Let’s be real. There is something incredibly specific about the "desert island" sub-genre that hits different. It isn’t just about survival. It's the aesthetic—the salt-crusted hair, the sun-drenched skin, and that weirdly alluring idea of stripping away society until there's nothing left but instinct. When Randal Kleiser dropped The Blue Lagoon in 1980, he wasn't just making a movie; he was bottling a very specific brand of tropical escapism that people are still trying to replicate decades later.
Movies like The Blue Lagoon usually fall into two camps. You’ve got the dreamy, coming-of-age romances where the scenery is as lush as the tension, and then you’ve got the gritty, "oh no, we're actually going to starve" survival dramas.
Finding that exact mix of innocence and isolation is harder than it looks. Most modern directors lean too hard into the horror of being stranded, forgetting that half the appeal of the 1980 Brooke Shields classic was the sheer beauty of it all. We want to see the turquoise water. We want the coconut husks. We want the "what would happen if the rules didn't exist anymore?" curiosity.
The 80s obsession with tropical isolation
It's impossible to talk about this vibe without mentioning Summer Lovers (1982). If you liked the visual language of The Blue Lagoon, this is its spiritual cousin. Also directed by Kleiser, it swaps the deserted island for the Greek islands, but the DNA is identical. It’s sun-bleached. It’s sweaty. It explores that same boundary-pushing territory of young people figuring out desire in a vacuum.
Then you have the actual sequel, Return to the Blue Lagoon (1991). Milla Jovovich basically stepped into the Brooke Shields role, and while critics absolutely trashed it at the time, it’s become a bit of a cult comfort watch for people who just want more of that specific Fiji scenery. It’s basically the same plot—shipwreck, growth, discovery—but with a 90s gloss.
Honestly, the 80s just did this better. They weren't afraid of the "slow" parts of being stranded. Modern movies feel the need to introduce a monster or a ticking clock, but those older films let the characters just exist in nature.
💡 You might also like: Anne Hathaway in The Dark Knight Rises: What Most People Get Wrong
When survival turns into a psychological game
If you’re looking for something with a bit more bite, The Beach (2000) is the obvious next step. Danny Boyle took Alex Garland’s novel and turned it into a fever dream about what happens when you try to create a "Blue Lagoon" style utopia in the real world. Leonardo DiCaprio’s character, Richard, is looking for exactly what we’re looking for when we watch these movies—something "pure."
But The Beach shows the dark side. It suggests that humans bring their baggage with them, even to a hidden paradise in Thailand. The cinematography is stunning, but the tone shifts from a tropical vacation to a psychological breakdown. It’s like The Blue Lagoon grew up and realized that people are actually kind of terrifying.
Cast Away is the gold standard for pure survival, obviously. Tom Hanks and a volleyball. It lacks the romance, but it captures the crushing silence of isolation that The Blue Lagoon skips over. While Emmeline and Richard had each other, Chuck Noland had his own sanity to contend with. It’s a masterclass in "show, don't tell."
The "Coming of Age" element in isolation
There's a reason these movies usually feature teenagers or young adults. It’s about the loss of innocence.
- Paradise (1982): This was a blatant attempt to cash in on the success of The Blue Lagoon. Phoebe Cates and Willie Aames get stuck in the desert rather than a jungle, fleeing a "white slave trader." It’s campy, it’s very of-its-time, and it’s arguably more "intense" than its predecessor, but it hits all those same notes of two young people discovering love while being hunted/stranded.
- Swept Away (1974/2002): The original Lina Wertmüller film is a biting social commentary about class. A rich woman and a sailor are stranded, and the power dynamic flips completely. Stay away from the Madonna remake unless you’re a completionist; the original Italian version is where the real substance is.
- Lord of the Flies: Specifically the 1990 version. It removes the romance entirely but doubles down on the "kids in nature" trope. It’s the dark mirror to the lagoon. If The Blue Lagoon is the dream of being stranded, Lord of the Flies is the reality of what happens when the social contract breaks.
