You’ve seen the "grumpy detective" trope a thousand times before. Usually, there's a guy in a trench coat, a drinking problem, and a messy divorce. But the upcoming Dept Q Netflix series isn't just another rehash of Broadchurch or The Killing. It’s based on the massive "Department Q" novels by Danish author Jussi Adler-Olsen, and if you haven't read them, you're in for something remarkably dark. This isn't cozy mystery territory. It’s gritty. It’s claustrophobic. Honestly, it's kinda gross in all the right ways for a crime junkie.
Scott Frank is running the show. If that name sounds familiar, it should. He’s the mind behind The Queen’s Gambit and Godless. He has this specific knack for taking dense source material and making it feel incredibly cinematic without losing the soul of the characters. By moving the setting from Copenhagen to Edinburgh, Scotland, Netflix is making a bold play. Some purists might hate it. I think it’s a stroke of genius because the misty, grey Scottish landscape mirrors the bleakness of the original books perfectly.
What Actually Is Department Q?
Basically, it's the basement. Carl Mørck is a detective who used to be a star but, after a traumatic shootout that left one partner dead and another paralyzed, he’s... well, he’s a wreck. His bosses want him out of the way. So, they stick him in a basement office to head up a new department called "Department Q." The goal? To look through old, unsolved cases to make the police force look like they're doing something. It’s supposed to be busy work. They didn't expect him to actually start solving them.
Matthew Goode is playing Carl. This is great casting. Goode has this ability to look incredibly refined one second and like he hasn't slept in three weeks the next. In the Dept Q Netflix series, he’s joined by Alex Ejuwon-Logbo as Akram and Kelly Macdonald as Dr. Rachel Kondrake. The dynamic between Carl and his assistant is the heartbeat of the whole thing. In the books, Assad (Akram in this version) is the one who actually keeps Carl from spiraling into total nihilism.
The cases aren't your standard "whoops, someone stole the jewels" stuff. We're talking about people kept in pressure chambers for years. We're talking about cults and decades-long conspiracies. It's heavy.
Why the Edinburgh Move Matters
Moving the story to Scotland isn't just about tax breaks or filming locations. There’s a specific "Nordic Noir" vibe that translates effortlessly to "Scottish Noir." Think about the cobblestones, the constant drizzle, and that heavy, Victorian architecture. It provides a sense of history that a modern American city just wouldn't have.
The Dept Q Netflix series is leaning into the isolation. Edinburgh can feel like a very small town despite being a capital city. When you're digging into cold cases from twenty years ago, that small-town claustrophobia is a powerful tool for a writer. Everyone knows everyone. Everyone has a secret they’ve been sitting on since the 90s.
Breaking Down the Source Material
If you want to understand where this show is going, you have to look at the books. Jussi Adler-Olsen didn't just write one-offs. He wrote a sprawling narrative.
- The Keeper of Lost Causes: The first big one. A politician disappears from a ferry. Everyone thinks she jumped. She didn't.
- The Absent One: This one deals with elite boarding schools and the kind of people who think they’re above the law.
- A Conspiracy of Faith: A message in a bottle written in blood. Yeah, it gets that intense.
The show is likely going to weave these together. Instead of a "case of the week" format, expect a serialized deep dive. Scott Frank has already proven with The Queen’s Gambit that he prefers the "long movie" approach to television. You’ll probably want to binge the whole thing in one Saturday.
The Cast Breakdown
Honestly, the chemistry is going to make or break this. Matthew Goode is the anchor. But Kelly Macdonald is the secret weapon. She’s been a staple of high-quality drama for years—everything from Trainspotting to Line of Duty. Playing a therapist (Dr. Kondrake) gives her a reason to poke at Carl’s psyche, which is exactly what the audience wants to see.
Then you have Leah Byrne as Rose. In the books, Rose is... complicated. She has multiple personalities (or at least very distinct "modes"), and she’s arguably smarter than Carl. If the Dept Q Netflix series keeps her character's edge, she’ll be a fan favorite. She’s the one who actually does the grunt work while Carl mopes and smokes.
Dealing with the "Scandi-Noir" Fatigue
Let's be real. There are a lot of detective shows on Netflix. A lot. You’ve got The Chestnut Man, Valhalla Murders, and Bordertown. Why should you care about this one?
Because it’s not just about the gloom. There’s a weird, dark humor in Department Q. It’s that "if I don't laugh, I'll scream" kind of vibe that people in high-stress jobs actually have. It feels more authentic than the stoic, humorless detectives we usually see. Carl Mørck is annoying. He’s rude. He’s lazy when he wants to be. He’s a real person, not a superhero with a badge.
👉 See also: Calvin Harris Sweet Nothing Lyrics: Why We All Misunderstood That 2012 Banger
The Dept Q Netflix series also benefits from a massive budget. Netflix isn't playing around here. They’ve seen the success of international crime dramas and they’re betting big on this being their next "prestige" hit.
What to Expect from Season 1
Rumor has it the first season will focus heavily on the disappearance of a high-profile figure, much like the first book. But they are updating the timeline. The books started in the mid-2000s. The show is firmly set in the present day. This changes the forensics. It changes how people communicate. But it doesn't change the fact that people are capable of doing horrible things to one another.
- Atmosphere: Expect lots of low-key lighting. If you can see the corners of the room, they aren't doing it right.
- Pacing: It’ll start slow. Cold cases are cold for a reason. You have to watch the characters scrape away the ice.
- Violence: It’s not senseless, but it is impactful. When something happens, you’ll feel it.
The Verdict on the Adaptation
Is it going to be better than the Danish films? That’s the big question. There is already a series of very successful Danish movies starring Nikolaj Lie Kaas. They are excellent. If you haven't seen them, go find them. They set a very high bar for the Dept Q Netflix series.
However, a TV series has more room to breathe. A movie has to cut the subplots. A eight-episode season can explore Carl’s home life—his weird relationship with his ex-wife and his teenage stepson. It can show the slow-burn friendship between him and Akram. That’s where the real gold is.
Actionable Insights for Fans
If you're planning on watching, here is how to get the most out of it.
First, don't read the spoilers for the books. The twists in the Department Q series are genuinely shocking. One of the major reveals in the first "case" is something I haven't seen replicated in any other crime fiction.
Second, pay attention to the background characters. Adler-Olsen is famous for planting seeds that don't sprout until three books later. Scott Frank is a fan of this kind of long-form storytelling, so expect "Easter eggs" that might seem insignificant now but will blow your mind in Season 2 or 3.
Finally, watch it with the subtitles on. Even if it's in English, the Scottish accents combined with the technical police jargon can be a bit much if you’re not used to it. Plus, you don't want to miss the dry, biting insults Carl throws at his superiors.
Next Steps for the True Crime Fan
- Read the first book: "The Keeper of Lost Causes" (also known as Mercy in the UK). It gives you the internal monologue of the victim, which the show might struggle to portray as deeply.
- Watch the Danish films: Search for Kvinden i buret. It’ll give you a baseline for the atmosphere.
- Follow the production: Keep an eye on the official Netflix "Tudum" site for behind-the-scenes clips of the Edinburgh set. The production design is reportedly top-tier.
- Check out Scott Frank’s previous work: If you haven't seen A Walk Among the Tombstones, watch it. It’s the closest thing to the tone he’s bringing to this project.
The Dept Q Netflix series has all the ingredients to be a massive hit. Great lead actor. Proven showrunner. Incredible source material. It’s just a matter of whether they can maintain that delicate balance between depressing realism and "just one more episode" entertainment. Based on the talent involved, I'm betting they will.