If you’re a fantasy football nerd today, you probably think Jalen Hurts or Josh Allen invented the "dual-threat" scoring explosion. You know the type: the quarterback who throws for 300 and runs for two more scores just because he can. But if you were around in the mid-90s—or if you've spent any time digging through the record books—you know the real godfather of the fantasy "cheat code" was Steve Young.
Honestly, the most fantasy points scored in one game Steve Young ever managed isn't just a stat; it's a piece of NFL history. While he had some monsters in the regular season, the one everyone points to is the night he finally got the "monkey off his back" in Super Bowl XXIX.
It was January 29, 1995. The San Francisco 49ers were playing the San Diego Chargers. By the time the fourth quarter rolled around, Young hadn't just beaten the Chargers; he’d basically broken the concept of a balanced box score.
The Big One: Super Bowl XXIX Stats
Even though the Super Bowl isn't technically a "fantasy" game for most season-long leagues (unless you're in a weird playoff challenge), it’s the definitive answer to Young's peak ceiling. Using modern standard scoring, here is what that night looked like:
- 325 Passing Yards (13 points)
- 6 Passing Touchdowns (24 points)
- 49 Rushing Yards (4.9 points)
- 0 Interceptions
Total it up, and you get 41.9 fantasy points.
👉 See also: Why the Marlins Won World Series Titles Twice and Then Disappeared
In 1995, that was unheard of. Heck, in 2026, a 42-point game from your QB is still a week-winner. What makes it crazier is that he did it on the biggest stage possible. He threw touchdown passes to Jerry Rice, Ricky Watters, and William Floyd like he was playing a video game on "Rookie" difficulty.
Why Steve Young was a Fantasy God
You've gotta realize that back then, quarterbacks didn't run like they do now. Sure, you had Randall Cunningham, but Young was different. He was surgical. In 1994, the year he won his second MVP, he completed over 70% of his passes. That's a "today" number, not a 90s number.
He was the QB1 for what many consider the greatest offense ever assembled. Imagine having the most fantasy points scored in one game Steve Young could offer while also having Jerry Rice at WR1. It was a literal nightmare for opponents.
One regular-season game that often gets overlooked was a Week 13 matchup against the New Orleans Saints in 1994. Young went off for 350 passing yards and three scores, but added another 40 yards on the ground. In an era where 250 yards and two TDs was a "great" day, Young was regularly pushing 30-plus fantasy points.
✨ Don't miss: Why Funny Fantasy Football Names Actually Win Leagues
The 1994 MVP Campaign
If you were lucky enough to draft him in '94, you basically had a ticket to the championship. He finished the season with:
- 3,969 passing yards
- 35 passing touchdowns
- 293 rushing yards
- 7 rushing touchdowns
Let that sink in for a second. Seven rushing touchdowns. That’s 42 fantasy points just from his legs. Most modern "scramblers" would kill for that kind of efficiency. He wasn't just running for his life; he was a goal-line weapon.
What Most People Get Wrong
A lot of people look at the most fantasy points scored in one game Steve Young and think he was just a product of the West Coast Offense. Kinda true, but mostly wrong. Young had to be incredibly mobile to make that system work.
He was constantly extending plays. If you watch the tape of that Chargers game, he’s not just standing in a clean pocket. He’s moving, resetting his feet, and flicking the ball 50 yards downfield with that signature left-handed delivery.
🔗 Read more: Heisman Trophy Nominees 2024: The Year the System Almost Broke
Actionable Insights for Fantasy Historians
If you’re looking to compare Young’s peak to modern stars, here is how you should weigh it:
- Standard vs. PPR: For QBs, the scoring hasn't changed much (4 per pass TD, 6 per rush TD), making Young’s 41.9-point Super Bowl directly comparable to modern elites.
- Era Adjustment: In 1994, the league average for passing yards per game was about 210. Young was averaging nearly 250 despite being pulled from several blowouts early.
- Efficiency Matters: Young's 112.8 passer rating in 1994 stood as the record for years. High efficiency means fewer interceptions, which means fewer point deductions in your fantasy matchup.
If you're doing a "Greatest of All Time" fantasy draft, Steve Young is a top-three pick at QB, period. He offered a floor that was safe because of his legs and a ceiling that was—as the Chargers found out—completely limitless.
To really appreciate the most fantasy points scored in one game Steve Young put up, go watch the highlights of Super Bowl XXIX. It’s a masterclass in how one player can completely dictate the flow of a game. For your next step, you should look up his 1998 season; even at 37 years old, he was still putting up 400-yard games like it was nothing.
Next Steps:
Go check out the 1994 49ers team stats to see how Jerry Rice and Ricky Watters benefited from Young's historic efficiency. You'll quickly see why that roster is still the gold standard for fantasy production.