Movies Similar to Rise of the Guardians: What Most People Get Wrong

Rise of the Guardians didn't exactly set the world on fire when it hit theaters back in 2012. DreamWorks actually took a massive financial hit on it, which is wild considering how much people obsess over Jack Frost on Tumblr and TikTok these days. It has this specific "vibe"—it's not just a kids' movie. It’s a secret war story. It’s about the heavy burden of being a myth.

Finding movies similar to rise of the guardians is kinda tricky because most "holiday" movies are just fluffy. You probably aren't looking for another generic Santa story. You want that gritty, high-stakes fantasy where childhood legends feel like superheroes and the shadows actually bite.

The "Secret Society" Energy

If the best part of Guardians for you was seeing Santa with "Naughty" and "Nice" tattoos leading a tactical strike team, you need movies that treat magic like a hidden infrastructure.

Hellboy II: The Golden Army (2008) is basically the R-rated, live-action cousin of Rise of the Guardians. Guillermo del Toro does the "mythical beings living in the cracks of the modern world" better than anyone. Instead of the Tooth Fairy, you get the Troll Market—a sprawling, hidden bazaar underneath the Brooklyn Bridge. It’s got that same sense of wonder mixed with "we are the only thing standing between you and the apocalypse."

👉 See also: Nothing to Lose: Why the Martin Lawrence and Tim Robbins Movie is Still a 90s Classic

Then there’s Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse. Now, stick with me. Peter Ramsey, who directed Rise of the Guardians, also co-directed Spider-Verse. You can feel his DNA in both. It’s that story of an outsider—Miles Morales or Jack Frost—who doesn't know where he fits until he’s thrust into a team of legends. The kinetic energy and the feeling of "believing in yourself to unlock your powers" is identical.

When Folklore Gets Dark

Rise of the Guardians works because Pitch Black is actually scary. He’s not a bumbling villain; he’s an existential threat to joy. If you want that darker edge, check these out:

• Kubo and the Two Strings (2016): This is a masterpiece from Laika. It deals with Japanese folklore and has some of the most unsettling villains in animation (those Sisters still give me the creeps). Like Jack Frost, Kubo is a boy with a magical instrument trying to figure out his family legacy while being hunted by his own grandfather, the Moon King.
• Wolfwalkers (2020): Set in 16th-century Ireland, this movie treats "Wolfwalkers" as these mythic, disappearing spirits of the woods. The art style is breathtaking—it looks like a moving woodcut painting. It captures that "protecting the old magic from the cold, hard world" theme perfectly.
• The Secret of NIMH (1982): This one is for the fans who liked the slightly "off" feeling of the Guardians' world. It’s dark, it’s intense, and it treats its characters with immense respect. No "talking animal" tropes here; just high-stakes survival and mystical science.

Reimagining the Icons

Honestly, seeing "North" as a Russian swordsman was a stroke of genius. Very few movies take established legends and flip them like that.

✨ Don't miss: How Old Is Paul Heyman? The Real Story of Wrestling’s Greatest Mind

Arthur Christmas (2011) does a similar thing but with a more comedic, high-tech slant. It treats Christmas like a massive military operation with "S-1" stealth crafts and millions of elves with specialized roles. It’s less "battle for the soul of the world" and more "family drama in a high-tech bunker," but the world-building is top-tier.

If you’re okay with live-action, The Spiderwick Chronicles (2008) is a solid pick. It handles the "hidden world of creatures right under our noses" aspect very well. It’s got that specific 2000s fantasy grit where the stakes feel real for the kids involved.

Why We Keep Looking for This Vibe

We’re obsessed with these stories because they validate that feeling we had as kids—that there is something more happening just out of sight. Rise of the Guardians isn't really about Santa; it’s about the concept of "The Center." What is your core?

🔗 Read more: Howie Mandel Cupcake Picture: What Really Happened With That Viral Post

Most animated movies today are a bit too afraid to be sincere. They mask everything with layers of irony or pop-culture references. Guardians was dead serious about its mythology.

What to Watch Next Based on Your Favorite Character:

• If you loved Jack Frost: Watch Kubo and the Two Strings or Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse. Both nail the "lonely kid finds a family" arc.
• If you loved Bunny (the badass version): Try Hellboy II or even the How to Train Your Dragon trilogy. The bond between Hiccup and Toothless has that same "unlikely warrior" energy.
• If you loved Pitch Black: Dive into Coraline. It’s the gold standard for "the shadow world is trying to eat you."
• If you loved the Team Dynamic: Big Hero 6 is your best bet. It’s a group of misfits using their unique "centers" to stop a masked villain.

Go grab some popcorn. Start with Kubo if you want to be emotionally wrecked, or Hellboy II if you want to see some cool monsters. Both are miles better than the generic sequels usually suggested in these lists.

Check out the "Guardians of Childhood" book series by William Joyce if you haven't already. The movie is actually a sequel/reimagining of those books, and they go way deeper into the backstories of characters like the Man in the Moon and Katherine (who basically becomes Mother Goose). Reading the books changes how you see the movie entirely.