Honestly, if you grew up with Teletoon or Disney Channel in the early 2010s, you probably remember the absolute chaos of Whitechapel. It was weird. It was campy. It was surprisingly dark for a "kids' show." But before the series became a cult classic, everything started with that 2010 television film. When people search for the My Babysitter’s a Vampire movie cast, they aren't just looking for a list of names. They’re looking for a hit of nostalgia and an answer to the question: "Whatever happened to that geeky kid with the premonitions?"
The movie worked because the chemistry was genuine. It wasn't just a Twilight parody, though it definitely leaned into those tropes with the fictional Dusk series. It was a Canadian production that managed to capture a very specific vibe—half horror, half teen comedy. Looking back, the casting directors really struck gold. Most of these actors were just teenagers at the time, yet they carried a franchise that lasted two seasons and still has fans begging for a revival over a decade later.
The Core Trio of Whitechapel
Matthew Knight played Ethan Morgan. He was basically the heart of the movie. Knight was already a veteran in the industry before he ever stepped foot in Whitechapel, having appeared in The Grudge 2 and Goosebumps. He played the "seer" role with this perfect blend of neurotic energy and relatable awkwardness. Ethan wasn’t your typical hero; he was a nerd who was terrified of everything, which made his eventual bravery feel earned. Interestingly, Knight shifted away from the spotlight after the show ended. He’s one of those rare child stars who seemingly chose a quieter life, leaving fans to revisit his work as the definitive Ethan Morgan.
Then there is Vanessa Morgan as Sarah.
Before she was Toni Topaz on Riverdale, she was a "fledgling" vampire struggling with the fact that she didn't want to eat her neighbors. Morgan brought a lot of weight to a role that could have been very one-dimensional. She had to balance being a tough supernatural protector with the vulnerability of a girl who just wanted a normal high school experience. Her career trajectory since the 2010 movie has been massive. From The Shannara Chronicles to her long-running stint on Riverdale, she’s arguably the most visible member of the original cast today. She’s often talked about how much she loved the "vampire" era of her career, and you can see that same charisma in her later work.
And we can't forget Atticus Mitchell. He played Benny Weir.
Every supernatural show needs a comic relief character who accidentally makes things worse with magic, and Benny was it. Mitchell played the "spellmaster" with such high energy. He and Knight had this bromance that felt real—like they’d actually been best friends since kindergarten. Since the movie, Mitchell has stayed busy in the Canadian indie scene and appeared in projects like Fargo and Killjoys. He has this specific "character actor" quality that makes him stand out in every scene he’s in.
The Supporting Cast That Made It Work
It wasn't just about the main three. The My Babysitter’s a Vampire movie cast was rounded out by characters who actually felt like they belonged in a small, monster-infested town.
💡 You might also like: Why Love Island Season 7 Episode 23 Still Feels Like a Fever Dream
Cameron Kennedy played Rory, the dorky friend who actually wanted to be a vampire. It’s a hilarious subversion of the trope. Most people in horror movies are running away from monsters; Rory was running toward them because he thought it would make him cool. Kennedy’s physical comedy was a highlight of the film.
Kate Todd played Erica.
Erica was the best friend who fully embraced the dark side. She was a "vampire's vampire." Todd was already a known face in Canada thanks to Radio Free Roscoe, and she brought a certain level of edge to the movie. She wasn't just a sidekick; she was a chaotic force. Todd eventually transitioned more into music, releasing country albums, which is a pretty cool pivot from playing a bloodthirsty teenager.
Then you have the "villain" of the movie, Jesse, played by Joe Dinicol.
He was the quintessential 2010s bad boy vampire. Leather jacket? Check. Soul patch? Check. Sinister plan to take over the town? Obviously. Dinicol has had a massive career since then, appearing in Arrow as Ragman and in various other high-profile series like Blindspot and Grey's Anatomy. He played Jesse with a smirk that made you hate him but also kind of understand why the high schoolers were intimidated by him.
Why the Casting Felt Different
Most teen movies at the time were trying way too hard to be "cool." This movie didn't.
The cast felt like actual teenagers. They had bad hair, awkward clothes, and they didn't always say the right thing. This authenticity is a huge reason why the movie transitioned so well into a TV series. When you look at the My Babysitter’s a Vampire movie cast, you see a group of actors who were clearly having fun. They weren't just checking boxes for a paycheck.
