Honestly, if you spent your childhood trying to master the "New Classic" dance routine in your living room, you’re probably still chasing that specific brand of serotonin only a 2000s teen movie can provide. Another Cinderella Story (2008) wasn't just a Selena Gomez vehicle; it was a peak moment for the "modern fairy tale" subgenre. It traded glass slippers for a Zune—which, let's be real, is a hilarious time capsule now—and turned the traditional ball into a high-stakes masked dance-off.
People often think any movie with a makeover or a prom counts as a "similar movie," but they're usually wrong. To find actual movies similar to Another Cinderella Story, you have to look for that very specific trifecta: a musical or dance-heavy plot, a "hidden identity" romance, and a villainous guardian who is more campy than actually terrifying.
The Direct Successors: The Rest of the Franchise
If you want the most obvious starting point, you’ve got to look at the rest of the Cinderella Story anthology. These aren't sequels in the traditional sense. They’re more like "spiritual cousins" that share the same DNA but swap out the actors and the specific art form.
A Cinderella Story: Once Upon a Song (2011)
This one stars Lucy Hale from Pretty Little Liars. Instead of dancing, the focus shifts to singing. It’s got that classic trope where the "evil stepsister" lip-syncs to the protagonist's voice to win over the hot guy (played by Freddie Stroma). It hits all the same beats as Selena’s version, especially that feeling of being an overlooked talent living in a basement.
🔗 Read more: Mike Judge Presents: Tales from the Tour Bus Explained (Simply)
A Cinderella Story: If the Shoe Fits (2016)
Sofia Carson takes the lead here. It’s very meta because the plot involves a musical production of Cinderella within the movie itself. It leans heavily into the "servant girl turns superstar" vibe. If you liked the competitive audition energy of Mary Santiago’s story, this is basically that but with more sequins.
When Dance is the Real Love Interest
What made Another Cinderella Story stand out was the choreography. Mary Santiago wasn't just a girl who liked a guy; she was a dancer who used movement to find her voice. If that’s what you’re craving, these are the heavy hitters.
Step Up (2006)
Before Channing Tatum was a household name, he was Tyler Gage, a kid from the wrong side of the tracks who ends up at a performing arts school. It’s less "fairy tale" and more "gritty teen drama," but the chemistry is electric. The climax features a fusion of street dance and ballet that rivals the Joey Parker/Mary Santiago finale.
💡 You might also like: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Feel the Beat (2020)
Sofia Carson (again!) plays a failed Broadway dancer who returns to her small town to train a group of misfits. It’s got that modern, polished look and a very clear "underdog wins the big competition" narrative. It’s basically the 2020s version of a DCOM (Disney Channel Original Movie), even though it's on Netflix.
Work It (2020)
Sabrina Carpenter stars in this one. It’s about a girl who lies her way into a dance team and then has to actually learn how to dance. It captures that fun, slightly goofy energy of the late 2000s while feeling updated for today. The romance is sweet, but the focus remains on the joy of the performance.
The Modern Fairy Tale Archetype
Sometimes you don't care about the dancing. Sometimes you just want the "secret identity" or the "unlikely girl meets the famous boy" plot.
📖 Related: The Lil Wayne Tracklist for Tha Carter 3: What Most People Get Wrong
- A Cinderella Story (2004): You can't talk about Selena without mentioning Hilary Duff. This is the blueprint. Instead of a dance-off, they meet in a chat room. Instead of a Zune, she loses a cell phone. It’s the gold standard for a reason.
- The Princess Diaries (2001): It’s not a literal Cinderella retelling, but it follows the same "invisible girl becomes the center of the world" arc. Anne Hathaway’s Mia Thermopolis feels like a sister to Mary Santiago—clumsy, underestimated, and ultimately iconic.
- Sydney White (2007): Amanda Bynes stars in this modern take on Snow White. It’s set in a college sorority, and instead of seven dwarves, she has seven dorks. It has that same colorful, slightly exaggerated reality that makes these movies so watchable.
Why We Still Watch These "Cheesy" Movies
There’s a common misconception that people only watch these for nostalgia. That’s a part of it, sure. But these films actually tap into a very real psychological desire for meritocracy. We love seeing a character who is talented but suppressed finally get their "moment" in the sun.
In Another Cinderella Story, Mary doesn't just get the guy; she gets into the Manhattan Academy of Performing Arts. She escapes Dominique’s house. The "happily ever after" isn't just about a boyfriend; it’s about career autonomy. That’s why these movies still rank. They offer a sanitized, musical version of the "girlboss" journey before that term even existed.
Your Weekend Watchlist
If you're planning a marathon of movies similar to Another Cinderella Story, don't just stick to the obvious ones. Mix it up.
- The Musical Powerhouse: Hairspray (2007). It has that same "dancing as rebellion" theme and stars Zac Efron during his peak teen idol years.
- The Hidden Identity Fix: Monte Carlo (2011). Another Selena Gomez film where she plays two different people. It’s got the glamour, the romance, and the "commoner among royalty" trope.
- The Underrated Gem: Starstruck (2010). A Disney Channel original about a regular girl who accidentally spends a day with the world's biggest pop star. It’s almost a beat-for-beat match for the Mary/Joey dynamic.
The best way to enjoy these is to lean into the tropes. Don't look for realism. Look for the sparkle, the choreographed hallways, and the inevitable moment where the mean girl gets her comeuppance in front of the whole school.
To get started, check your streaming platforms for the Cinderella Story sequels first, as they often hop between Max and Netflix. If you've seen those, move on to the 2020-era Netflix dance films like Feel the Beat to see how the genre has evolved into the current decade.