Honestly, it feels like forever ago that we were all obsessed with the supernatural vibes of Whitechapel. If you grew up in the early 2010s, My Babysitter’s a Vampire wasn't just another Disney Channel acquisition; it was a cult classic that actually leaned into the weirdness of Canadian horror-comedy. The My Babysitter's a Vampire cast had this chemistry that most teen shows would kill for, blending snarky dialogue with actual stakes—pun intended.
But here is the thing.
The show ended way too early. We got two seasons and a movie, and then... nothing. Silence. Since the cameras stopped rolling on the series finale back in 2012, the actors have taken some wild turns in their careers. Some stayed in the spotlight, while others basically vanished into the indie scene or behind-the-scenes work.
Matthew Knight as Ethan Morgan: The Seer Who Stepped Away
Matthew Knight was the heart of the show. He played Ethan Morgan, the "fledgling" seer who just wanted to survive high school without getting bitten by his babysitter. Knight was already a veteran child actor by the time he landed the role, having appeared in The Grudge 2 and The Grudge 3. He brought a certain vulnerability to Ethan that made the character relatable, even when he was seeing psychic visions of the apocalypse.
However, if you’re looking for his recent IMDb credits, you’re going to be disappointed. Matthew Knight has largely retreated from the public eye. His last major acting credit was around 2013-2014. It’s a common story in the industry; sometimes, after a decade of working as a kid, you just want a normal life. There have been rumors and scattered social media posts over the years, but Knight has successfully transitioned into a private life away from the Hollywood (or Toronto) machine. He didn't burn out; he just moved on.
Vanessa Morgan: From Fledgling Vampire to Riverdale Royalty
If you follow mainstream TV at all, you know exactly where Vanessa Morgan went. Playing Sarah, the "fledgling" vampire who refused to drink human blood, Morgan was the breakout star of the My Babysitter's a Vampire cast. She managed to balance the "tough girl" persona with a genuine warmth that kept the show grounded.
After Whitechapel, Vanessa didn't slow down. She had a stint on Finding Carter and The Shannara Chronicles, but her massive break came when she joined the cast of Riverdale as Toni Topaz. She didn't just play a character; she became a fan favorite and a voice for diversity on the show. Morgan was vocal about the need for better representation for Black actors in the writers' room, which actually led to meaningful changes in how her character was handled.
📖 Related: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
She’s a mom now, too. She’s been very open about her journey through pregnancy while filming a high-octane drama. Honestly, it's pretty cool to see how she’s navigated the jump from a Canadian teen show to a global pop-culture phenomenon. She’s easily the most "famous" member of the original group today.
Atticus Mitchell: Benny Weir and the Transition to Indie Grit
Benny was the best. Everyone knows a Benny—the guy who thinks he’s way more competent at magic (or life) than he actually is. Atticus Mitchell played the spell-casting best friend with a perfect comedic timing that kept the show from getting too dark.
Mitchell's career post-vampires has been fascinating because he stayed in the industry but chose really gritty, interesting projects. You might have spotted him in the first season of the Fargo TV series, where he played one of the Hess brothers. It was a complete 180 from the goofy kid in Whitechapel.
He also appeared in Killjoys and The Expanse. He seems to gravitate toward sci-fi and genre fiction, which makes sense given his roots. Unlike some actors who try to distance themselves from their "teen" roles, Mitchell has always seemed to embrace the cult following of the show while quietly building a resume that proves he’s a serious character actor.
Kate Todd: Erica’s Life After the Fangs
Erica was the vampire who actually liked being a vampire. Kate Todd played her with a sharp, mean-girl-with-a-heart-of-gold energy that was essential to the show's dynamic. But while she was great in front of the camera, Todd’s real passion has always been music.
She’s a country singer.
👉 See also: The Lil Wayne Tracklist for Tha Carter 3: What Most People Get Wrong
Actually, she was making music even while the show was airing. Since the series wrapped, she’s released albums like Finding My Way and has won several awards in the Canadian country music scene. She hasn't totally quit acting—she’s done voice work and appeared in some smaller projects—but if you want to know what she’s up to, you’re better off checking Spotify than Netflix. It’s a classic pivot, and she seems much more at home with a guitar than a set of plastic fangs.
