So, you’ve settled into your workshop, kicked a few yakmels, and now you’re looking at the townsfolk wondering who’s actually worth the "Heart Knot" investment. Honestly, Sandrock doesn't make it easy. With 21 different My Time at Sandrock romance options, the sheer volume of thirsty neighbors is a bit overwhelming. Some are sweet, some are weirdly obsessed with rocks, and one is a literal bandit who doesn't even show his face for the first half of the game.
Choosing a partner in this desert isn't just about who looks the best in cell-shaded graphics. It’s about who has the quests that won't make you want to hurl your pickhammer into the abyss.
The Heavy Hitters: Logan, Fang, and the "Slow Burn" Problem
If you’ve spent five minutes on a subreddit or Discord for this game, you know Logan is the poster child. He’s the "I can fix him" candidate of the year. But here's the thing: you can’t even properly talk to the guy until the third act. If you’re looking for a quick marriage to get those sweet, sweet workshop perks, Logan is a terrible choice. He’s a late-game reward, basically.
Then there’s Fang.
His story is genuinely heart-wrenching, involving a lot of silence and a very talkative crow named X. Romancing Fang is a full-time job. You have to participate in his medical trials—which, let's be real, feels a bit like being a lab rat for love—and you can't even give him gifts at the start. He'll just reject them. It takes patience. A lot of it. But for players who want a narrative that feels "earned," he's usually the top pick.
👉 See also: Finding the Right Words That Start With Oc 5 Letters for Your Next Wordle Win
The Guys
- Logan: The monster hunter. High drama, very late appearance, but arguably has the most cinematic romance missions like "Cornered Beasts."
- Fang: The quiet doctor. Requires finishing a massive chain of quests including "Eagles in the Oasis" before he'll even look at a Heart Knot.
- Unsuur: This man is a treasure. He loves rocks. He is a rock. He has one of the funniest reverse confessions in the game where he basically sends you a pile of stones.
- Owen: The local barkeep. He's stable, he’s kind, and he's available from day one. He’s the "safe" choice, though some fans find his lack of early-game drama a bit boring.
- Qi: The director of the Research Center. If you like nerds who forget to eat and talk in scientific jargon, he’s your guy. His romance is surprisingly cute if you can handle the social awkwardness.
The Bachelorettes: From Best Friends to Secret Agents
The ladies of Sandrock are just as varied. You've got Nia, who is basically your childhood best friend. She’s another one of those "wait for it" romances because she doesn't move to town permanently until much later.
If you want someone who is actually there while you're struggling to build your first furnace, Amirah or Mi-an are the way to go. Amirah is the resident artist, very classy, very "I’m too busy for your nonsense." Mi-an is your rival builder who is so wholesome it almost hurts.
The Girls
- Nia: The botanist. Her romance feels the most "natural" because of the history with the player, but again, the wait time is a killer.
- Amirah: The ceramicist. She has a protective brother (Arvio) who will constantly annoy you, so keep that in mind.
- Heidi: The architect. She’s practical and smart. If you want a partner who feels like an actual adult with a job, Heidi is it.
- Grace: She’s a cook at the Blue Moon, but there’s a lot more to her than just omelets. Her storyline has some of the biggest twists in the game.
- Catori: The entrepreneur. She’s a single mom trying to build an entertainment empire. Some people find her a bit "money-focused," but her struggle is real.
How the Mechanics Actually Work
Don't just go around throwing Heart Knots at people. It doesn't work like that. First, you need to reach "Friend" status, which is usually around 400 relationship points. You can get these by talking daily, winning at the "Critters" card game, or—the classic—giving them stuff they actually like.
Once you’re friends, you buy a Heart Knot from the "By the Stairs" shop.
✨ Don't miss: Jigsaw Would Like Play Game: Why We’re Still Obsessed With Digital Puzzles
When you hand it over, there's a chance they'll reject you. If your relationship is low (around the 400 mark), you only have about a 30% success rate. If you wait until you're "BFFs," that jumps up significantly. Some characters, like Unsuur or Logan, have "Reverse Confessions." This means if you pick the flirtatious dialogue options (the ones with the little heart icon) during their specific story quests, they might actually ask you out.
It’s way more satisfying than being the one begging for a date.
The Dark Side: Jealousy and Breaking Up
Yes, you can date multiple people at once. No, it is not a good idea if you value your sanity.
If you’re on a date with Amirah and you happen to walk past Owen, and you're dating him too? Prepare for a disaster. You'll lose a massive chunk of relationship points with both. Some characters are "forgiving" and will take an Apology Bear (bought at the Game Center) to reset the relationship. Others, like Amirah or Ernest, will just dump you on the spot.
🔗 Read more: Siegfried Persona 3 Reload: Why This Strength Persona Still Trivializes the Game
If you want to end things officially without the drama, you have to give them a Dead Branch. It’s cold, it’s harsh, and it resets your status to "Associate" or "Buddy."
Actionable Tips for Your First Playthrough
- Check the Social Tab: Always look at the icons. Hearts mean they're romanceable. Stars mean they're just friends (like Mort or Vivi).
- Hoard Special Items: Fang loves his medicinal herbs. Logan likes weapons and high-end scraps. Don't give them trash; it actually lowers your score.
- Don't Rush Act 1: Many of the best My Time at Sandrock romance options only get their "good" content after the town's major crises are solved.
- The "Flirt" Dialogue Matters: Even if you aren't dating yet, using those heart icons in conversation "flags" your interest for the game's internal logic, making reverse confessions possible later.
The best part about Sandrock is that there's no "wrong" choice, unless you pick Pen. Actually, especially if you pick Pen. He’s a ride, but maybe keep a backup save for that one.
To get started, focus on finishing the "Trial by Kiln" and "The Joy of Farming" quests early on. These unlock more social interactions and the ability to actually gift items consistently, which is the fastest way to get anyone to notice you in this dusty little town.