If you were hanging around the Mercer Arts Center in 1972, you probably didn't think you were watching the architects of the next thirty years of rock and roll. Honestly, you probably just thought you were watching five guys in thrift-store heels who were about to trip over their own guitar cables. But that was the magic. New York Dolls songs weren't just music; they were a frantic, lipstick-smeared middle finger to the self-serious "virtuosity" of the early seventies.
They were sloppy. They were loud. They were often out of tune.
And yet, without them, we don't get the Sex Pistols, the Ramones, or the entire hair metal explosion of the eighties. David Johansen, Johnny Thunders, Sylvain Sylvain, Arthur Kane, and Billy Murcia (later Jerry Nolan) took the bones of Chuck Berry and the girl-group melodies of the Shangri-Las, threw them in a blender with a handful of downers, and created a sound that felt like a brick through a window.
The Hits That Weren’t: Breaking Down the Essentials
It's kind of wild to realize that the Dolls only released two studio albums in their original run: New York Dolls (1973) and Too Much Too Soon (1974). They didn't sell well. Like, at all. But the influence of these specific tracks is immeasurable.
Personality Crisis
This is the big one. If you’ve heard one Dolls song, it’s this. Produced by Todd Rundgren—who reportedly had a "lukewarm" opinion of the band’s technical skills—it opens with a piano bang and a scream that sounds like Johansen is being electrocuted.
The lyrics are basically a snapshot of a nervous breakdown in a city that doesn't care. It’s got that "prima ballerina" line that everyone quotes, and Thunders' guitar work is pure, unadulterated filth. It’s the closest thing they ever had to a hit, and even then, it only barely scratched the consciousness of the mainstream.
✨ Don't miss: Elaine Cassidy Movies and TV Shows: Why This Irish Icon Is Still Everywhere
Trash
The double A-side to "Personality Crisis," this song is basically the band’s mission statement. It’s a love song, sort of, but it’s mostly about the grit of the Lower East Side. The "How do you call your lover to you?" refrain is a direct nod to fifties R&B, proving these guys were actually deep-rooted music nerds under all that mascara.
Looking for a Kiss
Talk about a song that captures a mood. This is a track about being bored, being high, and being desperate for a human connection in a "lonely planet" kind of way. It’s got a swagger that most bands would kill for. You can hear the exact moment where the New York Dolls songs stopped being just rock and roll and started being "proto-punk."
Jet Boy
The closer of the first album. It’s a six-minute epic (by their standards) that features some of Johnny Thunders’ most iconic riffage. It’s chaotic. It’s repetitive. It’s perfect.
Why the Songwriting Actually Mattered
People love to talk about the clothes. They talk about the drag, the platform boots, and the "trash" aesthetic. But if the songs were bad, the legend wouldn't have survived the seventies.
David Johansen and Johnny Thunders were the primary writers, and they had a weirdly sophisticated sense of melody. They weren't trying to be "progressive." They were trying to be catchy. They understood that a great rock song needs a hook you can scream while you're drunk.
🔗 Read more: Ebonie Smith Movies and TV Shows: The Child Star Who Actually Made It Out Okay
The Influence of the Brill Building
You wouldn't think a bunch of junkies in heels would care about 1960s pop, but they did. Songs like "Pills" (a Bo Diddley cover they made their own) and "Stranded in the Jungle" show their obsession with the past. They took the "innocence" of early rock and roll and corrupted it.
The Second Album Slump (Or Was It?)
Too Much Too Soon gets a bad rap sometimes. Sure, it’s heavy on covers, but tracks like "Babylon" and "Human Being" are essential. "Human Being" in particular is a defiant anthem. It’s the band saying, "We might be a mess, but we're real." It’s five minutes of screaming guitar and Johansen demanding respect for his own humanity. It’s heavy stuff for a band that most critics dismissed as a "fag act" at the time.
The Tragedy Behind the Tracks
You can't talk about New York Dolls songs without talking about the casualties. Billy Murcia died on their first UK tour before the first album was even out. He drowned in a bathtub after a party, a victim of the "too much too soon" lifestyle the band sang about.
Then you have Johnny Thunders and Jerry Nolan, both of whom succumbed to the long-term effects of their lifestyles in the early nineties. There's a persistent sadness underneath the party-vibe of their music. When you listen to a song like "Lonely Planet Boy," you’re not hearing a rock star; you’re hearing a kid who’s genuinely lost.
The 2000s Resurrection
Against all odds, the Dolls returned in 2004. Morrissey (a massive fan) convinced the surviving members—Johansen, Sylvain, and Kane—to play the Meltdown Festival. Arthur Kane died just weeks after that reunion, but Johansen and Sylvain kept the flame alive for three more albums.
💡 You might also like: Eazy-E: The Business Genius and Street Legend Most People Get Wrong
- One Day It Will Please Us to Remember Even This (2006)
- Cause I Sez So (2009)
- Dancing Backward in High Heels (2011)
Are they as "important" as the first two? Maybe not. But songs like "Dance Like a Monkey" and "We’re All in Love" proved they could still write a hook. They sounded cleaner, sure, but the spirit was still there.
Actionable Insights for the Modern Listener
If you’re just getting into the Dolls, don't just put them on in the background. This music demands your attention, mostly because it’s constantly trying to fall apart.
- Listen for the "Space": Notice how Johnny Thunders and Sylvain Sylvain's guitars interact. They aren't playing in perfect unison; they’re fighting each other. That’s the "Dolls sound."
- Trace the DNA: Listen to "Personality Crisis" and then listen to the Sex Pistols' "Holidays in the Sun." The lineage is direct.
- Check the Lyrics: Ignore the noise for a second and read David Johansen’s lyrics. He was a brilliant street poet who captured a very specific era of New York City that doesn't exist anymore.
The New York Dolls were never going to be the biggest band in the world. They were too messy for the radio and too weird for the suburbs. But their songs remain some of the most vital, exciting, and "human" recordings in the history of rock. They taught an entire generation that you didn't need to be a virtuoso to be a legend; you just needed a good riff and the guts to wear your girlfriend's blouse on stage.
To truly appreciate the New York Dolls, start by listening to the original 1973 self-titled debut from start to finish. Avoid the "remastered" versions that try to clean up the mud; the mud is where the soul lives. Once you've internalized that chaos, seek out the Lipstick Killers demos to hear how these songs sounded before a professional producer tried to tame them. Finally, watch the 2005 documentary New York Doll to understand the heartbreaking humanity of bassist Arthur Kane, which adds a completely new layer of depth to the music.