If you’ve spent any time wandering the brick sidewalks of Nashville, Indiana, you know the vibe. It’s that rare mix of high-end art galleries and kitschy salted-water taffy shops, all tucked into the rolling hills of the Hoosier National Forest. But if you're looking for the Nashville Inn Brown County Indiana, you’re going to run into a bit of a ghost story.
It’s gone.
I’m not talking about "closed for renovations" or "under new management." I’m talking about a literal hole in the town’s history. For decades, the Nashville Inn sat at the corner of Van Buren and Main Streets—the absolute epicenter of the village. It was the landmark everyone used to find their way back to their cars. Then, in the fall of 2003, a massive fire leveled it.
People still search for it, though. They remember the creaky floorboards and the smell of fried chicken. They look for that specific brand of rustic hospitality that modern boutique hotels sometimes struggle to replicate. Understanding what happened to the inn—and what replaced that cultural vacuum—is basically a crash course in how Brown County became the Midwest’s favorite weekend escape.
The Fire That Changed Nashville Forever
October 2003. It was peak leaf-peeping season. In Brown County, that’s basically the Super Bowl. The town was packed.
The fire started late at night. Honestly, it was a miracle nobody died. The Nashville Inn was a sprawling wooden structure, exactly the kind of building that fire marshals lose sleep over. By the time the volunteer departments from across the county arrived, the glow could be seen for miles.
It wasn’t just a hotel burning. It was a museum of sorts.
✨ Don't miss: Getting to Burning Man: What You Actually Need to Know About the Journey
When the smoke cleared, the "Heart of Nashville" was a pile of ash. The loss was felt deeply because the inn represented the transition of Nashville from a sleepy artist colony to a legitimate tourist destination. It had been there since the early 20th century, surviving through the Great Depression and the boom of the 1970s.
Why the Location Was Everything
You have to understand the geography of this town. Nashville is laid out in a way that funneling everyone toward that specific corner of Main and Van Buren is inevitable.
- Cornerstone Status: The inn sat right where the most foot traffic occurs.
- The Porch Life: Its massive porch was the best place in the county to people-watch.
- The Famous Fried Chicken: Ask any local over the age of 40 about the inn, and they’ll mention the Sunday dinners.
When it vanished, the town felt lopsided. For a long time, there was just a fence and a lot of questions about what would come next. There were rumors of a rebuild, but insurance complications and the sheer cost of modern fire codes made a "replica" impossible.
What Replaced the Nashville Inn?
If you go to that corner today, you’ll see the Cornerstone Inn.
It’s beautiful, honestly. It’s a massive, Victorian-style building that tries to honor the spirit of what was lost without being a cheesy imitation. It’s a boutique experience now. You get the 35 individually decorated rooms, the sweets in the afternoon, and that "steps away from everything" convenience.
But it’s different. It’s more "upscale weekend getaway" and less "rustic boarding house."
🔗 Read more: Tiempo en East Hampton NY: What the Forecast Won't Tell You About Your Trip
That shift reflects the broader change in Brown County. The area has moved away from the cheap, $40-a-night motels of the 1980s toward high-end cabins and luxury suites. It’s great for the local economy, but it’s why people still get nostalgic for the old Nashville Inn. They miss the accessibility of it.
Navigating Modern Nashville Without the "Old" Inn
So, you’re planning a trip. You’ve realized the Nashville Inn is a memory. Where do you actually stay to get that same feeling of being in the middle of the action?
You’ve got a few distinct lanes you can pick from.
The Village Boutique Experience
If you want to be where the inn used to be, you stay at the Cornerstone Inn or the Hotel Nashville. Hotel Nashville is a bit further up the hill, but it gives you that suite-style living. It’s great if you’re traveling with family and don't want to be cramped in a single room.
The State Park Vibe
For some, the "true" Nashville experience is the Abe Martin Lodge inside Brown County State Park. It’s just down the road. It has that heavy timber, stone-fireplace energy that the original Nashville Inn possessed. Plus, there’s an indoor water park now, which is a weird but welcome contrast to the 1930s architecture.
The "New" Rustic: Airbnb and Secluded Cabins
This is where the majority of the "stay" energy has shifted. People aren't looking for hotels as much; they’re looking for A-frames with hot tubs. Look toward areas like Gnaw Bone or the outskirts of Yellowwood State Forest if you want the quiet that the old-timers talk about.
💡 You might also like: Finding Your Way: What the Lake Placid Town Map Doesn’t Tell You
The Reality of Brown County Travel in 2026
Nashville isn't the "hidden gem" it used to be. It's popular.
If you show up on a Saturday in October without a reservation, you’re sleeping in your car. Or Bloomington. Seriously.
The loss of the Nashville Inn actually created a bit of a lodging crisis for a few years. The town had to pivot. Now, the focus is on diversity of experience. You can get a high-end spa treatment at The Seasons Lodge or you can grab a beer and a burger at Big Woods (the original "Pizza Company" location is a must-visit, even if the lines are long).
A Note on the Artist Colony Roots
The Nashville Inn was a hub for the Brown County Art Colony. This wasn't just a marketing gimmick. T.C. Steele and other Impressionist painters literally put this place on the map.
The inn used to display local work on the walls—not as decor, but as a gallery. When you visit today, make sure you stop by the Brown County Art Gallery or the Brown County Art Guild. They carry the torch that the inn used to hold. They have permanent collections that show what the landscape looked like before the paved roads and the fudge shops took over.
Actionable Tips for Your Nashville Trip
Don't just drive in, walk around for an hour, and leave. You’ll miss the best parts.
- Park Once: Use the public lot behind the Playhouse or near the Visitors Center. Nashville is small; you don't need to move your car to see the shops.
- The "Back Track" Rule: The best shops aren't always on Van Buren (the main drag). Walk the alleys and the side streets like Old Alley or Coachlight Square. That’s where the actual working artists usually have their studios.
- Timing is Everything: If you want the "old Nashville" quiet, visit on a Tuesday or Wednesday. Most shops are open, but the crowds are non-existent.
- The State Park Entrance: Use the West Entrance (near the park office) if you're coming from Bloomington, but if you're already in town, use the North Entrance (the covered bridge entrance). It’s one of the most photographed spots in Indiana for a reason.
- Food Beyond Fried Chicken: While the inn's chicken is gone, The Ordinary offers a colonial-style atmosphere that feels very "period correct." For something modern, Hobnob Corner is located in one of the oldest buildings in town and has a sourdough bread that people legitimately fight over.
The Nashville Inn Brown County Indiana might be a piece of history now, but its absence shaped the town into what it is today. It forced Nashville to modernize while desperately clinging to its "Little Switzerland" aesthetic. Whether you’re staying in a sleek new suite or a cabin in the woods, you’re walking the same paths that travelers have used for over a century to find a little bit of peace in the hills.
Next Steps for Your Trip
- Check the official Brown County Visitors Center website for a live "Leaf Cam" if you are planning a fall trip; the peak window is shorter than you think.
- Book your lodging at least six months in advance for October dates.
- Visit the T.C. Steele State Historic Site in nearby Belmont to see the actual house and gardens that started the entire tourism movement in this region.