You're standing in the lobby of the AMC Roosevelt Field, and the smell of butter is basically a physical force hitting you in the face. You checked the movie theater showtimes in Long Island on your phone five minutes ago, but now that you're here, the kiosk says the 7:15 PM IMAX screening of Avatar: Fire and Ash is sold out.
It happens. Often.
Long Island's movie scene is a weird, sprawling beast. It isn't just about the big chains like Regal or AMC, though they definitely dominate the horizon from Huntington to Montauk. It's about knowing which theater has the "good" recliners and which one still smells like the 90s (in a charming way, maybe?). If you're looking for showtimes today, you've got to navigate a mix of massive megaplexes and those tiny, independent gems that keep the art house vibe alive.
The Big Players: AMC, Regal, and the "Cinema de Lux" Experience
Most people searching for movie theater showtimes in Long Island are heading to one of the giants. We're talking about places like Island 16: Cinema de Lux in Holtsville. Honestly, if you haven't been there lately, they’ve leaned hard into the "premium" thing. They have these MX4D seats that literally poke you in the back and spray water during action scenes. It's a lot.
Then you have the AMC Stony Brook 17. It’s basically a landmark at this point. If you’re looking for Zootopia 2 or the latest horror flick like Primate, this is usually the default. But here’s the thing: their showtimes are staggered weirdly. You might see a 6:50 PM, a 7:00 PM, and a 7:10 PM, but each one is in a different format—Standard, Dolby, or IMAX.
Don't just click the first time you see.
👉 See also: Questions From Black Card Revoked: The Culture Test That Might Just Get You Roasted
Regal Lynbrook is another heavy hitter, especially since they renovated. It’s got that RPX screen which is basically Regal’s answer to IMAX. If you’re checking showtimes there for Greenland 2: Migration, pay attention to the "Laser" tag. It’s worth the extra three bucks for the brightness alone.
Why the "Tuesday Rule" is still a thing
If you want to save money, you probably already know about Discount Tuesdays. But on Long Island, it's a war zone. AMC Stubs members get 50% off on Tuesdays (and sometimes Wednesdays), which means showtimes for big hits like Song Sung Blue fill up by noon.
- Check the app at 10:00 AM.
- Book your seats.
- Don't expect to walk up to the window at 7:00 PM and get a center-row seat.
Finding Movie Theater Showtimes in Long Island for Indie Films
Sometimes you don't want a $20 bucket of popcorn and a movie about blue aliens. Sometimes you want a 35mm screening of a weird cult classic.
That’s where the Cinema Arts Centre in Huntington comes in.
This place is a nonprofit, and it feels like it. They have three screens and a cafe called Sky Room. If you’re looking for their showtimes, you won't always find them on Fandango. You’ve got to go to their site. This January, they’re running stuff like Hamnet and specialty screenings like The Testament of Ann Lee on actual 35mm film. They even have a "Sunday Schmooze" where they host film critics to talk about the movie afterward.
✨ Don't miss: The Reality of Sex Movies From Africa: Censorship, Nollywood, and the Digital Underground
It’s a different vibe. It’s quiet. People actually silence their phones.
Then there’s the Jacob Burns Film Center (okay, technically Westchester, but LI cinephiles make the trek) or the local gems closer to home like the Regal UA East Hampton. The East Hampton spot is interesting because its showtimes shift wildly depending on the season. In the winter, it’s a local hangout; in the summer, you’re sitting next to a Spielberg.
Current Blockbusters and What’s Coming Next
Right now, the schedules are packed. If you’re looking at movie theater showtimes in Long Island for this week, you’re likely seeing a heavy rotation of:
- Avatar: Fire and Ash: Taking up the biggest screens for 3+ hours.
- The SpongeBob Movie: Search for SquarePants: Great for the kids at the AMC Roosevelt Field.
- Marty Supreme: The new Josh Safdie flick starring Timothée Chalamet—this one is selling out fast in the "Artisan" theaters.
- 28 Years Later: The Bone Temple: This Danny Boyle sequel starts its run around January 15th.
There’s also a weirdly high demand for Gundam Premiere Night double features lately. If you’re an anime fan, those showtimes are usually one-night-only events, so you can't sleep on them.
Pro-Tips for Navigating Long Island Theaters
Honestly, the parking is the worst part. If you’re going to AMC Levittown 10, that parking lot is a labyrinth. Give yourself 15 minutes just for the car.
🔗 Read more: Alfonso Cuarón: Why the Harry Potter 3 Director Changed the Wizarding World Forever
If you're heading to Showcase Cinemas Island 16, join their Starpass. They usually do a "Free Popcorn" day around mid-January (National Popcorn Day), and they actually send you $5 rewards pretty frequently. It’s one of the few loyalty programs that doesn't feel like a total scam.
Also, look for "Open Caption" showtimes. A lot of theaters on the Island, specifically the Regal locations in Tangram and Lynbrook, are started to offer these more frequently. If you struggle to hear the dialogue over the sound of the person next to you crunching on nachos, these screenings are a lifesaver.
Actionable Next Steps
To get the best experience next time you're looking for movie theater showtimes in Long Island, follow this routine:
- Download the "Big Three" apps: AMC, Regal, and Showcase. Don't rely on Google’s snippet alone; it sometimes lags behind real-time sell-outs.
- Check the "Premium" labels: If a showtime says "Laser" or "Dolby Cinema," it's almost always worth the upgrade at Roosevelt Field or Stony Brook.
- Visit a boutique theater: Once a month, skip the megaplex and hit the Cinema Arts Centre in Huntington. It keeps the local film scene alive and offers movies you literally won't see anywhere else.
- Book early for weekends: For new releases like Mercy or Send Help (coming late January), Friday and Saturday nights are usually 90% full by 4:00 PM.
Finding a showtime is easy. Finding the right theater, a decent parking spot, and a seat that isn't in the front row—that's the real challenge.