When you think about the most successful presidents of the United States, names like Lincoln or Washington usually pop up like a reflex. It’s almost baked into our DNA at this point. But honestly, "success" in the White House is a moving target. What one generation calls a triumph, the next might see as a massive oversight. We like to think these rankings are set in stone—literally, in the case of Mount Rushmore—but the reality is way more fluid and, frankly, a bit more chaotic than your high school history book let on.
Historians basically treat these rankings like a high-stakes fantasy football league. Every few years, organizations like C-SPAN or the Siena College Research Institute poll hundreds of experts to see who’s up and who’s down. And while the guys at the very top rarely budge, the middle of the pack is a revolving door of shifting reputations.
Why We Still Argue Over the Most Successful Presidents of the United States
Success isn't just about winning wars or keeping the economy from imploding, though those are pretty big deals. It’s also about "Moral Authority," "Public Persuasion," and "International Relations." According to the 2021 C-SPAN Historians Survey, these are the invisible metrics that separate a one-term wonder from a legendary statesman.
Take Abraham Lincoln. He is almost universally ranked #1. Why? Because he didn't just win a war; he managed to keep a literal crumbling country from dissolving into separate nations while navigating a political landscape that was basically a snake pit. But even Lincoln had his critics at the time—people who thought he was a tyrant for suspending habeas corpus. Success, it turns out, often looks a lot like "doing the unpopular thing that happens to work out a century later."
The Big Three: The "Granite" Leaders
If you look at the 2024 Presidential Greatness Project survey, the top tier is basically a private club. Abraham Lincoln, Franklin D. Roosevelt (FDR), and George Washington. That’s it. Those are the ones historians say are "in a class by themselves."
🔗 Read more: When is the Next Hurricane Coming 2024: What Most People Get Wrong
FDR, for instance, recently overtook Washington for the #2 spot in some polls. That’s a huge shift! It’s mostly because scholars are valuing the creation of the modern presidency and the social safety net more than the "founding father" mystique lately. Roosevelt took a broken economy and a world at war and somehow didn't let the machine break. That kind of administrative stamina is rare.
Washington is a weird case because his success was mostly about what he didn't do. He didn't become a king. He didn't stay for a third term. He didn't let the new government collapse under the weight of its own ego. He was the "indispensable man" not because he was a policy genius, but because he was the only one everyone could agree on.
The Surprise Comebacks You Didn't See Coming
This is where things get interesting. You've probably heard that Ulysses S. Grant was a drunk who ran a corrupt administration. That was the "consensus" for decades. But guess what? Grant is having a massive moment. In 2000, he was ranked 33rd by C-SPAN. In 2021? He jumped to 20th. In the 2024 University of Houston poll, he’s up to 17th.
Why the sudden love for Grant? Historians are finally looking past the scandals of his subordinates and focusing on his civil rights record. He used the power of the federal government to crush the first iteration of the KKK and fought like hell to protect the rights of newly freed Black Americans. In a modern context, that makes him look like a visionary, not a failure.
💡 You might also like: What Really Happened With Trump Revoking Mayorkas Secret Service Protection
On the flip side, look at Andrew Jackson. He used to be a top-ten staple. Now? He’s plummeting. His treatment of Native Americans and the Trail of Tears has moved from a "noted flaw" to a "defining failure" in the eyes of many scholars. It’s a perfect example of how our cultural values dictate who we call successful.
The Modern Era: Recency Bias vs. Reality
It's always tricky to rank guys who are still alive or only recently out of office. Barack Obama has seen a steady climb, currently sitting at #7 in the latest scholarly rankings. Ronald Reagan usually hovers around the top ten or fifteen, though he fluctuates depending on who you ask.
The "living president" bounce is a real thing. Once a president leaves office and the partisan heat dies down, we start to look at their long-term impact. Bill Clinton held steady for years but dipped slightly in recent polls as "Moral Authority" became a bigger factor for historians.
What Really Makes a President "Great"?
It’s not just about being a nice person. Honestly, some of the "greatest" presidents were famously difficult.
📖 Related: Franklin D Roosevelt Civil Rights Record: Why It Is Way More Complicated Than You Think
The Siena College polls use 20 different categories, including:
- Willingness to take risks: This is why Teddy Roosevelt stays so high. He was a wild card, but his risks (like the Panama Canal or trust-busting) usually paid off.
- Ability to compromise: This is actually why Joe Biden debuted relatively high at #14 in the 2024 rankings. Scholars gave him points for getting major legislation through a razor-thin Congress.
- Luck: Seriously, they track luck. Some presidents just get dealt a bad hand (looking at you, Jimmy Carter and the stagflation era).
The "Failure" Tier: Learning from the Bottom
You can’t understand the most successful presidents without looking at the ones who flopped. James Buchanan, Andrew Johnson, and Franklin Pierce. These guys are the basement dwellers. Their common thread? They all failed to meet a crisis. Buchanan watched the country slide into Civil War and basically said, "Not my problem." Johnson actively fought against Reconstruction. If success is defined by meeting the moment, failure is defined by running away from it.
Surprising Bits You Might Not Know
- Lincoln was an inventor: He's the only president to hold a patent (for a device to lift boats over shoals). He was a tinkerer at heart.
- Washington didn't live in the White House: It wasn't finished! He spent his time in New York and Philly.
- The "Mount Rushmore" debate: If we added a fifth face, who would it be? In the 2024 survey, 65% of scholars said it should be FDR. Obama came in second at 11%.
Success is a mix of timing, temperament, and the ability to convince a stubborn public to follow you into the dark. It's not about being perfect—Lincoln had his setbacks, and FDR had his critics—it's about leaving the office stronger than you found it.
How to Dig Deeper into Presidential History
If you're looking to form your own opinion on who the most successful presidents of the United States really are, don't just stick to the highlight reels.
- Check out the primary sources: Go to the Library of Congress website and read actual letters. It’s wild how much more "human" they sound when they’re complaining about their cabinet or their teeth.
- Compare the polls: Look at the C-SPAN 2021 results versus the 2024 Presidential Greatness Project. See who moved and ask yourself why.
- Visit a Presidential Library: If you're ever near one, go. They are designed to make the president look good, sure, but seeing the original documents from a crisis like the Cuban Missile Crisis or the Great Depression puts the weight of the job in perspective.
History isn't a finished product. It's an ongoing argument. The names at the top might stay the same for now, but the reasons why we put them there are changing every single day.