June 12, 1994, started out as a totally normal Sunday in Brentwood. It was warm. Nicole Brown Simpson had just watched her daughter’s dance recital. She ate dinner with her family at Mezzaluna. Everything seemed fine until it wasn't. By midnight, the murder scene of nicole brown would become the most famous, and arguably the most scrutinized, patch of sidewalk in American history.
If you walk past 875 South Bundy Drive today, it looks different. The address was actually changed to throw off tourists. But back then, it was a Mediterranean-style condo with a gated walkway. That walkway became a literal river of blood. Honestly, the sheer amount of physical evidence left behind is still staggering to look at thirty years later. People talk about the trial like it was just a TV show, but the reality on the ground was a nightmare of forensic details and missed opportunities.
The First Officers on the Scene
The bodies weren't found by the police. A white Akita with bloody paws—Nicole’s dog—led neighbors to the gate. When LAPD officers arrived at 12:13 AM, they found Nicole Brown Simpson lying face down at the base of the stairs. She was wearing a short black dress. She was barefoot.
The ferocity of the attack was terrifying. According to the autopsy report by Dr. Lakshmanan Sathyavagiswaran, the final wound to her neck was so deep it severed both carotid arteries. She had almost been decapitated. Just a few feet away, Ron Goldman’s body was slumped against a fence and a tree. He’d been stabbed nearly 30 times.
What the Investigators Found
It’s kinda wild how much stuff was just lying there in the open. Detectives noted several key items immediately:
🔗 Read more: Does Emmanuel Macron Have Children? The Real Story of the French President’s Family Life
- A dark blue knit cap.
- A blood-stained left-hand leather glove (Aris Isotoner, size XL).
- A white envelope containing the eyeglasses Nicole’s mother had left at the restaurant earlier.
- A set of keys belonging to Goldman.
- A beeper.
Beside the bodies was a trail of bloody shoe prints. These weren't just any prints. They were from a size 12 Bruno Magli shoe, a rare and expensive Italian brand. There were also drops of blood to the left of these prints. This suggested the killer was bleeding from their left hand as they walked away.
The Evidence That Defined a Decade
The murder scene of nicole brown wasn't just about the bodies; it was about the DNA. This was 1994. DNA testing was relatively new to the public. The prosecution eventually presented a "mountain of evidence," but the way it was handled at the scene created a loophole big enough for a "Dream Team" of lawyers to drive a truck through.
Basically, the LAPD made some rookie mistakes. They used a blanket from inside Nicole’s house to cover her body, which potentially contaminated the scene with hair and fibers from the home. They didn't photograph everything with scales for measurement. Some evidence sat in a hot van for hours.
The Glove and the Socks
We all know the "if it doesn't fit, you must acquit" line. But the forensic reality of the gloves was complex. The left glove was found at the Bundy scene, soaked in the blood of both victims. The right glove was found hours later at O.J. Simpson’s Rockingham estate by Detective Mark Fuhrman.
💡 You might also like: Judge Dana and Keith Cutler: What Most People Get Wrong About TV’s Favorite Legal Couple
Fibers on the Rockingham glove included:
- Hairs consistent with Nicole Brown.
- Hairs consistent with Ron Goldman.
- Dog hair from an Akita.
- Fibers from a 1993-1994 Ford Bronco carpet.
That last one is a big deal. It linked the murder scene directly to O.J.'s car. Inside his bedroom at Rockingham, police found a pair of black socks. Forensic testing found blood from both O.J. and Nicole on them. The defense famously argued this was planted, pointing to the presence of EDTA—a preservative used in lab vials. However, the FBI later testified that the EDTA levels were consistent with what occurs naturally in human blood or common household products.
Why the Scene Still Matters
The investigation changed how police work is done today. It was a brutal lesson in "Chain of Custody." If you can't prove exactly who touched a piece of blood-stained carpet from the moment it was found to the moment it hit the lab, the evidence is vulnerable.
The murder scene of nicole brown also highlighted the intersection of domestic violence and homicide. Nicole had called the police multiple times in the years leading up to her death. There were photos of her bruised face from 1989. For many experts, like Lt. Dan Marcou, the crime scene at Bundy was the tragic, predictable end of a long cycle of abuse.
📖 Related: The Billy Bob Tattoo: What Angelina Jolie Taught Us About Inking Your Ex
Analyzing the Timeline
The window for these murders was incredibly tight.
- 9:50 PM: Goldman leaves Mezzaluna.
- 10:15 PM: Neighbors hear a dog barking "plaintively."
- 10:40 PM: Kato Kaelin hears three loud thumps on the wall of his guest house at Rockingham.
- 10:55 PM: A dogwalker finds the Akita.
That means the killer had roughly 20 to 30 minutes to commit a double homicide, leave a trail of evidence, drive home, and potentially clean up before a limo driver arrived at 10:25 PM. It's a timeline that still fuels debates in true crime circles to this day.
Actionable Insights for True Crime Researchers
If you are looking to understand the forensic side of this case better, here is what you should do next:
- Review the Autopsy Reports: Specifically look for the "defensive wounds" on Ron Goldman’s hands. They tell a story of a much longer struggle than the one Nicole faced.
- Study the EDTA Testimony: Read the transcripts from FBI agent Roger Martz. It explains the science behind the "planted evidence" theory and why the jury found it so confusing.
- Examine the Bruno Magli Photos: Look up the civil trial evidence. Photos surfaced after the criminal trial showing O.J. wearing the exact "ugly" shoes he claimed he never owned.
- Visit Forensic Archives: Many universities use the OJ case as a "what not to do" guide for evidence collection. Search for "LAPD evidence mishandling OJ Simpson" to see the specific protocol changes that resulted from this trial.