Honestly, if you were watching the New England Patriots vs Atlanta Falcons Super Bowl back in 2017 and didn’t turn the TV off by the third quarter, you’re either a die-hard Pats fan or a masochist. Most people remember the meme. 28-3. It’s basically shorthand for the most improbable collapse in sports history. But when you actually dig into the play-by-play, it wasn't just a "choke job." It was a weird, mathematical perfect storm where everything that could go wrong for Atlanta did, and every coin flip of a play went New England’s way.
The Falcons weren't just winning; they were embarrassing the dynasty.
At one point, ESPN’s win probability tracker had the Falcons at a 99.6% chance to win. You’ve got a better chance of being struck by lightning while winning the lottery than the Patriots had of winning that game. And yet, here we are, still talking about it years later because it fundamentally broke the way we think about football leads.
The First Half Massacre
The first quarter was actually a scoreless defensive stalemate. Boring, right? Then the second quarter hit like a freight train. Devonta Freeman sliced through the line for a touchdown. Austin Hooper caught a 19-yard heater from Matt Ryan. Before Bill Belichick could even adjust his hoodie, it was 14-0.
Then came the "oh no" moment for New England. Tom Brady, looking human for once, threw a pass toward Danny Amendola that Robert Alford stepped in front of. Alford didn't just pick it off; he took it 82 yards to the house.
21-0.
✨ Don't miss: What Place Is The Phillies In: The Real Story Behind the NL East Standings
The Patriots managed a measly field goal before the half, but the vibe was "funeral." Lady Gaga jumped off the roof of the stadium for the halftime show, which was honestly the most life anyone saw in NRG Stadium for about two hours. When the Falcons came back out and Tevin Coleman caught a touchdown to make it 28-3 with 8:31 left in the third, the stadium started emptying.
Why New England Patriots vs Atlanta Falcons Super Bowl Changed Everything
We have to talk about the "math" of the comeback. To make up a 25-point deficit in roughly 17 minutes of game time, you don't just need to play well. You need the other team to stop the clock for you.
Atlanta’s offensive coordinator at the time, Kyle Shanahan, has taken a lot of heat for this. The Falcons kept passing. If they had just run the ball three times and kicked a field goal on their late fourth-quarter drive, the game is over. Instead, they took a sack, got a holding penalty, and pushed themselves out of field goal range. It was a massive strategic blunder that basically handed the keys back to Brady.
The Turning Points You Forgot
Everyone talks about the Edelman catch, but a few other things had to happen:
- The Dont'a Hightower Strip Sack: This was the spark. Matt Ryan got blindsided, the ball popped loose, and New England recovered at the Atlanta 25. If Ryan gets that pass off, the Falcons likely score and end the comeback right there.
- The Two-Point Conversions: New England didn't just need touchdowns; they needed two-point conversions. They went 2-for-2 on those. That is statistically ridiculous under that kind of pressure.
- James White’s God-Mode: While Brady got the MVP, James White was the engine. He set a Super Bowl record with 14 receptions. He scored three touchdowns and a two-point conversion. He was basically unguardable in the flat.
That Julian Edelman Catch
You know the one. Brady throws a ball into triple coverage. It gets tipped by Robert Alford (who almost had his second pick of the night). The ball tumbles toward the turf, hits a shoe, bounces off an arm, and somehow Julian Edelman traps it an inch above the grass.
🔗 Read more: Huskers vs Michigan State: What Most People Get Wrong About This Big Ten Rivalry
I’ve watched the replay fifty times. It still doesn't look real.
That play moved the ball to the Atlanta 41-yard line and kept the momentum from stalling. It felt like destiny. At that point, the Falcons players looked like they were seeing ghosts. You could see it in their eyes on the sidelines—they knew what was coming.
Overtime and the Final Blow
When the game ended 28-28 in regulation, it was the first time a Super Bowl ever went to overtime. The Patriots won the toss. In the NFL's overtime rules at the time (and still for the most part), if the first team scores a touchdown, it’s over.
The Falcons' defense was gassed. They had played 93 snaps compared to Atlanta's 46. Their legs were gone. Brady marched them 75 yards like it was a 7-on-7 drill. James White tossed himself into the end zone on a 2-yard toss, and that was it. 34-28.
The greatest comeback. The greatest choke. The greatest game. Take your pick.
💡 You might also like: NFL Fantasy Pick Em: Why Most Fans Lose Money and How to Actually Win
What We Learned From the Stats
The box score for the New England Patriots vs Atlanta Falcons Super Bowl is a work of fiction.
- Tom Brady: 466 passing yards (a record at the time).
- Matt Ryan: A nearly perfect passer rating of 144.1... and he still lost.
- First Downs: New England had 37; Atlanta had 17.
It’s a reminder that efficiency is great, but volume and "not making the catastrophic mistake" win championships. Atlanta was the more explosive team for 40 minutes, but New England was the more relentless team for 60.
Actionable Takeaways for Football Fans
If you're looking back at this game to understand modern NFL strategy, there are three things to watch:
- Clock Management is King: Atlanta lost because they didn't force the Patriots to use their timeouts. When you have a lead, make the clock your friend.
- The "Running Back as Receiver" Meta: This game proved that a versatile back like James White is more dangerous than a deep-threat WR in the clutch. Short, high-percentage throws move the chains and tire out a defense.
- Conditioning Matters: The Falcons' defense collapsed because they couldn't get off the field. New England’s "no-huddle" offense in the fourth quarter was specifically designed to exploit tired defenders who couldn't substitute.
Check out the full highlights if you have a chance—even knowing the ending, the tension of those final eight minutes in the fourth quarter is unmatched in professional sports.
Next time you see a team down by three scores, just remember: it’s never over until the clock hits zero, especially if the guy wearing number 12 is on the other sideline.