You're staring at your phone at 3 AM. The RFA chatroom just closed, and suddenly, a notification pings. It’s an email from a "Longcat" or maybe a "Rice Soup Master." Your heart sinks. One wrong move, and they won't show up to the party.
If you've played Cheritz’s masterpiece for more than five minutes, you know the stakes. Getting the mystic messenger answers email right isn't just about being polite; it’s the thin line between a Good Ending and a "Normal" Ending that feels like a slap in the face.
Honestly? The email system is kind of a trap. It looks simple, but the logic is often... weird. Why would a cat lover want to hear about a cat limousine? Because it's Mystic Messenger. That's why.
The Brutal Reality of the Guest List
Let's talk numbers. To snag that Good Ending in Casual or Deep Story, you usually need at least 10 confirmed guests.
If you’re playing Another Story (V or Ray’s routes), the game gets mean. You’ll need 16 or more. Miss a few, and you’re stuck with the Normal Ending. It’s not "bad," but after eleven days of sleep deprivation, you want the best possible payoff.
The mechanic works like a three-strike system.
- First Reply: If you get this wrong, they're gone. Period. The thread dies.
- Second Reply: You can still save it, but you're on thin ice.
- Third Reply: The final confirmation.
When you see a silver envelope, you're safe. They are 100% coming. A green envelope? That's a "maybe." They might show up, or they might ghost you like your last Tinder date. It’s RNG (randomness) at that point.
Mystic Messenger Answers Email: The Cheat Sheet
You don’t have time to guess. Here are the correct responses for the most common (and confusing) guests that pop up in the RFA inbox.
The Weird Ones
- @allergy (Cat Allergy): Tell them about the cat allergy. Suggest beef and seaweed soup. Then, tell them you might be allergic to guests not attending.
- @artwomen: Van Gogh. Monet. The Louvre.
- @badcomment: I saw it on YouTube. I want to go see a movie. Report them!
- @barista: Arabica coffee. Drip brewing. Italian.
The Professional Types
- @banker: 100% interest rate. Bank passbook. We split it up.
- @detective: Treasure Hunter. Seven’s dynamic world.
- @docascon (Doctors with Conscience): Hippocratic oath. Request exam results. Big hospital near your house.
- @education: There’s this person called Jaehee. Games that give soda as prizes. It’s because you’re too smart.
The Total Wildcards
- @floppy: A rainbow-colored floppy disk model. Windows 8.1 3711 disks. Obtain a limited edition cassette.
- @god: Wow! Amazing that I get to talk to God! I am your daughter.
- @lolol: Dia. Of course lol. Play LOLOL together.
- @oil: Fancy party! Lots of parking space! Of course!
Why You Keep Failing (Even With a Guide)
I've seen people use a guide and still mess up. The most common mistake? Not opening the final confirmation email.
🔗 Read more: Images of Super Mario Bros: Why We Can’t Stop Looking at a Plumber
Seriously. If you answer all three questions correctly but don't click that final "Completed" message, the guest won't count. The game considers the thread "in progress." Always, always double-check your inbox before the party starts on Day 11.
Another thing: some guests only trigger if you pick specific dialogue in the chatrooms. If you're being mean to Seven, don't expect his hacker friends to want to party with you. The game tracks your "vibe" even outside the email app.
The "Save State" Trick
If you’re worried about a specific guest, there’s a sneaky way to handle it. You can actually save your game right before opening an email. If you pick the wrong choice (you’ll see a yellow/orange arrow instead of a teal/green one), just reload.
It costs HG (Hourglasses) if you aren't careful with your save slots, but for Ray’s route? It’s often worth it. Another Story is notorious for having guests with answers that make zero logical sense.
Pro Tips for 2026 Players
- Speed is key: Don't let emails sit for three days. While there isn't a strict "timer" that makes them expire instantly, the closer you get to the party, the less time you have for the back-and-forth.
- The 10-Guest Rule: In Casual/Deep story, aim for 12. Why? Because accidents happen. Someone might get a "Green" status and decide to stay home.
- Don't Ignore "Normal" Guests: Even if you aren't a fan of the guest's personality, invite them. Each guest you successfully bring to the party grants you 1 Hourglass in the "Guest" tab of the RFA menu. It’s the best way to farm HG for free.
Getting the mystic messenger answers email right is basically a mini-game of social engineering. You have to think like the guest, not like yourself. If the guest is a narcissist, stroke their ego. If they're a nerd, talk tech.
Actionable Next Steps:
Check your current guest list in the app. If you have fewer than 10 "Completed" silver icons and you're already on Day 9, start aggressively triggering guest prompts in the remaining chatrooms. Go through your "In Progress" emails and use the answers above to lock them in before the Day 11 party transition.