You probably saw the headline pop up during the final stretch of the 2024 presidential campaign. It was everywhere for a minute. Kamala Harris made a surprise appearance on Saturday Night Live, and suddenly, the internet was screaming about the NBC equal time notice. People were confused. Was it a fine? Was NBC in trouble? Not really. It was basically a regulatory paperwork drill that highlights how weirdly old-school our broadcast laws still are.
Broadcasting isn't the Wild West. At least, not the kind you see on over-the-air TV.
If you own a TV station, you’re using public airwaves. The government, specifically the FCC, decided decades ago that because those airwaves are limited, you can't just use them to tip the scales for one politician while ignoring the other. That’s the core of the Equal Opportunities rule, often called the "Equal Time" rule. When NBC gave Harris ninety seconds of screen time right before an election, they triggered a massive compliance headache that resulted in that famous notice.
The Saturday Night Live Incident That Triggered the FCC
Let’s get into the weeds. It’s November 2, 2024. Kamala Harris appears in a "mirror image" sketch with Maya Rudolph. It was charming, it was short, and it was a massive legal flag.
Brendan Carr, an FCC Commissioner, immediately took to X (formerly Twitter) to call it out. He argued this was a clear attempt to evade the rules. Why? Because the rule says if a station gives free time to one candidate, they have to offer the same deal to all other "legally qualified" candidates. NBC didn't pre-announce the cameo to the Trump campaign. They just did it.
The fallout was fast.
To cover their tracks and stay within the lines of the law, NBC filed an official NBC equal time notice with the FCC. This wasn't a confession of a crime. It was a public acknowledgment. They were essentially saying, "Hey, we gave Candidate A this much time. If Candidate B wants it, the clock is ticking."
But here is the kicker: the "equal time" doesn't have to be on the same show. Donald Trump didn't get to go on SNL the next week. Instead, NBC gave him a 60-second spot during a NASCAR race and Sunday Night Football. It was roughly the same amount of time, reaching a massive audience. That’s how the law actually functions in the real world. It’s a game of minutes and seconds.
Section 315: The Law Behind the Notice
Most people think the Equal Time rule means news stations have to be "fair."
They don't. Not in the way you think.
💡 You might also like: Florida Man March 14: What Really Happened on the Wildest Day in the Sunshine State
The Fairness Doctrine was killed off in the 80s. You can be as biased as you want on a news program. However, Section 315 of the Communications Act is still very much alive. It specifically covers "uses" of a broadcast station by a candidate. If a candidate's voice or likeness appears on a non-exempt program, the station is on the hook.
What counts as exempt?
- Bona fide newscasts.
- Bona fide news interviews (think Meet the Press).
- Bona fide news documentaries.
- On-the-spot coverage of news events.
Saturday Night Live is none of those. It’s entertainment. Therefore, any appearance by a candidate on a sketch comedy show is a "use." When Harris appeared, NBC became legally obligated to provide the same opportunity to Donald Trump, provided he asked for it within seven days.
Why You See These Notices on Public Files
If you’ve ever gone down the rabbit hole of the FCC’s online public inspection files, you’ll see these notices all over the place during election cycles. They are dry. They are boring. They usually look like a standard form letter.
The NBC equal time notice specifically informed the public—and rival campaigns—that 1 minute and 30 seconds of "free" time had been provided. It’s a transparency mechanism. Without the notice, a campaign might not even know their opponent was on a local affiliate in a swing state, making it impossible to claim their rightful airtime.
It’s honestly a bit of a relic. In a world of Netflix, TikTok, and YouTube, the FCC has zero jurisdiction over "equal time." A candidate can spend 24 hours a day on a streaming platform, and the FCC can't do a thing. But if you're a legacy broadcaster like NBC, CBS, or ABC, you are still bound by the 1934 Communications Act. It creates this weird reality where broadcast TV is the most regulated, "fair" place left, even if it feels the most chaotic during an election.
