The pressure is weirdly heavy. Imagine being 19 years old and suddenly having the hopes of a multi-billion dollar franchise, an entire city, and a million screaming fans resting on your shoulders. That’s the life of the NBA draft pick number 1.
It's not just a title. It's a permanent label. If you win, you’re a "generational savior." If you struggle, you’re a "bust" before your first contract is even halfway through.
Take a look at the 2025 NBA Draft. The Dallas Mavericks took Cooper Flagg at number 1. People were calling him the "Great White Hope" of American basketball before he even stepped on a college court at Duke. He’s 6'9", he’s got a 7-foot wingspan, and he basically does everything on the court. But is he a lock for greatness?
History says... maybe.
Why the Number One Pick Isn't a Guaranteed Ring
We have this idea that the first overall pick is a cheat code. You get the best guy, you win the championship. Simple, right?
Honestly, it’s rarely that clean.
The NBA draft pick number 1 often goes to the worst-run teams. That’s how the lottery works. You’re putting a teenager into a locker room that just lost 60 games. Sometimes the culture is toxic. Sometimes the coach is about to get fired.
Look at Victor Wembanyama. He was the most hyped prospect since LeBron James. When the San Antonio Spurs took him at number 1 in 2023, he actually lived up to it. He finished his rookie year with 1,500 points, 250 assists, and 250 blocks. Only three other legends—Kareem, Hakeem, and David Robinson—have ever done that.
But for every Wemby, there’s a cautionary tale.
Remember Anthony Bennett in 2013? The Cleveland Cavaliers shocked everyone by taking him first. He played four seasons and was out of the league by 2017. He’s often cited as the biggest bust in history. But was it his fault, or the Cavs' scouting?
The Skill Gap is Shrinking
In the old days, the top pick was usually a dominant big man. You wanted Shaq. You wanted Patrick Ewing.
Now? It's about versatility.
The 2024 top pick, Zaccharie Risacher, is a 6'9" wing from France. He wasn't even the consensus number one for most of the year. The Atlanta Hawks took him because he fits the modern "3-and-D" mold. He had a solid rookie season, averaging about 12.6 points. He didn't set the world on fire like Wemby, but he showed he belongs.
The "Bust" Narrative is Kinda Unfair
We love to use the word "bust." It’s a catchy headline.
But injuries change everything. Greg Oden was the NBA draft pick number 1 in 2007. He was supposed to be the next Bill Russell. His knees just didn't hold up. Is he a bust? Technically, yes, because he didn't produce. But it wasn't a lack of talent. It was bad luck.
Then you have guys like Markelle Fultz. He went number 1 to Philly in 2017. He literally forgot how to shoot because of a nerve condition (Thoracic Outlet Syndrome). He’s carved out a decent career as a rotation player, but when you go first, "decent" feels like a failure.
What Really Makes a Number One Pick "Successful"?
If you talk to NBA scouts, they’ll tell you it’s not just about the stats. It’s about the "second contract."
If a team signs their top pick to a max extension after four years, that’s a win.
- Franchise Alteration: Did the team’s winning percentage actually go up?
- All-Star Appearances: Usually, you expect at least three or four.
- Marketability: Can you sell jerseys with this kid’s name on them?
Cooper Flagg is the perfect example of this. He’s got the motor. He never takes a play off. Scouts love that because even if his shot isn't falling, he’s still blocking three shots and grabbing ten rebounds. He affects the game in ways that don't always show up in a box score.
The International Takeover
The last few years have proven that the NBA draft pick number 1 doesn't have to be an American college star.
- 2023: Victor Wembanyama (France)
- 2024: Zaccharie Risacher (France)
Basketball is global now. The scouts are watching kids in Paris and Belgrade just as closely as they’re watching kids in Durham or Lawrence. This has actually made the draft harder to predict. You’re comparing a kid playing against grown men in the EuroLeague to a kid playing against 19-year-olds in the NCAA.
It’s apples and oranges.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Draft
Most fans think the team with the worst record gets the best player.
The lottery odds were flattened a few years ago. Now, the three worst teams all have a $14%$ chance at the top spot. This was supposed to stop "tanking," but teams still do it. They just do it more subtly.
When you see a team like the Wizards or the Pistons trading away every veteran for "future considerations," you know what they’re doing. They want that NBA draft pick number 1. They want the chance to change their luck.
Actionable Insights for Following the Draft
If you want to actually understand the draft like an expert, stop looking at mock drafts in November. They’re almost always wrong.
Follow the "Stock Risers": Watch for guys who perform well in the NCAA Tournament or the FIBA U19 World Cup. Pressure moments reveal who can handle the NBA spotlight.
Watch the "Wingspan to Height" Ratio: The NBA is obsessed with "length." If a kid is 6'6" but has a 7'1" wingspan, he’s going to be drafted higher than a 6'8" kid with short arms. It’s about defensive potential.
Ignore the Hype Videos: Every top prospect looks like Michael Jordan on a mixtape. Go watch a full game of them struggling. See how they react when they miss three shots in a row. That’s how you spot a future star.
The NBA draft pick number 1 is a gamble. It always has been. Whether it’s LeBron James or Anthony Bennett, you’re betting on a teenager’s brain as much as their body.
👉 See also: Feyenoord vs Inter Milan: Why This European Clash Still Matters
Pay attention to the 2026 class. There are already names like AJ Dybantsa surfacing. The cycle never stops. The hype will be enormous, the expectations will be impossible, and somewhere, a GM is praying they don't pick the next bust.
Focus on the defensive versatility and the mental toughness. Those are the traits that actually turn a number one pick into a Hall of Famer.