Honestly, it feels like just yesterday we were all watching Ethan Morgan try to navigate high school while his babysitter literally craved his blood. My Babysitter’s a Vampire was that rare lightning-in-a-bottle moment for Teletoon and Disney Channel. It didn't try too hard. It was campy, a little dark for its age group, and had a cast that actually felt like they liked each other. People still hunt for news about a revival because the chemistry was just that good.
When you look back at the My Babysitter’s a Vampire cast, it’s wild to see how many of them stayed in the industry versus those who kind of slipped into the background of "normal" life. We’re talking about a group of Canadian actors who became global faces for a specific generation of horror-comedy fans.
The Core Trio: Matthew Knight, Vanessa Morgan, and Atticus Mitchell
Matthew Knight played Ethan Morgan. He was the "Seer," the dork with a heart of gold who accidentally stumbled into a supernatural underworld in Whitechapel. Knight was a veteran child actor before this, having appeared in The Grudge 2. But after the show and the movie wrapped, he basically disappeared from the limelight. He chose a path away from the cameras. You won't find him on a Netflix series or a Marvel movie. He just... lived his life. It’s a rare move in an industry that demands you stay relevant 24/7.
Then there's Vanessa Morgan. She played Sarah, the fledgling vampire who refused to give in to her instincts. Vanessa is arguably the biggest breakout star from the My Babysitter’s a Vampire cast. Most people know her now as Toni Topaz from Riverdale. She’s stayed in the CW/Teen drama sphere for years, becoming a huge advocate for diversity in casting along the way. She’s a mom now, she’s a social media powerhouse, and she’s arguably the person most likely to say "yes" if a reunion ever actually happened.
Atticus Mitchell, who played Benny Weir, was the comedic engine of the show. Benny was the spellmaster who usually messed up his spells. Mitchell has had a really interesting career trajectory. He didn't go the "teen heartthrob" route. Instead, he leaned into more indie and prestige projects. You might have spotted him in the first season of Fargo or the high-concept series Killjoys. He has this specific, quirky energy that directors seem to love. He’s kept working steadily in the Canadian film industry, which is a tough nut to crack.
The Supporting Players and Villains
We can't talk about the cast without mentioning Kate Todd. She played Erica, the vampire who actually enjoyed being a vampire. Kate was already a "Disney Channel Canada" legend from Life with Derek. After the show, she focused heavily on her music career, releasing country albums and occasionally doing voice work. She’s got a very different vibe now than the leather-clad snarky teen we saw on screen.
💡 You might also like: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong
Cameron Kennedy played Rory. Every show needs a "Rory." He was the comic relief who actually turned into a vampire and thought it was the coolest thing ever. Like Matthew Knight, Cameron isn't super active in the Hollywood scene anymore. He did some work in Life with Boys and a few other projects, but he’s largely moved on from the industry.
Then there’s the adult cast. Joe Dinicol played Jesse, the main antagonist. He’s been everywhere. You’ve seen him in Arrow as Ragman and in Halt and Catch Fire. He’s one of those "hey, it’s that guy" actors who works constantly because he’s incredibly reliable.
Why the Chemistry Worked (And Why Fans Still Care)
The reason the My Babysitter’s a Vampire cast stuck in our heads isn't just because of the scripts. It was the "it" factor. In the early 2010s, everything was trying to be Twilight. Everything was moody and blue-tinted and serious. This show wasn't that. It was bright, it was funny, and the actors played it with a wink to the audience.
- They actually looked like teenagers.
- The banter felt improvised (even when it wasn't).
- There was a genuine friendship between the "Big Three."
If you go back and watch the behind-the-scenes clips from 2011 or 2012, you see them joking around in a way that doesn't feel forced by a PR team. That authenticity translates through the screen. It’s why people are still writing fanfiction and demanding a Season 3 over a decade later.
Navigating the "Canadian Actor" Path
It’s important to understand that most of this cast followed the classic "Toronto to LA" pipeline—or consciously chose not to. Being a successful actor in Canada is a specific kind of grind. You do the guest spots on Degrassi, you get a lead in a Teletoon show, and then you have to decide if you want to move to California.
📖 Related: Questions From Black Card Revoked: The Culture Test That Might Just Get You Roasted
Vanessa Morgan made the jump and succeeded. Joe Dinicol made the jump and became a character actor staple. Others, like Matthew Knight, seemingly decided that the child-star life was enough and stepped away. There is a lot of respect in that. To walk away from fame when you're at the top of a cult hit is a bold move.
Real Talk: Will There Ever Be a Reboot?
Everyone asks this. Every time Vanessa Morgan posts a throwback photo, the comments explode. Here’s the reality: the rights to the show are a bit of a mess. It was a co-production. Plus, the cast has aged out of the "babysitter" demographic.
However, we’re in the era of the "legacy sequel." If iCarly can come back and Wizards of Waverly Place can get a sequel series, why not this? Imagine an adult Ethan and Sarah dealing with supernatural threats in a modern, tech-heavy world.
- Vanessa Morgan has expressed interest multiple times in interviews.
- The fan base is now in their 20s and 30s with disposable income (advertisers love this).
- The "monster of the week" format is making a comeback on streaming services.
If a reboot happened, it would likely need to be a "next generation" thing, with the original cast returning as mentors. But let's be real—without the original My Babysitter’s a Vampire cast, it wouldn't be the same. You can’t just replace that specific group of people and expect the same magic.
What to Watch if You Miss the Cast
If you’re feeling nostalgic and want to see what the gang is up to now, check out these projects:
👉 See also: The Reality of Sex Movies From Africa: Censorship, Nollywood, and the Digital Underground
- Vanessa Morgan: Riverdale (obviously) or the movie Pimp.
- Atticus Mitchell: The Colony or The Hardy Boys (2020 series).
- Joe Dinicol: Arrow (Season 5) or Grey's Anatomy.
- Kate Todd: Her YouTube channel, where she shares her music and life updates.
Actionable Next Steps for Fans
If you want to support the cast or help keep the dream of a revival alive, there are actually things you can do that aren't just shouting into the void of Twitter.
First, stream the show on official platforms. Numbers matter. When Disney+ or other streamers see a spike in views for an old property, it triggers an internal metric. If "My Babysitter's a Vampire" starts trending in the "popular" section, executives notice.
Second, follow the cast on their current ventures. Support Vanessa’s new projects or Atticus’s indie films. Showing that the fan base is still active and loyal helps them pitch new projects.
Finally, check out the TV movie. A lot of people forget there was a pilot movie that started it all. It has a slightly different tone and is a great way to see how the characters were originally envisioned before the series smoothed out the edges.
The legacy of the My Babysitter’s a Vampire cast is one of the more wholesome "where are they now" stories in Hollywood. No major scandals, no public meltdowns—just a group of talented people who made something special, moved on, or leveled up. Whether we ever see them back in Whitechapel or not, they’ve definitely left their mark on the genre.