Let’s be real for a second. If you grew up in the early 2010s, your Friday nights probably involved a specific brand of Canadian supernatural chaos. I’m talking about the kind of show that didn’t take itself too seriously but somehow managed to nail the "teenagers fighting high school and literal demons" vibe better than most big-budget dramas. My Babysitter’s a Vampire started as a TV movie on Teletoon (and later Disney Channel) before exploding into a two-season cult classic. It was campy. It was self-aware. Honestly? The My Babysitter’s a Vampire cast had a chemistry that most Disney clones would kill for.
It has been over a decade since we last saw Ethan Morgan and his "seer" visions. Since then, the fans have never really stopped asking for a Season 3. While the show ended on a massive cliffhanger with a literal explosion that left everyone’s fate in the air, the actors have moved on to some pretty massive projects. Some stayed in the Canadian acting circuit, while others ended up in massive Netflix hits or even the Hallmark cinematic universe.
Matthew Knight as the Nerdy Seer Ethan Morgan
Matthew Knight was the heart of the show. He played Ethan, the dorky, slightly high-strung protagonist who realized his babysitter was a "fledgling" vampire. Knight was already a veteran child actor by the time he landed the role, having appeared in The Grudge 2 and Goosebumps.
His performance was peak "awkward teen." He had this specific way of playing Ethan that felt genuine—like a kid who actually enjoyed being a nerd rather than a writer's trope of one. After the show wrapped in 2012, Knight sort of pulled a vanishing act from the industry. Unlike many of his co-stars who pivoted into adult roles, he largely stepped away from the limelight. He did a few projects like The Good Witch movie series, playing Brandon Russell, but by the mid-2010s, he transitioned into a private life. It’s a bit of a bummer for fans who wanted to see him in more supernatural stuff, but honestly, retiring after a successful run is a power move.
Vanessa Morgan: From Fledgling to Riverdale Icon
If there is one breakout star from the My Babysitter’s a Vampire cast, it’s undoubtedly Vanessa Morgan. She played Sarah, the babysitter in question who was stuck in that awkward "I don't want to drink human blood" phase.
Vanessa’s career after Whitechapel has been massive. She didn't just stay in Canada; she jumped straight into the deep end of teen drama. Most people know her now as Toni Topaz from Riverdale. It’s funny because you can see the DNA of Sarah in Toni—both characters are tough, fiercely loyal, and don't take any nonsense from the boys around them.
💡 You might also like: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
Beyond Riverdale, she’s been everywhere:
- She competed on The Amazing Race Canada with her sister, Celina.
- She had a major role in the fantasy series The Shannara Chronicles.
- She’s become a massive social media personality and a mother, often sharing updates about her son, River.
Watching her go from a Disney-adjacent fledgling to a staple of the CW felt like a natural progression. She always had that "it" factor.
Atticus Mitchell and the Benny Weir Fanbase
You can't talk about Ethan without talking about Benny. Atticus Mitchell played the spell-casting best friend who was arguably the funniest part of the entire series. Benny was the guy who would try to fix a problem with magic and accidentally turn someone’s grandma into a lizard.
Atticus Mitchell is one of those actors who just works constantly. He stayed very active in the Canadian TV scene. If you’ve watched the critically acclaimed series Fargo, you might have spotted him in the first season as Mickey Hess. He also appeared in Killjoys, The Colony, and more recently, The Hardy Boys.
What’s cool about Atticus is that he hasn’t shied away from his roots. He’s done various interviews over the years acknowledging the show’s legacy. He’s also a musician, playing in a band called The Fishbowl. He’s managed to maintain that "alt-guy" vibe that made Benny so likable in the first place.
📖 Related: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
The Rest of the Whitechapel High Crew
Then we have Rory and Erica. Cameron Kennedy played Rory, the "accidental" vampire who was essentially a golden retriever in undead form. Rory was the comic relief, often the target of Benny’s failed spells. Like Matthew Knight, Kennedy has mostly stepped away from acting in recent years. His last major credits were around 2014-2015.
Kate Todd, who played the fierce and fashionable Erica, was already a Canadian TV staple thanks to Life with Derek. She brought a certain edge to the show—Erica actually liked being a vampire, which provided a great foil to Sarah’s constant moral struggling. Kate Todd has since pivoted more toward music, releasing country and pop tracks, and she’s also involved in voice acting and various media projects.
The Supporting Powerhouse: Joe Dinicol
We have to mention Joe Dinicol. He played Jesse, the villainous vampire ex-boyfriend who basically started all the trouble in the pilot movie. Dinicol is one of those "hey, it’s that guy" actors. He moved from My Babysitter's a Vampire to playing Rory Regan (Ragman) in Arrow. He also had a recurring role in Grey’s Anatomy. He’s a character actor who consistently delivers, and he gave the show a sense of real stakes early on.
Why the Cast Chemistry Worked So Well
Most teen shows from that era feel incredibly dated now. The dialogue is cringey, and the acting is stiff. But My Babysitter’s a Vampire holds up surprisingly well. Why? Because the My Babysitter’s a Vampire cast felt like actual friends.
They weren't 25-year-olds playing 14-year-olds. They were young, they were energetic, and they clearly enjoyed the absurdity of the scripts. When Benny and Ethan bickered, it felt like real high school banter. When Sarah looked annoyed at their stupidity, it felt genuine. This authenticity is likely why the show still does numbers on streaming platforms and why TikTok is full of "Where are they now?" edits.
👉 See also: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
The show thrived on its low-budget charm. It used practical effects when it could and leaned into the camp. The actors knew exactly what kind of show they were in. They didn't try to make it Twilight; they made it Whitechapel.
The Legacy of the Show in 2026
It’s been years, and yet the rumors of a revival never truly die. While there is nothing currently in official production, the cast remains supportive of one another. Vanessa Morgan and Atticus Mitchell have been seen together at conventions, and the fan base is arguably more active now than it was when the show was airing, thanks to the power of nostalgia.
In the world of reboots, this is one of the few shows where a "ten years later" special would actually make sense. Imagine Ethan as a professional paranormal investigator who still doesn't quite have his life together, or Sarah navigating the world as a "grown-up" vampire.
Actionable Steps for Fans and Collectors
If you're looking to dive back into the world of Whitechapel or want to keep up with the My Babysitter's a Vampire cast, here is how to stay in the loop:
- Follow the socials: Vanessa Morgan is the most active on Instagram and TikTok, providing the most frequent glimpses into her current life and past roles.
- Check Canadian Streaming: Depending on your region, the show often rotates through platforms like Netflix, Tubi, or the Roku Channel. In Canada, it frequently pops up on CTV’s digital platforms.
- Support Indie Projects: Many of the secondary cast members work in independent Canadian cinema. Keeping an eye on the Toronto International Film Festival (TIFF) lineups is a great way to see what Atticus Mitchell or Joe Dinicol are up to.
- Physical Media: Because licensing for teen shows can be a nightmare, the DVD sets of Season 1 and 2 are becoming collector's items. If you find them at a thrift store or a local media exchange, grab them. Digital rights for these shows often expire, leaving physical copies as the only way to ensure you can watch the "Lucia" episode whenever you want.
The show was a lightning-in-a-bottle moment for Canadian television. It proved you could make a supernatural teen comedy that was actually funny, slightly spooky, and deeply relatable. While the actors have grown up and moved on to different stages of their lives, the impact of their time in Whitechapel remains a core memory for a generation of viewers.