Honestly, sequels are a bit of a gamble. The Muppets even sang about it. Right at the start of the 2014 flick, they literally belt out a song called "We’re Doing a Sequel" where they admit the second one is never quite as good. But looking back at the Muppet Most Wanted cast, you've gotta wonder if they were just being humble. The sheer volume of talent crammed into this 112-minute caper is actually kind of ridiculous.
We aren't just talking about a few puppets and a lead actor. This was a massive, globe-trotting production that pulled in everyone from A-list Oscar winners to obscure indie favorites. It’s a weird, beautiful mess of a movie.
The Human Leads: More Than Just Sidekicks
In most Muppet movies, the humans are there to provide a grounded "straight man" for the felt-covered chaos. But in this one? The humans are almost as cartoonish as the puppets.
✨ Don't miss: Who Plays Skyler White: What Most People Get Wrong About Anna Gunn
Ricky Gervais plays Dominic Badguy. It’s pronounced "Bad-gee," he’ll tell you. He’s the world’s second most dangerous criminal, playing second fiddle to Constantine (the evil Kermit look-alike). Gervais is basically doing his classic droll, slightly uncomfortable schtick, but it works perfectly when he’s tap-dancing with a frog. He’s gone on record saying he’d do anything with a frog, which is a bit of a weird motto, but hey, it made for a great "I’m Number Two" musical number.
Then there's Tina Fey. She plays Nadya, the high-ranking, Russian-accented guard at Gulag 38B. She’s obsessed with Kermit—not as a hero, but as the perfect inmate to lead her prison talent show. Her performance is pure high-energy camp. If you’ve ever wanted to see the creator of 30 Rock sing a song about "The Big House" while surrounded by hardened criminals, this is your movie.
Ty Burrell rounds out the main trio as Jean Pierre Napoleon. He’s a French Interpol agent who is essentially a living caricature of Inspector Clouseau. He spends the whole movie facing off with Sam Eagle in a "who has the bigger badge" contest. Their chemistry is actually one of the highlights of the film, especially during the investigation of the museum heists.
The Puppet Performers Behind the Magic
While we see the characters, the real stars are the puppeteers. This film was a major milestone for the core Muppet team.
- Steve Whitmire: At the time, he was still the voice of Kermit the Frog. He also handled Statler, Beaker, and Rizzo.
- Eric Jacobson: He’s the powerhouse behind Miss Piggy, Fozzie Bear, Sam Eagle, and Animal. The range required to go from Piggy’s diva antics to Animal’s drumming is insane.
- Matt Vogel: This was really his movie. He played the villain, Constantine. He had to play a character who was pretending to be Kermit, but doing it with a thick European accent and a mole. Vogel also voiced Floyd Pepper and Sweetums.
- Dave Goelz: The legend. He’s been around since the beginning and still voiced Gonzo, Bunsen Honeydew, and Waldorf.
It's kinda wild to think that just five or six people are responsible for nearly every "personality" you see in the Muppets troupe. They aren't just doing voices; they’re doing high-level choreography while cramped under floorboards or hidden behind furniture.
That Massive List of Cameos (And Who You Missed)
The Muppet Most Wanted cast is famous—or maybe infamous—for having over 30 celebrity cameos. Some are blink-and-you’ll-miss-it, while others are full-blown musical numbers.
The Gulag alone is a goldmine of "Wait, is that...?" moments. You’ve got Ray Liotta, Danny Trejo, and Jemaine Clement playing prisoners. Seeing Ray Liotta—the guy from Goodfellas—singing and dancing in a Russian prison is the kind of fever dream only the Muppets can provide. Tom Hiddleston even pops up as "The Great Escapo," a magician inmate who gets about five seconds of screen time.
💡 You might also like: Calvin Payne: Why the House of Payne Star Still Frustrates (and Hooks) Us
In the "blink and you'll miss it" category:
- James McAvoy as a UPS delivery guy.
- Saoirse Ronan as a ballet dancer (she’s actually Irish-American, which fits the Dublin stop of the tour).
- Chloë Grace Moretz as a newspaper girl.
- Usher playing... well, an usher. It’s a terrible pun. Everybody knows it.
Then you have the musical heavyweights. Celine Dion appears as a "Piggy Fairy Godmother" to sing a duet with Miss Piggy. Lady Gaga and Tony Bennett show up right at the beginning. Even Josh Groban is there, though he spends most of the movie as a nameless prisoner in a maximum-security box until he finally gets to belt out a high note at the end.
Why This Cast Mattered for the Franchise
This movie felt different than the 2011 reboot. That one was all about nostalgia and "saving the Muppets." This one? This was the Muppets getting back to their roots of being a bit weird, a bit cynical, and very meta.
By leaning so heavily on a human cast like Gervais and Fey, the movie tried to bridge the gap between "kid's movie" and "satirical comedy." It didn't always work—some critics at the time felt the Muppets themselves got pushed to the sidelines in favor of the human subplots. But if you look at the ensemble as a whole, it’s a tribute to the "Variety Show" format that Jim Henson originally intended.
✨ Don't miss: Lil Nas X Uncensored: Why Everyone Is Still Talking About Him in 2026
The movie also gave a lot of "lost" Muppets a chance to shine. We saw more of the Electric Mayhem, and even 80's Robot made a comeback. It’s a deep dive into the puppet archives.
Your Next Steps for a Muppet Marathon
If you're planning to rewatch this or dive into the franchise for the first time, don't just stop at the credits. There’s a lot more to explore:
- Check out the Extended Cut: There are several cameos and jokes (like a bit with Dexter Fletcher) that only appear in the "Statler and Waldorf" cut of the film.
- Listen to the Soundtrack: Bret McKenzie (of Flight of the Conchords) wrote the songs for this. "I'm Number Two" and "Together Again" (not the 1984 one, the new one) are genuine earworms.
- Track the Evolution: Watch the 2011 The Muppets first, then Most Wanted, and then the short-lived 2015 TV series The Muppets. It shows a fascinating arc of how the performers were trying to modernize these characters for a 21st-century audience.
The Muppet Most Wanted cast remains one of the most eclectic groups ever assembled for a family film. Whether you're there for the puppets or the bizarre sight of Christoph Waltz dancing the waltz, it's a testament to the fact that everybody in Hollywood still wants to play with the Muppets.
Actionable Insight: To get the most out of the cameos, watch the "We're Doing a Sequel" opening sequence carefully. It features several quick appearances that set the tone for the entire "celebrity-heavy" nature of the film.