The Seven-Day Rule
Campaigns aren't just handed time automatically. They have to be proactive. If a candidate sees their opponent on a talk show, they have exactly seven days from that appearance to demand their equal time. If they miss the window? Tough luck.
In the 2024 case, the Trump campaign didn't have to fight hard because the NBC equal time notice acted as a giant "Open for Business" sign for the request. NBC knew they had stepped in it, and they moved quickly to settle the debt before the FCC could even think about an investigation.
Misconceptions About What "Equal" Means
"Equal" does not mean "identical." This is where a lot of the internet outrage goes off the rails.
If a candidate appears at 11:30 PM on a Saturday, the station doesn't have to give the opponent 11:30 PM on a Saturday. They just have to provide a slot with a "comparable" audience. This is measured by ratings and demographics. Giving a candidate time at 3:00 AM on a Tuesday wouldn't count if their opponent was on during primetime.
The station also can't censor what the candidate says during their equal time. This leads to some wild situations where fringe candidates buy "equal time" ads and run graphic or controversial footage that the station would normally never air. Because of Section 315, the station is actually immune from libel suits regarding what the candidate says in those specific slots. They are legally forced to air it, so they can't be held responsible for the content.
👉 See also: How Long Can Gavin Newsom Be Governor: The Reality of California’s Term Limits
How Local Affiliates Get Caught in the Crossfire
It's not just the big network in New York. Every local NBC affiliate that aired that SNL episode technically had a responsibility. When the NBC equal time notice was filed, it covered the network's bases, but local stations often have to file their own paperwork in their local public files.
Imagine you're a station manager in Des Moines. You didn't ask for Kamala Harris to be on SNL. You just aired the feed. Suddenly, you have local candidates for House seats asking why they don't get time too. The law applies to everyone from the President down to the local county clerk. If a local station airs a "use" of a candidate, they owe time to every other legally qualified candidate for that same office. It is a logistical nightmare for small stations with limited staff.
The Future of Broadcast Regulations
Is this rule actually useful anymore?
Critics argue that the NBC equal time notice is a performance. They say it doesn't actually stop bias because the candidates who get the free "uses" are usually the ones with the most fame anyway. Smaller, third-party candidates rarely have the legal teams necessary to track every "use" and file requests within the seven-day window.
On the flip side, proponents say it's the only thing keeping the big three networks from becoming 24/7 campaign ads for their favorite party. Without Section 315, a network owner could theoretically give their preferred candidate a free hour every night for "interviews" and leave the opponent in the dark.
The 2024 SNL incident was a wake-up call for networks. It showed that even a "surprise" cameo is enough to trigger a massive response. Expect networks to be much more careful—or much more blatant—in how they handle these notices in the future.
Practical Steps for Tracking Equal Time
If you're a political junkie or someone working on a campaign, you shouldn't just wait for a headline about an NBC equal time notice. You can actually monitor this yourself.
- Check the FCC Public Files: Every broadcast station has a digital public file hosted by the FCC. You can search by station call sign (like WNBC) and look under the "Political Files" section.
- Monitor Non-News Programs: If you see a candidate on a talk show, a comedy sketch, or even a scripted cameo in a drama, that's a trigger. News doesn't count, but almost everything else does.
- The Seven-Day Clock: If you are working for a candidate, you have exactly one week. Mark the calendar the second the opponent appears on screen.
- Demand Comparable Time: Don't settle for a 4:00 AM slot. Use the station's own ratings data to demand a slot that actually reaches the same number of voters.
The reality of the NBC equal time notice is that it's a tool for transparency. It's not a "gotcha" and it's not a sign of a scandal. It's the sound of a giant media corporation following the rules so they don't lose their license. In a media environment where truth feels subjective, these rigid, old-fashioned rules provide one of the few paper trails we have left to see how power is being balanced—or tipped—on the airwaves.
Broadcasters are essentially guests in our living rooms. The equal time notice is just their way of proving they haven't overstayed their welcome by playing favorites. It might feel like a formality, but in the high-stakes world of election law, formalities are everything. Keep an eye on the public files; you'd be surprised how often these notices pop up without making the front page.