Ask any Buckeye fan where they were when Cardale Jones hit Devin Smith deep against Wisconsin, and they can probably tell you exactly what was on their plate. It was a weird time. Ohio State wasn't supposed to be there. Most of the country had written them off after that ugly loss to Virginia Tech in September, and honestly, can you blame them? J.T. Barrett was a freshman, the offensive line looked like a sieve, and the playoff felt like a pipe dream. But that's the thing about national championship Ohio State football history—it usually happens when you least expect it.
People talk about the 1968 "Super Sophomores" or the 2002 "Holy Buckeye" season with Tressel, but the 2014 run was different. It was the first ever College Football Playoff. It featured a third-string quarterback who looked like a create-a-player in a video game. It shouldn't have worked. Yet, it remains the gold standard for what this program is capable of when the chips are down.
The Quarterback Room That Defied Logic
Let's be real for a second. Most teams fold when their Heisman-caliber starter goes down. Braxton Miller's shoulder gave out before the season even started. Then J.T. Barrett, who had basically saved the season, broke his ankle against Michigan. Enter Cardale Jones. "12 Gauge." A guy who was mostly known for a tweet about classes being pointless.
What happened next wasn't just luck. It was a masterclass in coaching by Urban Meyer and Tom Herman. They didn't just survive; they thrived. In the three biggest games of their lives—the Big Ten Championship, the Sugar Bowl against Alabama, and the Title game against Oregon—Jones looked like the best player on the field. He had this weird, nonchalant confidence. He would shrug off 300-pound defensive linemen like they were middle schoolers. It was a statistical anomaly that worked because the surrounding talent was pro-level.
Think about that roster. Ezekiel Elliott, Michael Thomas, Taylor Decker, Joey Bosa. Looking back, it’s almost hilarious that people thought they were underdogs. But they were.
Why 2002 Still Hits Different for the Old Guard
If you grew up in the 90s, you remember the pain. John Cooper was a great coach, but he couldn't beat Michigan, and he definitely couldn't win the big one. Then came Jim Tressel. The vest. The punting. The "Tresselball" that drove everyone outside of Columbus absolutely insane.
📖 Related: Why Netball Girls Sri Lanka Are Quietly Dominating Asian Sports
The 2002 national championship Ohio State football team was a heart attack in cleats. They didn't blow people out. They grinded them into dust. They won seven games by a touchdown or less. Remember the "Holy Buckeye" play against Purdue? Craig Krenzel throwing a prayer to Michael Jenkins on 4th and 1? That ball was in the air for what felt like ten minutes.
The Fiesta Bowl against Miami is still one of the most controversial and physical games in the history of the sport. Everyone remembers the pass interference flag. People in Coral Gables are still screaming about it. But if you watch the tape, the Buckeyes' defensive line—led by Will Smith and Dustin Fox—absolutely battered Ken Dorsey. Miami was an NFL factory, and a bunch of kids from Ohio just out-toughed them. It wasn't pretty. It was football in the mud.
The Woody Hayes Era: Setting the Standard
We have to talk about the 1968 team. You can't understand the obsession with winning titles in Columbus without Woody. He was a lightning rod, sure, but he understood the psyche of the state. He didn't just want to win; he wanted to dominate the line of scrimmage until the opponent quit.
The '68 squad was special because they were so young. Rex Kern, Jack Tatum, Jim Stillwagon. They were "Super Sophomores." They went into the Rose Bowl and took down O.J. Simpson's USC team. That season established the "Three Yards and a Cloud of Dust" philosophy that defined the program for decades.
Woody used to say, "You win with people." He meant it. He recruited players who were as stubborn as he was. While the game has changed—the RPOs, the NIL deals, the transfer portal—that DNA of being a "power" program started right there. If you don't win the trenches, you don't win at Ohio State. Period.
👉 See also: Why Cumberland Valley Boys Basketball Dominates the Mid-Penn (and What’s Next)
The Modern Struggle for the Crystal Ball
Since 2014, the Buckeyes have been "right there" almost every year. They've made the playoff repeatedly. They've had Heisman finalists at quarterback like Justin Fields and C.J. Stroud. So why haven't they hoisted the trophy again?
- The Georgia/Alabama Hurdle: The talent gap between the top three teams is razor-thin. Sometimes it just comes down to a missed field goal or a single blown coverage in the fourth quarter.
- Defensive Identity: Under Ryan Day, the offense has been elite, but the defense has had some identity crises. You can't win a national championship Ohio State football title without a top-five defense.
- The Michigan Problem: You can't win a title if you don't win your division (or the conference). The resurgence of the rivalry has added a massive layer of stress to the final week of November.
The 2019 team might have been the best Ohio State team to not win a title. Justin Fields, J.K. Dobbins, Chase Young. That loss to Clemson in the semifinal was a gut punch. A touchdown catch by Chris Olave that wasn't, a roughing the kicker penalty—it was a game of inches that went the wrong way.
What It Takes to Win in the New Era
Winning a title in 2026 isn't like winning in 2002. The playoff is bigger. The season is longer. You basically have to play an NFL-length schedule. To get back to the mountain top, the Buckeyes have to evolve without losing that "Ohio Tough" identity.
It’s about depth now. You don't just need a great starting eleven; you need thirty guys who can start on any team in the country. The 2014 team had that. When J.T. went down, the team didn't blink. That is the blueprint.
Honestly, the pressure in Columbus is unlike almost anywhere else. It’s not enough to go 11-1. It’s not enough to beat Michigan. If there isn't a trophy in the case at the end of the year, people feel like something went wrong. It's a heavy burden for 19-year-olds, but it's what they sign up for when they put on that silver helmet.
✨ Don't miss: What Channel is Champions League on: Where to Watch Every Game in 2026
How to Track the Next Championship Run
If you want to know if the Buckeyes are legit contenders this year, stop looking at the scoreboard and start looking at the line of scrimmage. Are they getting pushed back on 3rd and 2? Are the linebackers filling gaps?
Success in national championship Ohio State football history has always been built on three specific pillars:
- Winning the Turnover Battle: In 2014, they were opportunistic.
- Elite Special Teams: Tressel lived and died by the punt.
- The "Big Play" Threat: Whether it's Zeke's 85-yard run through the heart of the south or Marvin Harrison Jr. making an impossible catch.
The history of this program is written in scarlet and gray, but the ink is never dry. Every season starts with the same expectation: gold pants and a trophy. Anything less is just a prelude to the next attempt.
Practical Steps for Following Buckeye Title Hunts
- Watch the "Trench Warfare": Don't just follow the ball. Watch the left tackle and the defensive ends. That’s where Ohio State wins or loses titles.
- Monitor the Injury Report: As 2014 showed, depth is everything. See who the "next man up" is during spring ball.
- Check the Strength of Schedule: The committee prizes big wins. Pay attention to those out-of-conference matchups against teams like Texas or Alabama.
- Follow Local Beat Writers: Guys like those at Eleven Warriors or the Columbus Dispatch often see the tactical shifts before they become obvious on national TV.
- Analyze Recruiting Rankings: You generally need a "Blue Chip Ratio" of over 50% to win a title. Ohio State usually hovers around 80%.
The road to the trophy always goes through the Big Ten. If they can survive the gauntlet of the expanded conference, they have as good a shot as anyone. It’s just about peaking at the right time—just like Cardale and company did in that snowy winter of 2014.