If you grew up in East Tennessee, the name Mr. Gatti’s probably triggers a very specific sensory memory. You can smell the yeast from the dough, hear the chaotic clatter of tokens hitting a metal tray, and see that dim, neon-lit arcade glow. But here is the thing: a lot of people think the Mr. Gatti’s in Halls is just a relic of the 90s.
They’re wrong.
Actually, the spot at 6903 Maynardville Pike is very much alive in 2026. While so many other buffet chains folded or turned into sad, empty shells of their former selves, the Halls location has managed to hang on to its "neighborhood staple" status. It’s weirdly consistent. You go there for a birthday party when you're seven, and then you find yourself back there at twenty-seven because, honestly, that Dutch Apple Treat pizza still hits the same.
The Secret Sauce (Literally)
Most people assume all cheap pizza is created equal. It isn't. Mr. Gatti’s has always been a bit of an outlier because of the cheese. They don't use the standard bags of shredded mozzarella that most chains buy in bulk. They use smoked provolone.
📖 Related: Why Zip Code New Braunfels TX Isn’t as Simple as You Think
That one choice changes the entire flavor profile. It gives the pizza a bit of a "tang" that sets it apart from the greasier, saltier options down the road. The dough is another story. They still make it fresh every day—yeast-risen, hand-rolled. You can tell. It’s got that chewy, bready texture that stands up to the buffet heat lamps better than the cardboard-crust competitors.
What to Actually Eat on the Buffet
If you’re walking in and just grabbing the first slice of pepperoni you see, you’re doing it wrong. To get the most out of the Mr. Gatti’s Halls TN experience, you have to be strategic.
- The Gatti’s Deluxe: It’s the heavy hitter. Pepperoni, mild sausage, mushrooms, onions, bell peppers, and black olives. It’s balanced.
- The Sampler: This is basically every meat they have in the building on one slice. It’s aggressive, but if you’re hungry, it’s the move.
- Macaroni and Cheese Pizza: Sounds like a fever dream. Tastes like childhood. Kids will fight you for the last slice of this.
- Custom Requests: A lot of people don't realize you can actually ask the staff to throw a specific pizza on the buffet. If you want a Spinach Alfredo or a BBQ Chicken pizza and it’s not out there, just ask. They’re usually cool about it.
The Arcade: Nostalgia vs. Reality
The game room at the Halls location is actually bigger than the one in Maryville. It’s about 2,200 square feet of "I hope I win enough tickets for a plastic spider."
In 2026, the arcade landscape has shifted. You’ve got Dave & Buster’s and these high-end "bar-cades," but Mr. Gatti’s stays in its lane. It’s built for families who don't want to spend $100 on three games. Some of the games are still as low as thirty or forty cents. It’s one of the few places left where a $10 game card actually lasts more than five minutes.
The "Gatti Goods" redemption counter is still the final destination. Sure, the prizes are mostly trinkets, but for a kid in Halls, those tickets are basically currency. It’s the ritual that matters.
Why Halls Stays Loyal
Halls Crossroads is a tight-knit community. People here value things that stick around. The Mr. Gatti’s on Maynardville Pike has survived because it’s a "third place"—somewhere that isn't home and isn't work (or school).
It’s where the Little League teams go after a win at the Halls Community Park. It’s where grandparents take the grandkids on a rainy Tuesday because it’s climate-controlled and there’s a salad bar. Speaking of the salad bar—it’s surprisingly legit. While the kids are face-down in pepperoni, you’ll see plenty of adults building massive salads. It’s the "health" tax you pay so you can justify three slices of dessert pizza later.
Dealing With the Crowds
If you show up at 6:00 PM on a Friday night, be prepared. It’s going to be loud. There will be at least three birthday parties happening simultaneously. The air will be 40% oxygen and 60% excitement.
📖 Related: Little Blue Menu Menu: Why Chick-fil-A Is Experimenting With Wings and Burgers
If you want a quieter experience, go for a late lunch during the week. The buffet is still fresh, but the "screaming toddler" decibel level drops significantly. Plus, the staff usually has more time to make those custom pizza requests we talked about.
The Legend of the Dessert Pizza
We have to talk about the Dutch Apple Treat. It is the undisputed king of the Mr. Gatti’s menu. It’s essentially a giant apple pie disguised as a pizza, topped with that crumbly streusel and a drizzle of icing.
Then there’s the Chocolate Bavarian Cream pizza. It’s rich, messy, and arguably better than any actual dessert you’d find at a fancy Italian spot. They also do a "Very Cherry" version, but the Apple and Chocolate ones are the ones people actually remember decades later.
Practical Tips for Your Visit
- Check for Coupons: Before you head out, check their local site or social media. They almost always have "Family Four Pack" deals or "Game Card" bundles that save you a decent chunk of change.
- The To-Go Option: You don't have to eat the buffet. You can order a large pizza for pickup or delivery. Sometimes you just want that smoked provolone flavor without the arcade noise.
- Military and Senior Discounts: They offer these, so make sure to ask at the register.
- The TV Rooms: The Halls location has those classic separate dining rooms with the big screens. If there’s a big game on or if you just need to park the kids in front of cartoons while you eat in peace, head for one of those.
Mr. Gatti’s Halls TN isn't trying to be a five-star bistro. It knows exactly what it is: a place for hot pizza, cold drinks, and enough arcade games to keep the kids busy while you actually get to finish a conversation. In a world that keeps getting more expensive and complicated, there’s something genuinely nice about a place that hasn't changed its vibe in thirty years.
Your Next Steps:
Check the current buffet hours for the Halls location, as they can shift slightly on holidays. If you’re planning a birthday party, call at least two weeks in advance—those private rooms fill up fast, especially during soccer and baseball season. If you're just going for a meal, try a "Build Your Own" medium pizza to-go to experience the crust and cheese quality without the buffet distractions.