The Supporting Players: Cameron Kennedy and Beyond
Let’s talk about Rory. Cameron Kennedy played the high-energy, slightly delusional vampire who provided the bulk of the physical comedy. Kennedy was a standout, but like Matthew Knight, he hasn't been super active in the mainstream acting world lately. He’s done some theater and smaller roles, but he’s largely stayed out of the "celeb" spotlight.
Then there’s Joe Dinicol, who played the villainous Jesse in the movie and made appearances in the show. Dinicol has had a very solid career, most notably playing Rory Regan (Ragman) on Arrow. He’s one of those "hey, it’s that guy" actors who pops up in everything from Blindspot to Grey's Anatomy. He brought a certain level of gravitas to the My Babysitter's a Vampire cast that helped the show feel more like a legitimate supernatural drama and less like a parody.
Why the Show Still Has a Grip on Us
You might wonder why we are still talking about a show that ended over a decade ago. It’s simple. My Babysitter’s a Vampire arrived at the peak of the vampire craze (post-Twilight, mid-Vampire Diaries) but it didn't take itself too seriously. It was self-aware.
The chemistry of the My Babysitter's a Vampire cast felt real because, by all accounts, they were actually friends. You can't fake that kind of rapport. The show also benefitted from the Canadian television model—shorter seasons, tighter writing, and a specific kind of low-budget charm that forced the creators to rely on character development rather than expensive CGI.
Common Misconceptions About the "Missing" Season 3
There is a lot of misinformation online about a "lost" Season 3. Let's set the record straight:
✨ Don't miss: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong
- Was it cancelled? Sort of. It wasn't officially "axed" in a dramatic fashion, but the funding and production cycles just never aligned for a third season.
- The "Movie" Rumors: For years, fans have campaigned for a wrap-up movie. While the cast has expressed interest in a reunion, there is currently nothing in active development.
- The "Lost Scripts": Fans often claim there are finished scripts for Season 3 floating around. While the writers certainly had ideas and outlines, no full season was ever produced or filmed in secret.
What You Can Do Now as a Fan
If you’re feeling nostalgic for the My Babysitter's a Vampire cast, you don't have to just scroll through old Tumblr tags. There are actually a few ways to support the actors and relive the show in a way that actually matters in 2026.
First, check out Vanessa Morgan’s latest work on The CW or her social media, where she’s quite active. If you want to see the "serious" side of the cast, track down Atticus Mitchell’s roles in Fargo or The Colony. It’s a great way to see how these actors have evolved their craft.
Secondly, the show is often available on streaming platforms like Netflix or Disney+ depending on your region. Rewatching it through official channels actually helps signal to networks that there is still an audience for this kind of content. That is how "revivals" happen. Look at iCarly or That '90s Show. If the numbers are there, the suits eventually take notice.
Finally, keep an eye on the Canadian indie film scene. Many of the supporting actors and crew members from the show are still very active in the Toronto film community. Supporting Canadian media is the best way to ensure we get more "weird" shows like this in the future.
Actionable Insights for Fans:
- Follow the music: Check out Kate Todd's discography on streaming services to support her career post-acting.
- Stream officially: Watch the series on licensed platforms to contribute to the show's "demand" metrics.
- Look for "The Expanse" or "Fargo": Specifically watch Atticus Mitchell’s episodes to see his range as an adult actor.
- Engagement: Join the subreddit or Discord communities—they are still active and often share rare behind-the-scenes clips that aren't on YouTube.
The legacy of the My Babysitter's a Vampire cast isn't just about a show that ended too soon. It's about a group of young actors who captured a specific moment in time and have since gone on to build diverse, interesting lives. Whether they are leading a hit drama, singing country music, or choosing a life of privacy, they’ve all left a mark on a generation of fans who still check under the bed for vampires—or at least for a really good babysitter.