📖 Related: When Was Kai Cenat Born? What You Didn't Know About His Early Life
There’s a specific scene in the movie where they’re at the school dance, and the stakes (pun intended) are high, but the banter never stops. That’s hard to pull off. If the actors don't have chemistry, the jokes fall flat. But Mitchell, Knight, and Morgan worked like a well-oiled machine.
A Quick Look at the Main Players
- Matthew Knight (Ethan): The psychic leader. Now largely retired from acting.
- Vanessa Morgan (Sarah): The heart of the group. Currently a major TV star (Riverdale, The Shannara Chronicles).
- Atticus Mitchell (Benny): The magic expert. Continues to work in prestige TV and film.
- Cameron Kennedy (Rory): The comic relief. Also took a step back from the industry after the show's run.
- Kate Todd (Erica): The resident "mean girl" vampire. Now a successful musician.
- Joe Dinicol (Jesse): The antagonist. A staple of modern network television dramas.
The Production Behind the Faces
Director Bruce McDonald and the writing team of Tim Burns and Tom McGillis (the minds behind Total Drama) knew exactly what they were doing. They took the "monster of the week" format and grounded it with characters people actually liked. Usually, in these types of movies, the parents are either non-existent or totally oblivious. In this case, the parents (played by Ari Cohen and Laura DeCarteret) were part of the charm. They were just trying to raise their kids in a town that happened to be a nexus for the supernatural.
The movie was shot in Toronto and Hamilton, Ontario. If you watch closely, you can see that classic Canadian "suburban" aesthetic that defined so many 2000s and 2010s shows. It gave the film a cozy, familiar feeling that balanced out the scenes of vampires exploding into dust.
Common Misconceptions About the Cast
One thing people get wrong is thinking the movie and the show had different casts.
Actually, the main ensemble stayed remarkably consistent. Usually, when a TV movie gets picked up for a full series, at least one or two major roles get recast due to scheduling or budget. Not here. The fact that they kept everyone—from the leads to the supporting geeks—allowed the world-building to feel seamless.
Another misconception? That it was a Disney project.
While it aired on Disney Channel in the U.S., it was actually a Fresh TV production from Canada. This is why the humor feels a bit "sharper" and less sanitized than your typical Wizards of Waverly Place episode. The cast was allowed to be a little bit more "teen" and a little less "child star."
👉 See also: Anjelica Huston in The Addams Family: What You Didn't Know About Morticia
The Enduring Legacy
Why are we still talking about the My Babysitter’s a Vampire movie cast in 2026?
It’s simple: the "teen supernatural" genre is currently in a weird place. Everything is either hyper-sexualized or extremely grim. People miss the era where a vampire movie could just be a fun, slightly spooky adventure with friends. The cast represented a time when teen TV felt adventurous and creative without needing a massive CGI budget.
Vanessa Morgan has even teased the idea of a reboot or a "where are they now" special on her social media over the years. The fans are still there. The "Benny and Ethan" dynamic is still a blueprint for how to write teenage boy friendships.
Actionable Steps for Fans and Collectors
If you're looking to dive back into the world of Whitechapel, here is what you should actually do:
- Check the International Cuts: Sometimes the Canadian versions (Teletoon) have slightly different edits or longer scenes than the Disney Channel US versions. If you can find the original DVD releases, they are worth grabbing for the "behind the scenes" footage of the cast.
- Follow the Cast on Social Media: Vanessa Morgan is very active and often shares throwback photos. Atticus Mitchell occasionally pops up in indie projects that are well worth a watch if you like his style of dry humor.
- Support the Creators: Fresh TV is still around. Following the producers and writers can give you a better idea of why the show ended so abruptly (spoiler: it was a cliffhanger that never got resolved, which still hurts).
- Analyze the Tropes: If you're a writer or a film student, look at how this movie uses "the seer," "the wizard," and "the fledgling." It’s a masterclass in establishing a magic system in under 90 minutes.
The movie wasn't just a springboard for Vanessa Morgan's career; it was a moment in time where Canadian television proved it could compete on a global scale by just being genuinely funny and well-cast. Whether you're a "Dusk" fan or you're just here for the nostalgia, the chemistry of this ensemble remains the reason the movie holds up today.
Next Steps to Explore:
Locate the original movie on streaming platforms like Netflix or Disney+ (availability varies by region) to see the cast's chemistry in action. For those interested in the technical side, researching the production history of Fresh TV offers great insight into how mid-budget Canadian hits are made. Finally, if you're a fan of Vanessa Morgan, comparing her performance as Sarah to her later work in Riverdale shows an impressive evolution of her acting range within the supernatural genre.