Benson Boone is doing something weird.
Actually, it's not just weird; it's borderline chaotic. If you’ve spent any time on TikTok or Spotify in the last year, you’ve likely stumbled upon the polarizing anthem that is "Mystical Magical." It’s the kind of track that makes some people want to do a backflip and others want to delete their social media apps entirely.
Honestly, it's hilarious. The "Beautiful Things" singer, known for his gut-wrenching ballads and cinematic belt, decided to lean into a whimsical, almost hallucinogenic pop sound for the second single of his 2025 album, American Heart. The lyrics are a fever dream. We're talking moonbeams. We're talking ice cream. We're talking about dancing at the movies.
What the heck is "moonbeam ice cream" anyway?
Most people got it wrong at first. They thought he was losing his edge or trying too hard to be the next Freddie Mercury (though performing "Bohemian Rhapsody" with Brian May at Coachella 2025 certainly didn't help quiet those comparisons). But if you look at the mystical magical benson boone lyrics through a different lens, you see a songwriter who is finally having a bit of fun with the absurdity of early-stage attraction.
The Confusion Behind the Mystical Magical Benson Boone Lyrics
The song opens with a classic "push-pull" relationship dynamic. Benson sings about a girl who gives him the "colder shoulder" one minute and then "switches up with no warning" to kiss him the next. It's frustrating. It’s "rude," as he puts it.
But then, the pre-chorus hits.
This is where the internet lost its collective mind. Boone’s voice climbs into a stratospheric falsetto—one he later joked in a Rolling Stone interview sounded like "Tiny Tim’s Tip Toe Through the Tulips"—to deliver a list of sensations.
👉 See also: Diego Klattenhoff Movies and TV Shows: Why He’s the Best Actor You Keep Forgetting You Know
"Once you know what my love's gonna feel like / Nothing else will feel right, you can feel like / Moonbeam ice cream, taking off your blue jeans / Dancing at the movies, 'cause it feels so..."
The imagery is jarring. It doesn’t follow a logical narrative path. Instead, it’s a sensory overload. Taking off blue jeans is a tactile relief. Dancing at the movies is a social taboo that feels exhilarating when you’re in love. And moonbeam ice cream? That’s pure vibe.
Some fans on Reddit theorized that the song was about "love bombing" or "coercive control," but that’s a bit of a stretch for a song that literally mentions ice cream in the chorus. It’s more likely that Benson was trying to capture the feeling of a crush rather than the mechanics of one. Love is surreal. It’s magical. It’s mystical. It’s basically a unicorn in song form.
Why the Song "Failed" Then Became a Hit
When "Mystical Magical" first dropped in April 2025, the initial reaction was... let’s say "mixed."
The song was mocked relentlessly on TikTok. People called the lyrics "cringe" and the vocal production "too much." For a few weeks, it looked like the sophomore slump was hitting hard. But a funny thing happened over the summer of 2025.
The hate turned into a meme, and the meme turned into genuine appreciation.
By the time the American Heart album officially launched in June, "Mystical Magical" had become the "song of the summer" for a massive group of fans who realized the track wasn't meant to be taken so seriously. It’s a theatrical, glam-rock-inspired romp. It’s meant to be shouted in a stadium, not analyzed in a dark room with headphones.
✨ Don't miss: Did Mac Miller Like Donald Trump? What Really Happened Between the Rapper and the President
Decoding the Specific Lyrics
If we're being real, the "moonbeam ice cream" line is a stroke of accidental genius. It’s a synesthetic metaphor. It combines the visual (light) with the gustatory (sweetness) and the ephemeral (melting). You can’t hold a moonbeam, and you can’t keep ice cream from melting. It’s a fleeting, perfect moment.
Boone has since admitted that he basically made the phrase up because it "sounded good," though fans pointed out it was also the title of a 2015 song by a band called Citra. Pure coincidence? Probably.
Then there's the second verse, where he sings:
"Not saying you gotta chase me / But I wouldn't mind it / If you gave me just a little bit."
This is the vulnerability that makes Benson Boone, well, Benson Boone. Even in a song filled with balloons and "magical" feelings, he’s still that kid who is just hoping someone likes him back. It’s a pivot from the "alpha" energy of the pre-chorus back to the reality of being a guy who is still waiting for a text back.
The Live Performance Factor
You can't talk about these lyrics without talking about how they change when he’s on stage.
The studio version is polished—maybe too polished for some. But live? The mystical magical benson boone lyrics take on a much heavier, rock-and-roll edge. During his American Heart World Tour, Benson would often extend the bridge, letting the band go wild while he did his signature backflips and belted the chorus with a rasp that you just don't hear on the radio edit.
🔗 Read more: Despicable Me 2 Edith: Why the Middle Child is Secretly the Best Part of the Movie
He leans into the campiness. He wears the colorful outfits. He owns the "whimsical" label.
What You Can Learn from Benson’s Approach
There’s a lesson here for anyone who creates anything.
Benson Boone took a massive risk with this track. He could have played it safe and released "Beautiful Things 2.0." Instead, he released a song about moonbeams and movies.
- Vulnerability doesn't always mean crying. Sometimes, being vulnerable means being willing to look a little silly in front of millions of people.
- Polarization is better than boredom. The people who hated "Mystical Magical" talked about it just as much as the people who loved it. That's how you stay relevant in 2026.
- Context matters. A lyric that sounds "cringe" on a phone speaker can feel like a revelation in a crowded concert venue with thousands of people screaming along.
The song eventually peaked at No. 12 on the Billboard Hot 100, proving that even the weirdest lyrics can find a home if the hook is big enough.
If you're trying to figure out the "true" meaning of the song, don't look too hard. It’s about that brief, chaotic window of time when you’re so into someone that the world stops making sense. It's messy. It's weird. It's mystical.
Next time you’re listening, pay attention to the transition between the second verse and the final chorus. Notice how the instrumentation drops out for a split second before the "magical" hook comes back in. That’s the moment the "magic" happens.
For the most authentic experience, try watching the official lyric video directed by Matt Eastin. It perfectly captures the "dancing through the chaos" vibe that the song intends to deliver. Whether you love the song or still think it's the weirdest thing he's ever written, you can't deny that Benson Boone knows how to get people talking.
Go back and listen to the American Heart version versus the live Coachella recording. You’ll hear two completely different artists, and that’s exactly what makes the current era of pop music so interesting. You don't have to choose a side; you can just enjoy the ride.