Finding movies like The Notebook on Netflix is a bit of a moving target because the licensing deals change faster than a summer romance in Seabrook. You know the feeling. You’ve just finished watching Allie and Noah scream at each other in the rain, and suddenly, you need that specific brand of "love against all odds" or you won't be able to sleep. It’s that Nicholas Sparks itch. It’s the high-stakes longing, the gorgeous cinematography, and the inevitable realization that time is the real villain in every romance.
Netflix knows this. They’ve spent millions trying to recreate that 1940s-era yearning with their own original films, though some hit closer to the mark than others. Honestly, nothing quite replaces Ryan Gosling’s beard or Rachel McAdams’ iconic blue dress, but there are plenty of stories on the platform right now that explore the same themes of class divide, letters that never arrived, and love that survives for decades.
Why we keep searching for movies like The Notebook on Netflix
It’s about the "what if." Nicholas Sparks tapped into a universal anxiety with the original 1996 novel and the subsequent 2004 film. What if the one who got away came back? What if your parents were wrong about that "poor boy" from the lumber yard?
Most people looking for movies like The Notebook on Netflix are actually looking for a few specific tropes. They want the period costumes. They want the sweeping orchestral scores. But mostly, they want the emotional payoff of a love that is tested by something much bigger than a simple misunderstanding—usually something like war, illness, or a massive wealth gap.
The Last Letter from Your Lover (2021)
If you haven't seen this one yet, start here. It is arguably the closest thing Netflix has to a spiritual successor to the Allie and Noah saga. Based on the novel by Jojo Moyes (the powerhouse behind Me Before You), it follows a dual-timeline narrative. Shailene Woodley plays Jennifer Stirling in the 1960s, a woman caught in a stifling marriage who begins a whirlwind affair with a journalist.
The parallel? A modern-day journalist, played by Felicity Jones, finds their old love letters and tries to piece together what happened. It has everything. Secret meetings. Gorgeous 1960s fashion that rivals Allie’s wardrobe. A devastating missed connection at a train station. It captures that specific Sparks-ian tragedy where two people are clearly meant to be together, but the universe is actively working against them.
✨ Don't miss: Who was the voice of Yoda? The real story behind the Jedi Master
Dear John (2010)
Sometimes Netflix actually has the real deal. Dear John is a literal Nicholas Sparks adaptation. Channing Tatum is the soldier on leave, and Amanda Seyfried is the idealistic college student. They fall in love over a few weeks, and then the rest of the movie is basically an exercise in how much long-distance pining a human heart can take.
It hits those same notes of social class and parental disapproval, though it trades the 1940s aesthetic for the early 2000s post-9/11 landscape. The letters are the centerpiece here, just like Noah’s 365 letters that Allie’s mom hid in the original story. It’s a bit grittier, sure. But the "Notebook" DNA is undeniable.
The historical romance trap
Let's be real. Part of why we love The Notebook is the nostalgia for a time we never lived through. The 1940s look amazing on film. When searching for movies like The Notebook on Netflix, you’ll often get recommended Bridgerton or Persuasion.
Don't fall for it if you want that specific Sparks vibe.
Jane Austen adaptations are about wit and societal rules. The Notebook is about raw, messy, "I'm a bird if you're a bird" emotion. You need films that prioritize the feeling over the etiquette.
🔗 Read more: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
Purple Hearts (2022)
This was a massive hit for Netflix, though it’s polarizing. It features a marriage of convenience between a struggling singer (Sofia Carson) and a Marine (Nicholas Galitzine). It doesn't have the period setting, but it has the high-stakes emotional friction. They come from two different worlds. They disagree on almost everything. But then the tragedy of war forces them to confront how they actually feel. It’s a modern melodrama in the purest sense. If the part of The Notebook you liked best was Noah and Allie fighting because they were so different, Purple Hearts will satisfy that itch.
Our Souls at Night (2017)
This is the "old age" side of the story. If the scenes with James Garner and Gena Rowlands in the nursing home are what move you, watch this. It stars legends Robert Redford and Jane Fonda as neighbors who have both lost their spouses and decide to start sleeping in the same bed—platonically at first—just to have someone to talk to. It’s quiet. It’s beautiful. It deals with the reality of loving someone when you’re closer to the end than the beginning. It lacks the rain-soaked kissing scenes of the younger actors, but the emotional weight is just as heavy.
What people get wrong about the "Notebook" formula
A lot of people think any sad movie is like The Notebook. That’s not true. To really match that energy, a movie needs a few non-negotiables.
- A Class Divide: One person has money; the other doesn't.
- The Interference: A parent or a fiancé who is "perfect on paper" but clearly the wrong choice.
- The Return: A significant gap in time where both people grow up but never move on.
- The Visuals: Warm lighting, water (lakes, rain, ocean), and iconic outfits.
All the Bright Places or The Fault in Our Stars (when they are on the platform) often get grouped into this category. They shouldn't be. Those are "sick-lit" teen dramas. They are great, but they don't have that sweeping, multi-generational epic feel. You want something that feels like it could be a legend told by a grandfather.
Rebecca (2020)
Wait, hear me out. Lily James and Armie Hammer in a remake of the Hitchcock classic. It’s a gothic romance, so it’s darker. But the aesthetic? The 1930s/40s vibe? The sprawling estate? It captures that feeling of being overwhelmed by a love that feels like it’s haunted by the past. It’s more of a thriller, but the romantic tension is dialed up to eleven.
💡 You might also like: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
Making the most of your Netflix search
The algorithm is your friend, but it's also a bit lazy. If you just type in "romance," you’ll get The Kissing Booth. No offense to Joey King, but that is not the vibe.
To find the hidden gems that feel like movies like The Notebook on Netflix, try searching for these specific terms in the search bar:
- "Period Pieces"
- "Romantic Dramas based on Books"
- "Sentimental Movies"
Often, international films like The Cook of Castamar (a series, but still) or Anonymously Yours capture that deep-seated longing better than the big-budget American rom-coms.
One Day (2024 Series)
I know, it's a show, not a movie. But it’s the best thing Netflix has done for romance fans in a decade. It follows Emma and Dexter on the same day every year for twenty years. It has the same "destined to be together but the timing is never right" energy as Noah and Allie. You get to see them age. You see the fashion change from the 80s to the 2000s. By the end, you will be a puddle on the floor. It is the ultimate commitment for someone who wants to feel something deeply.
Actionable steps for your movie night
If you're ready to dive in, don't just pick the first thing you see. Check the "Leads" section on the Netflix detail page. If you see names like Nicholas Sparks or Jojo Moyes, you’re in the right place.
- Check the "More Like This" tab specifically on The Last Letter from Your Lover rather than the general romance category. It filters for the "melodrama" tag which is the sweet spot.
- Look for the "International" tag. Films from Turkey or Spain often lean much harder into the "Notebook" style of epic, tragic romance than modern Hollywood does.
- Turn off the lights. These movies are designed for atmosphere.
The reality is that The Notebook was a lightning-in-a-bottle moment for cinema. The chemistry between Gosling and McAdams wasn't just acting—they famously didn't get along at first, which created a genuine friction that translated perfectly to the screen. While Netflix has many contenders, the "best" replacement is usually the one that makes you forget you're looking at a screen and makes you wish you had someone to build a house for.
Start with The Last Letter from Your Lover. It’s the most authentic bridge to that 1940s longing you're looking for. Then, move to One Day if you have the emotional stamina for a longer journey. Just keep the tissues nearby. You’re going to need them.