You ever pick up a comic and feel like the pages are actually gaslighting you? That’s the Moon Knight Jeff Lemire experience in a nutshell. Honestly, before 2016, Moon Knight was often just "Marvel’s Batman but with a cape that looks like a croissant." Then Jeff Lemire and Greg Smallwood showed up and decided to turn the character's brain inside out. It wasn't just another superhero book; it was a 14-issue descent into a mental health crisis that happens to involve ancient Egyptian deities.
Most people who watched the Disney+ show recognize the "asylum" setting. But the comic is way weirder. It’s better, too.
The Hospital That Shouldn't Exist
The story kicks off with Marc Spector waking up in a bleak, decrepit mental institution. He’s told he’s been there since he was twelve. All those memories of being a mercenary? The silver gliders? The Egyptian god Khonshu? The doctors tell him it’s all a delusion. It’s a classic "is he or isn't he" trope, but Lemire leans into it so hard you actually start doubting the last forty years of Marvel history.
The staff at the hospital aren't just mean; they're literally the goddess Ammut and her cronies in disguise. Or maybe they aren't. That’s the hook.
Lemire doesn't give you a straight answer for a long time. You've got Marc trying to escape a New York City that has been buried in sand and replaced by "New Egypt." The pacing is frantic. One second he’s Marc, the next he’s Mr. Knight punching a cop who might actually be a crocodile-headed monster named Sobek.
📖 Related: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
Why the Art Changes Everything
You can't talk about the Moon Knight Jeff Lemire run without talking about the visual chaos. Greg Smallwood’s art is the glue, but then things get experimental.
When Marc’s mind starts splintering into his different alters, the art style shifts to match who is "fronting."
- Steven Grant: The billionaire persona gets a clean, sleek look from Wilfredo Torres.
- Jake Lockley: The gritty cab driver's world is drawn by Francesco Francavilla in a heavy, orange-and-teal noir style.
- Moon Knight in Space: There’s a weird sci-fi version of Marc fighting space wolves on the moon, rendered in the hyper-detailed, scratchy style of James Stokoe.
It’s brilliant. It’s not just a gimmick; it’s a way to let the reader feel the disorientation of Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID). You aren't just reading about a guy with multiple personalities; you're seeing the world through three different lenses at the same time.
Khonshu is a Terrible Father
In older comics, Khonshu was often just a distant source of powers. Lemire makes him a toxic, overbearing parent. He’s manipulative. He’s cruel. He basically tells Marc that he’s nothing without the god.
👉 See also: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
The core of this run is Marc realizing that his mental health isn't a "gift" from a god, and it's not a weakness to be cured. It's just who he is. The finale involves Marc literally confronting Khonshu in a psychic landscape to reclaim his own mind. It’s incredibly emotional.
Most superhero stories end with a big punch-up. This one ends with a man accepting his own fractured identity so he can finally stop being a puppet.
What the Disney+ Show Kept (and What It Lost)
If you loved episode five of the Moon Knight series—the one where they're in the hospital—you've seen the Lemire influence. That entire aesthetic was lifted straight from these pages. However, the show made Steven Grant a bumbling gift-shop clerk. In the Lemire run, Steven is still the suave movie producer, which makes his eventual breakdown even more jarring.
The comic is also much darker. There’s a sense of dread that the TV show replaced with CGI action. If you want the "pure" version of that psychological horror, the 2016 run is the only place to find it.
✨ Don't miss: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
How to Actually Read the Lemire Run
If you're looking to dive in, don't just buy random issues. You want the collected editions.
- Moon Knight Vol. 1: Lunatic – This covers the hospital escape and the "New Egypt" stuff.
- Moon Knight Vol. 2: Reincarnations – This is where the different artists come in for the alters.
- Moon Knight Vol. 3: Birth and Death – The final showdown with Khonshu.
You can usually find these collected in a single "Complete Collection" or Omnibus. Honestly, just get the big book. You’re going to want to read it all in one sitting anyway.
Actionable Insights for New Readers
- Don't worry about continuity: You don't need to know thirty years of Marvel history. Lemire explains the basics of the "mercenary at the statue" origin within the story.
- Watch the gutters: Smallwood uses negative space (the white parts of the page) as a storytelling tool. Pay attention to how the panels shrink or grow based on Marc’s stability.
- Prepare for a re-read: The first time through is confusing on purpose. Once you know the ending, the clues in the first three issues become much more obvious.
The Moon Knight Jeff Lemire era changed the character forever by making him more than just a guy in a white suit. It proved that the most interesting battles aren't fought in the streets of New York, but inside the mind of the hero himself. If you've only seen the show, you're missing the best part of the story.
Go find a copy of Moon Knight: Lunatic. It’s worth the headache.