You know her as the girl with the shotgun. The one who went from a studious, slightly-too-perfect suburban teenager to a monster-hunting journalist with a perm that could survive an apocalypse. Natalia Dyer, the Nancy actress Stranger Things fans have watched grow up for a decade, is a bit of an enigma. Honestly, if you saw her walking down a street in Manhattan today, you might not even realize it’s her. She’s quiet. She’s tiny. She’s nothing like the loud, bombastic "movie stars" we usually see plastered across TikTok.
People always ask the same stuff. Is she really dating Jonathan? (Yes, and they’ve been together basically since the Obama administration). Did she really hate her hair in the early seasons? (Kinda). But there is so much more to her story than just being the big sister in a hit Netflix show.
📖 Related: Is R Kelly Out Of Jail TMZ: What Really Happened with the Release Rumors
The Audition She Thought She "Trashingly" Failed
Most people think Natalia Dyer was some polished Hollywood product. Nope. She was a student at NYU’s Gallatin School of Individualized Study when the audition for Stranger Things—then called Montauk—landed on her desk. She wasn't even sure if she wanted to be a professional actor. In her head, she was going to have a "job-job" and maybe do community theater on the side.
The day of her audition, she was having a rough time. It was an emotional day, she was stressed, and she walked out of the room convinced she had "completely trashed" the performance. She didn't think she was "Nancy Wheeler." She thought she was just another college kid who blew an opportunity.
But the Duffer Brothers saw something. They saw that specific blend of 1980s innocence and iron-willed determination. By the time the screen test rolled around, she realized she might actually be doing something right. She ended up putting her education on pause to fly to Atlanta.
Think about that for a second. Imagine leaving NYU to go film a "weird" sci-fi show that nobody knew would work. At the time, Netflix wasn't the giant it is today; they only had a few hits like Orange Is the New Black. It was a massive gamble.
Why the Nancy Actress Stranger Things Fans Love Is More Than a Meme
Nancy Wheeler is a divisive character, or at least she was in the beginning. People loved to hate her for how she treated Barb. Then they loved her for how she treated the Demogorgon.
Natalia Dyer plays Nancy with a very specific, grounded intensity. It’s not just about the guns or the investigation. It's about the fact that she’s an introvert playing an introvert who has to become an extrovert to survive. Natalia has said in interviews that she’s actually quite private and shy.
The Real Life Romance: Natalia and Charlie
The chemistry you see on screen between Nancy and Jonathan Byers isn't fake. Natalia Dyer and Charlie Heaton have been a couple since 2016. They are famously private, which is rare for a "power couple" in 2026.
- September 2016: First "amigos" post on Instagram.
- December 2017: They finally made it red-carpet official at the Fashion Awards in London.
- 2025/2026: They are still together, recently spotted at Burberry’s fashion shows and the Stranger Things musical premiere.
Working with your partner for ten years on the same set? That sounds like a recipe for disaster for most people. But Natalia has mentioned that it’s actually "really fun" because they have this shared shorthand. They can talk about the scenes before they even get to set. They understand the weird pressure of being famous in a way nobody else really can.
Life After the Upside Down: What’s Next in 2026?
With the Stranger Things series finale having just dropped on New Year’s Eve, everyone is looking at what the "kids" are doing next. While some of her co-stars are jumping straight into Marvel movies or massive pop careers, Natalia is taking a slightly different path. She’s always been an indie darling at heart.
If you haven't seen Yes, God, Yes, you need to. She plays a Catholic schoolgirl discovering her own sexuality, and it’s arguably her best performance to date. It’s funny, it’s awkward, and it shows her range way beyond just being "Nancy."
Looking ahead at the 2026 slate, she has some heavy hitters coming up:
- Chestnut: A queer coming-of-age drama where she plays a recent college grad in Philadelphia. It’s supposed to hit streaming in Spring 2026.
- God’s Country: This one is a survival thriller. People are already comparing it to The Revenant. It’s gritty, it’s dirty, and it’s a total 180 from the 80s prep look.
- All Fun and Games: A horror film with Asa Butterfield that leans into the darker, more visceral stuff she clearly enjoys.
The Misconception of "Stardom"
We live in an era where actors are expected to be "on" 24/7. Natalia Dyer doesn't play that game. She has millions of followers on Instagram but barely posts. She’s talked about how being "overexposed" might actually limit her ability to do her job. If we know too much about Natalia, we won't believe her as Nancy or whatever character she plays next.
She’s actually a Nashville native. She grew up doing theater at the Tennessee Center for the Performing Arts. She even had a tiny, tiny role in the Hannah Montana movie back in 2009. Did you catch that? She was Clarissa Granger. It’s a hilarious bit of trivia that shows how long she’s been grinding in this industry.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Aspiring Actors
If you’re following Natalia Dyer's career or trying to emulate her success, there are a few "Natalia rules" to live by:
- Value Privacy: You don't have to share everything to be successful. In fact, keeping some mystery might make your work more believable.
- Diversify Your Roles: Don't get stuck in the "teen drama" box. Natalia intentionally chose weird indie films like Velvet Buzzsaw to prove she could do more.
- Education Matters: Even though she paused NYU, she’s constantly talking about her love for language and art. Being a well-rounded human makes you a better storyteller.
- Trust the Process: She thought she failed her biggest audition. Sometimes your "worst" day is actually the day your life changes.
Natalia Dyer has officially survived the 1980s. Now, as she enters this new phase of her career in 2026, she’s proving that the Nancy actress Stranger Things introduced us to was just the beginning. She’s not just a girl with a shotgun anymore; she’s one of the most thoughtful, intentional actors of her generation.
Whether she's taking French classes or filming a survivalist thriller in the woods, she’s doing it on her own terms. That’s the real "Nancy Wheeler" energy we should all be looking for.
To keep up with her latest work, keep an eye on the Spring 2026 festival circuit for Chestnut. It’s a project she’s been passionate about for years, and it’s likely to be the film that finally separates her from her Hawkins persona for good.