You’re standing on the sidewalk in Covington, Georgia, looking up at that iconic brick facade. If you’ve spent any time on the couch watching Elena Gilbert and the Salvatore brothers, your brain is probably screaming "Mystic Falls." You expect a vampire to walk out. Or maybe a brooding hybrid. But honestly? Once you step through those heavy doors, the "Hollywood" of it all kinda takes a backseat to the smell of actual, honest-to-God Southern cooking.
The mystic grill covington ga menu is a weird, beautiful paradox. It is simultaneously a tourist pilgrimage site and a legitimate, high-end kitchen that doesn't just rest on its cinematic laurels. People come for the photo ops. They stay because the kitchen knows exactly what to do with a piece of goat cheese and a deep fryer.
The Reality of the Mystic Grill Covington GA Menu
Let’s be real. Most "TV-themed" restaurants are a total letdown. You usually get a soggy burger named after a character and a $15 cocktail that tastes like blue Gatorade. Mystic Grill is different. It’s "chef-driven," which is a fancy way of saying they actually care about where their tomatoes come from. They source from local farmers. They hire local people. It’s a community hub that happens to be famous on the CW.
If you’re looking at the mystic grill covington ga menu for the first time, don't just hunt for the Vampire Diaries references. You’ll miss the point.
Starters That Actually Start Something
Most people go straight for the Fried Green Tomatoes. It’s the law in Georgia, basically. But these aren't your greasy, roadside stand variety. They come topped with a Southern pimento cheese and a tomato jam that balances the acidity perfectly. It’s $7.00. That’s cheaper than a Starbucks run in some cities.
Then there’s the Baked Brie. It’s served in a whole wheat bread bowl with rosemary ginger pear jam. It’s heavy. It’s decadent. You’ll probably need a nap afterward. If you want something lighter—sorta—the Goat Cheese & Rosemary Honey medallions are a sleeper hit. They're covered in dried cranberries and candied pecans. It's the kind of dish that makes you realize why people in the South are so obsessed with pecans.
Why the Entrees Are More Than Just Fan Service
The heart of the mystic grill covington ga menu lies in its "Yard" and "Pasture" sections. This isn't just a steakhouse. It’s a place that takes Southern staples and gives them a slight, upscale nudge.
Sweet Tea Fried Chicken sounds like a gimmick. It isn't. Brining chicken in sweet tea is an old-school Southern secret for moisture, and at $15.00, it’s one of the best values on the square. It comes with buttermilk mash and green beans, topped with an andouille red eye gravy. That gravy? It’s got a kick. It’s not for the faint of heart or the spice-averse.
The Burger That Rules the Square
If you ask a local what to order, they aren't going to tell you to get a salad. They’re going to point at The Clocktower Burger.
It’s massive.
Actually, massive is an understatement.
It’s a structural engineering project.
It usually features a fried egg, bacon, and enough beef to satisfy a hungry Original vampire. Patrons regularly report they can only finish half. It’s the "bomb," as one regular put it, especially if you pair it with the "winder fries"—those curly, crispy potato wedges that hold salt better than a standard fry ever could.
Sea and Pasta
Surprisingly, the Grilled Salmon gets rave reviews. It’s perfectly cooked—tender, not that rubbery stuff you get at chain restaurants. For the pasta lovers, the Bleu Cheese Chicken Pasta is a weirdly addictive combo. Cavatappi pasta, bleu cheese cream, bacon, and roasted tomatoes. It’s sharp. It’s salty. It’s polarizing. You either love bleu cheese or you’re wrong, basically.
The Hidden Gems and Local Favorites
There’s a sandwich called the T.K. Adams Turkey Melt. Most tourists skip it because it doesn’t sound "mystic" enough. Big mistake. It’s an open-faced sandwich on wheat with applewood smoked turkey, bacon, and hollandaise. Yes, hollandaise on a turkey melt. It’s named after a local legend, and it tastes like a brunch dream that wandered into a lunch menu.
The Mystic Grilled Cheese is another one. It has blackberry jam and jalapeños. That sweet-heat combo with the melted Havarti on sourdough is why this place stays busy on a Tuesday night when there aren't any tour buses in town.
The Dessert Situation
You cannot leave without the Chocolate Cheesecake. It’s served with chocolate crumbles and syrup. It’s rich enough to share, but you probably won't want to. One reviewer mentioned eating the whole thing before her husband even came downstairs. No regrets. The Raspberry Cheesecake is also a staple, though it’s a bit more "standard" than the chocolate explosion.
Making the Most of Your Visit
Eating at Mystic Grill isn't just about the food; it’s about the geography of the building.
- The Rooftop: If the weather is even remotely nice, ask for a seat on the roof. You get a direct view of the Covington Clock Tower. It’s the best seat in the house for people-watching on the square.
- The Bar: There are dedicated chairs at the bar for Alaric, Stefan, and Damon. Even if you aren't a fan, the bar area has a "loft-style" vibe that feels very "big city" for a small Georgia town.
- The Gift Shop: It’s in the basement. It’s full of Vampire Diaries memorabilia. It’s also where you realize just how much this building has been through—it was built in 1906 and has survived fires and decades of change.
The Pricing Reality
Look, you’re going to spend money here. A dinner for two with drinks and dessert can easily hit $150.00 in 2026. Is it worth it? If you value quality ingredients and an atmosphere you can't find anywhere else, then yeah. If you just want a quick burger, there’s a Wendy’s down the road. But you didn’t come to Covington for a Frosty.
✨ Don't miss: Chastain Horse Park Atlanta Georgia: Why This Buckhead Icon Isn't Just for Riders
Navigating the Crowd
Covington is "The Hollywood of the South" for a reason. Production crews are constantly in and out. This means the restaurant can get packed.
- Monday to Thursday: These are your best bets for a walk-in.
- Saturdays: Don't even try without a plan. The square is "live," the shops are full, and the wait times can be brutal.
- Sundays: They open at 11:00 AM. It’s a huge brunch spot for locals after church.
The mystic grill covington ga menu changes seasonally, too. They might swap out a pear jam for a peach jam depending on what’s growing nearby. That’s the "chef-driven" part. They aren't just opening cans in the back. They’re actually cooking.
To truly experience what this place has to offer, step away from the "TV show" mindset for just a second. Order the Fried Meatloaf. It sounds weird, but it’s amazing—served with Yukon potato mash and green beans. It’s Southern comfort food that has been elevated just enough to justify the price tag.
Once you're done with your meal, walk around the square. Covington is a town that embraces its history, both the real stuff from 1906 and the fictional stuff from Mystic Falls. The Grill is the center of that universe. Whether you’re a fan of the show or just a fan of a really good ribeye, you’re going to find something that hits the spot.
Next Steps for Your Visit:
Check the official website for current seasonal rotations on the mystic grill covington ga menu before you arrive, as specific sides like the "Roasted Root Vegetables" or "Autumn Greens" change based on local farm availability. If you are planning a weekend visit, call ahead to see if they are taking reservations for your party size, as rooftop seating is usually first-come, first-served and fills up within minutes of opening.