You’ve seen the Netflix series with Evan Peters. Maybe you’ve even spiraled down a late-night Wikipedia rabbit hole about the Milwaukee Cannibal. But honestly, if you haven’t sat through the 2017 film My Friend Dahmer, you're missing the most haunting piece of the puzzle. It’s not a slasher. It’s not a police procedural. It’s a slow-motion car crash of a coming-of-age story that ends exactly where the nightmares begin.
Based on the 2012 graphic novel by John "Derf" Backderf—who actually walked those wood-paneled halls with Jeffrey Dahmer—the my friend jeffrey dahmer movie is a masterclass in "what if." What if someone had noticed the vodka in the orange juice? What if his "friends" weren't just using him for a cheap laugh?
The Casting Choice That Shouldn’t Have Worked (But Did)
When Disney Channel star Ross Lynch was announced as Jeff, people lost it. How do you go from Austin & Ally to a budding necrophile?
It was brilliant.
Lynch nailed the posture. That stiff, Frankenstein-like gait. The way he carried his shoulders like he was constantly trying to fold himself into a box. Most true crime biopics lean too hard into the "creepy" factor from frame one, but Lynch plays it with a terrifying blankness. You don't see a monster; you see a kid who is slowly, agonizingly being hollowed out.
The director, Marc Meyers, didn't want a caricature. He wanted a human. And that’s what makes it so much harder to watch.
🔗 Read more: Jack Blocker American Idol Journey: What Most People Get Wrong
Fact vs. Fiction: Did the "Dahmer Fan Club" Actually Exist?
Basically, yes. But the movie shifts the vibe.
In the film, we see Derf (played by Alex Wolff) and his crew adopt Jeff as a sort of "mascot." They encourage him to "do a Dahmer"—which involved Jeff faking epileptic fits or spastic outbursts in malls and libraries. It was cruel. It was 1970s high school at its peak.
- The Movie Version: Derf is portrayed as a bit of a ringleader, a cynical kid who finds Jeff’s "performances" hilarious until the darkness starts leaking out of the seams.
- The Real Life Version: Derf has been pretty vocal in interviews, including a 2018 chat with The Independent, stating that Dahmer actually came to them. He wasn't just a victim of their boredom; he was a willing participant who loved the attention. He used his "goofball antics" to mask the fact that he was spiraling.
One of the wildest things about the production is where they shot it. They didn't just find a random house in Ohio. They filmed in Jeffrey Dahmer’s actual childhood home in Bath, Ohio.
Can you imagine?
The crew was setting up lighting rigs in the same rooms where the real Lionel and Joyce Dahmer (played with tragic intensity by Dallas Roberts and Anne Heche) had their screaming matches. That shed in the backyard where Jeff dissolved roadkill? It was built on the same ground where the real one stood. That kind of authenticity isn't just for PR; it seeps into the film’s DNA. It feels heavy.
💡 You might also like: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
Why This Isn't Just Another Serial Killer Movie
Most movies about killers focus on the "why." They want to find the smoking gun—the one trauma that turned the key.
This movie doesn't do that.
It shows a "perfect storm." You’ve got a mother struggling with severe mental health issues, a father who is physically there but emotionally miles away, and a school system that just... looked the other way.
The Missing Intervention
There’s a scene where Jeff is clearly drunk in class. Not just "had a beer" drunk, but "stinking of hard liquor" drunk. In the film, as in real life, the adults just pushed him through. "Next year he'll be someone else's problem," seemed to be the mantra.
It highlights a systemic failure that feels uncomfortably modern.
📖 Related: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
The Humanity of the Victims
While the my friend jeffrey dahmer movie ends before the first murder, the specter of Steven Hicks hangs over the final act. We see Jeff's internal battle—the way he stalks a local jogger, Dr. Matthews (Vincent Kartheiser), with a baseball bat. He's trying to fight the urges, but he’s doing it entirely alone.
By the time the credits roll, you don't feel like you've watched a horror movie. You feel like you've watched a tragedy where the ending was preventable, which is a much harder pill to swallow.
Actionable Takeaways for True Crime Fans
If you're looking to get the most out of this story, don't just stop at the credits. There are layers here that most casual viewers miss.
- Read the Source Material: Derf Backderf’s graphic novel is even more detailed. It includes "The Archive," where he shows his original high school sketches of Dahmer. Seeing those 1978 drawings of a future serial killer is bone-chilling.
- Compare the Portrayals: Watch a few scenes of Ross Lynch side-by-side with Evan Peters from the Netflix show. Peters plays Dahmer as an adult who has accepted his nature; Lynch plays him as a teenager who is still terrified of what he’s becoming.
- Visit the History (Virtually): Look up the geography of Bath, Ohio. The isolation of the Dahmer house explains a lot about how he was able to go unnoticed for so long.
The my friend jeffrey dahmer movie doesn't give you the satisfaction of an arrest or a trial. It leaves you in that driveway in 1978, watching a car pull away, knowing that the world is about to change for 17 families. It’s a quiet, beige nightmare. And honestly? It’s the most honest portrayal of the killer we’ve ever seen.
For those interested in the psychological "why," start by looking into the "Dahmer Fan Club" members today—most have spent their lives trying to reconcile the class clown they knew with the man he became.