had the wheels—he could run like the wind—but the turnovers and the lack of a supporting cast turned his tenure into a "what if" story.
Jones showed flashes. The 2022 season was great. He led them to a playoff win in Minnesota and earned a $160 million contract. But the injuries caught up, and the consistency never arrived. By 2024, the Giants were ready to move on.
As of 2025, the team turned to youth with Jaxson Dart, while mixing in veterans like Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston to keep the seat warm. It’s the same cycle we’ve seen for a century. Hope, followed by a bit of chaos.
Actionable Insights for Giants Fans
If you're trying to settle a debate about the greatest Giants QB, keep these things in mind:
- Don't ignore the era. Charlie Conerly's 173 touchdowns in the 50s are arguably more impressive than Daniel Jones' stats because the ball was like a watermelon and defenders were allowed to clothesline receivers.
- Context matters for Eli. His .500 regular-season record (117-117) looks mediocre, but he played on some truly talent-depleted rosters toward the end of his career.
- The "Peak" Winner. If you want the highest peak, it's Y.A. Tittle (1961-1963). If you want the best "Big Game" performer, it's Simms or Eli.
- Watch the tape. Stats don't show how Simms stood in the pocket while getting hit by LT in practice or how Eli navigated the New York media for 16 years without ever losing his cool.
The next time someone says the Giants haven't had good quarterbacks, remind them that this team has four Super Bowl trophies. Those weren't won by accident. They were won by guys who could handle the toughest media market in the world without blinking.