So, the Phillies are back at it again. Just when you think Dave Dombrowski might actually take a breath after re-signing Kyle Schwarber to that massive five-year deal, he goes out and renovates the entire pitching staff. If you've been following the news this week, it's clear the front office isn't just looking for "arms"—they're looking for a very specific type of stability.
Honestly, the new pitcher for Phillies conversation isn't just about one guy anymore. It's about a total shift in how this team handles the late innings and the back of the rotation.
Between the high-stakes signing of Brad Keller and the recent trade for Chase Shugart, the 2026 Phillies are looking a lot different than the squad that slumped out of the NLDS against the Dodgers last October. We need to talk about why these specific moves happened now, because the logic behind them is actually pretty fascinating once you look past the radar gun readings.
The Brad Keller Bet: $22 Million for a Career Renaissance
Let’s start with the big one. The Phillies handed Brad Keller a two-year, $22 million contract, and for a minute, half of Twitter was scratching their heads. Why? Because we remember the Kansas City version of Keller who occasionally struggled with command.
But forget that guy.
The Keller the Phillies just bought is the one who reinvented himself with the Chicago Cubs in 2025. We’re talking about a guy who posted a career-low 2.07 ERA. He wasn’t just "getting lucky" either. His strikeout rate jumped to 9.7 per nine innings. That’s elite territory.
🔗 Read more: Texas vs Oklahoma Football Game: Why the Red River Rivalry is Getting Even Weirder
The Phillies are basically betting $11 million a year that Keller’s transformation is the real deal. In a rotation that already features Zack Wheeler and Aaron Nola, having a guy like Keller—who can start or provide "heavy" relief—is a massive luxury. It’s also worth noting that Keller is already so locked into his new form that he’s committed to pitching for Team USA in the 2026 World Baseball Classic.
Who is Chase Shugart and Why Did the Phillies Trade for Him?
While everyone was obsessing over the Bo Bichette rumors this week, the Phillies quietly pulled off a trade with the Pirates for Chase Shugart. On paper, it looks like a minor move. They sent 18-year-old prospect Francisco Loreto to Pittsburgh to get him.
But look closer.
Shugart is 29 years old and coming off a really solid 2025 where he put up a 3.40 ERA in 35 appearances. He’s not a "strikeout-the-side" flamethrower—he only averaged 6.2 K/9—but he’s a pitch-mover. He uses five different pitches, including two fastballs that sit in the mid-90s and a sweeper that can be absolute filth when it’s on.
Dombrowski has a history of finding these "Red Sox factory" guys (Shugart was originally a Boston draft pick) and turning them into reliable middle-relief bridges. With one minor league option remaining, Shugart gives the Phillies the one thing they lacked last year: roster flexibility.
💡 You might also like: How to watch vikings game online free without the usual headache
The Rotation Reality: Life Without Ranger Suárez
We have to address the elephant in the room. This offseason feels different because for the first time in a long time, Ranger Suárez isn’t the safety net.
Suárez hit free agency and, according to recent reports, is heading to Boston on a massive $130 million contract. That hurts. It changes the entire chemistry of the rotation. You can't just "replace" a guy who induces a 55% ground ball rate and remains cool as an ice cube in the postseason.
Because of that gap, the Phillies are leaning harder on Jesús Luzardo, who just signed a one-year, $11 million deal to avoid arbitration. He’s the projected number four starter, and honestly, he might be the most important pitcher on the staff this year. If Luzardo can stay healthy and Keller performs like he did in Chicago, the Phillies might actually survive the loss of Ranger.
The Current 2026 Projected Rotation
- Zack Wheeler: The undisputed ace (though he's currently rehabbing a shoulder issue).
- Cristopher Sánchez: Last year’s Cy Young runner-up and now a foundational piece.
- Aaron Nola: The veteran workhorse who needs to find more consistency with his curveball.
- Jesús Luzardo: The high-upside lefty looking to prove he’s an anchor.
- Andrew Painter: The kid. The phenom. The guy everyone is waiting for in Spring Training.
Why the Bullpen Overhaul Matters
If you watched the 2025 playoffs, you know the bullpen was a bit of a rollercoaster. That's why the list of new pitchers for the Phillies is so long this winter. It’s not just Keller and Shugart.
The team also brought in:
📖 Related: Liechtenstein National Football Team: Why Their Struggles are Different Than You Think
- Jonathan Bowlan: Acquired in the Matt Strahm trade.
- Kyle Backhus: A lefty depth arm from Arizona.
- Zach Pop: Signed to a one-year deal to add more sinker-ball depth.
- Zach McCambley: A Rule 5 pick who could be a wild card.
Basically, the Phillies are creates a "Thunderdome" situation in Clearwater. They’ve signed or traded for about six different guys who are all fighting for the final two or three spots in the pen.
The Lucas Giolito Rumors
One more thing to keep an eye on: the Phillies aren't necessarily done. Lucas Giolito is still sitting out there in free agency, and several insiders have linked him to Philadelphia.
Giolito is 6-foot-6 and just had a massive bounce-back year in Boston. If the Phillies find out that Zack Wheeler’s shoulder rehab is going slower than expected, don't be surprised if they pivot and drop another big contract on Giolito. It would be a very "Dombrowski" move to double-down on veteran starters right before pitchers and catchers report.
Actionable Insights for Phillies Fans
If you're trying to figure out what all these transactions actually mean for the 2026 season, here’s the reality of the situation:
- Watch the Spring Training Battle: The bullpen isn't set. Guys like Chase Shugart and Zach Pop are going to have to outpitch the younger prospects to keep their spots. Every inning in March matters this year.
- Monitor Zack Wheeler’s Velocity: His shoulder is the "X-factor." If his velocity is down in Clearwater, the Phillies will almost certainly sign another veteran starter like Giolito or Framber Valdez.
- Temper Expectations for Andrew Painter: He’s the future, but the Phillies have enough depth now with Keller and Luzardo that they don't have to rush him. He might start the year in Triple-A just to manage his innings.
- Don't Panic About the Lefty Gap: Yes, losing Ranger Suárez sucks. But Luzardo and Cristopher Sánchez are both lefties who have proven they can dominate elite lineups.
The Phillies are clearly tired of "almost" winning. By flooding the roster with guys like Keller and Shugart, they’re trying to ensure that when the playoffs hit, they aren't relying on tired arms or unproven rookies. It’s a gamble on veteran stability, and we’ll see if it pays off when Opening Day hits on March 26.