Why the "Lagoon" aesthetic is making a comeback
You can see the influence of these films in modern shows like The White Lotus or The Wilds, though they’ve been updated for a cynical audience. We aren't as naive as we were in 1980. We know about skin cancer and dehydration. Yet, the visual language remains.
📖 Related: America's Got Talent Transformation: Why the Show Looks So Different in 2026
The 2012 Lifetime movie Blue Lagoon: The Awakening tried to modernize the story by making it two high schoolers who fall off a boat during a school trip to Trinidad. It’s basically a CW version of the story. It lacks the grit and the weirdness of the original, but it proves the premise is immortal. We will always want to watch attractive people try to light a fire on a beach.
The real-life locations that fueled the fire
Most of The Blue Lagoon was filmed on Nanuya Levu, a private island in Fiji. You can actually go there. It’s a resort now. That’s the irony—the very place that came to symbolize "untouched" beauty is now a high-end tourist destination.
Similarly, Maya Bay in Thailand (where The Beach was filmed) had to be closed to tourists for years because so many people wanted to find that "secret" spot that they nearly destroyed the ecosystem. Our collective obsession with these movies has a literal environmental impact.
Beyond the beach: Movies with the same DNA
Sometimes the "island" isn't a physical island. It’s any place where the rules of the world don't apply.
- Into the Wild (2007): Christopher McCandless sought his own version of a blue lagoon in the Alaskan wilderness. It’s the same impulse—the rejection of society—but with a much grimmer outcome. It captures that "expert" level of loneliness.
- Six Days, Seven Nights (1998): This is the rom-com version. Harrison Ford and Anne Heche. It’s light, it’s fun, and it focuses on the "odd couple" dynamic. It’s what you watch when The Blue Lagoon feels a bit too heavy or dated.
- The Savage Islands (Nate and Hayes): A 1983 swashbuckler that captures the South Pacific adventure vibe. It’s less about romance and more about Tommy Lee Jones being a pirate, but the setting is pure 80s tropical nostalgia.
Acknowledging the "Cringe" and the Controversy
We have to be honest: watching The Blue Lagoon today is a bit of a trip. The sexualization of minors (Brooke Shields was only 14 during filming) is something that modern viewers find deeply uncomfortable, and rightly so. Shields later testified before Congress about the lack of protections for child actors.
👉 See also: All I Watch for Christmas: What You’re Missing About the TBS Holiday Tradition
When you're looking for movies like The Blue Lagoon, you're often looking for the feeling the movie gave you as a kid—the sense of adventure and the beauty of the natural world—rather than the specific, problematic elements of the 1980 production. Films like The Black Stallion (1979) actually do a better job of capturing that "child in nature" wonder without the baggage. It’s about a boy and a horse stranded on a deserted island, and the first 30 minutes are practically a silent film. It’s gorgeous. It’s haunting. It’s arguably a better "island" movie than the one we're talking about.
Practical steps for the "Island" movie fan
If you want to dive deeper into this specific cinematic niche, don't just stick to the hits.
- Check out the 1949 version: Before Brooke Shields, Jean Simmons starred in a version of The Blue Lagoon. It’s much more chaste, obviously, but the technicolor cinematography is incredible for its time.
- Look for "Survivalist" Cinema: If you liked the "how to build a hut" aspect, look into movies like Swiss Family Robinson (the 1960 Disney version) or even the more recent Slightly Out of Focus style documentaries about real shipwrecks.
- Vibe Check: If you just want the aesthetic, look for "Coastal Tropical" as a genre on Letterboxd. There are thousands of lists dedicated to movies that feel like a humid summer afternoon.
Ultimately, these films work because they tap into a universal fantasy. We all think, just for a second, that we’d be the ones to thrive. We’d build the perfect shelter. We’d find the perfect waterfall. We’d finally be free of our phones and our jobs. The Blue Lagoon and its successors are the "what if" that we never actually want to live through, but we’ll never stop watching.
To get the most out of this genre, start by watching The Black Stallion for the pure artistry, then move to The Beach for the reality check, and finish with Summer Lovers if you just want to see the sun set over the ocean. Just don't forget the sunscreen.