You’ve probably seen the movie on Netflix. It's got the sweeping vistas, the dramatic horse rides, and a gritty performance that makes you want to go out and buy a Stetson. But honestly, the real story of Montford the Chickasaw Rancher—a man named Montford Johnson—is way more interesting than anything a Hollywood scriptwriter could cook up. We're talking about a guy who built a 1.3-million-acre empire in a place everyone else was too terrified to touch.
Basically, he was the original pioneer of the "wild" west of Indian Territory. But he wasn't some gunslinging outlaw. He was a businessman. A diplomat. A survivor.
The Abandoned Boy Who Built an Empire
Montford was born in 1843, and life didn't exactly hand him a silver spoon. His dad, Charles "Boggy" Johnson, was a Shakespearean actor from England. Think about that for a second. An English actor in the middle of the Chickasaw Nation. After Montford’s mother, Rebekah Courtney, passed away, Boggy just... left. He headed back east, leaving Montford and his sister Adelaide to be raised by their grandmother, Sallie Tarntubby.
Growing up under Sallie's wing was where he really learned the ropes. He didn't just learn how to ride; he learned the Chickasaw traditions and the specific rhythms of the land. Later, at the Chickasaw Manual Labor Academy, he picked up the "modern" farming tech of the mid-1800s. It was this weird, perfect blend of traditional knowledge and new-school agribusiness that set him apart.
✨ Don't miss: BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse Superstition Springs Menu: What to Order Right Now
Why the "Wild Tribes" Actually Trusted Him
Most history books paint the relationship between ranchers and the Plains tribes (like the Comanche and Kiowa) as a constant bloodbath. It was messy, sure. But Montford Johnson did something different. He talked to people.
Through his friend Jesse Chisholm—yeah, the guy the trail is named after—Montford negotiated a deal. He wanted to ranch on the western edge of the Chickasaw Nation, a place people called "no man's land" because of the threat of raids. The tribal chiefs agreed to let him stay on one condition: No white cowboys. They didn't want the U.S. military or Texas rangers creeping onto their land. Montford agreed. He hired African-American and Native American cowboys almost exclusively. This wasn't just some diversity initiative; it was a survival strategy that created one of the most unique workforces in American history.
The Salt Block Strategy: How He Rebuilt After the War
The Civil War absolutely trashed the local economy. Cattle were scattered, brands were lost, and most people were broke. Montford, being the clever guy he was, noticed something about the wild cattle roaming the hills. They were desperate for salt.
🔗 Read more: Bird Feeders on a Pole: What Most People Get Wrong About Backyard Setups
He didn't waste time chasing them on horseback for weeks. Instead, he built "traps"—large pens with salt licks inside. The gates were designed so cattle could walk in but couldn't get back out.
- He’d bait the pens.
- He’d wait for the "unruly" wild cattle to wander in.
- He’d negotiate with other ranchers to buy the rights to unbranded cattle.
By the time he was done, he had 35,000 head of cattle. That’s a massive operation even by today’s standards.
What the Movie Got Right (and Wrong)
You’ve gotta give it to Chickasaw Nation Productions; they did a solid job with the film Montford: The Chickasaw Rancher. It’s one of the few Westerns that actually feels authentic because it was produced by the people whose history it belongs to.
💡 You might also like: Barn Owl at Night: Why These Silent Hunters Are Creepier (and Cooler) Than You Think
- The Vibe: They nailed the grit. Life back then wasn't clean. It was dusty, sweaty, and stressful.
- The Character: Montford was known for his integrity. He wasn't just out to get rich. He famously let starving people take cattle from his herds when the U.S. government failed to provide promised rations.
- The "Hollywood" Factor: Naturally, the film ramps up the gunfights. In reality, Montford's greatest weapon was his mouth—he spent more time negotiating treaties and business deals than he did shooting at people.
The Legacy Nobody Talks About
Most people think of ranching as just cows and grass. For Montford, it was about building a future for the Chickasaw people. His family helped establish eight different towns in Oklahoma. Think about that. Eight towns.
He also took in countless orphans. Having been abandoned by his own father, he made it a point to never let a kid in his orbit go without a home. It’s this side of him—the philanthropist—that often gets buried under the "cowboy" legend.
How to Explore the History of Montford the Chickasaw Rancher Today
If you're actually interested in seeing where this all went down, you don't have to just watch Netflix.
- Visit the Montford Inn: Located in Norman, Oklahoma, this place is run by Montford’s direct descendants. There's even a "Chickasaw Rancher" room filled with family history.
- Check out the Chickasaw Cultural Center: They have incredible exhibits on the ranching era and how the tribe transitioned after the Removal.
- Read the Source: The book The Chickasaw Rancher by Neil R. Johnson (Montford’s grandson) is the definitive account. It’s basically a refined version of family diaries and oral histories.
Montford Johnson died in 1896, but the way he handled business—with fairness, inclusion, and a healthy dose of stubbornness—is still a blueprint for how to build something that lasts in a world that’s constantly changing. He didn't just survive the frontier; he defined it.
To get a true sense of the scale of his operations, start by mapping out the historical Chisholm Trail route through central Oklahoma. Seeing the geography helps you understand the sheer logistical nightmare he managed to turn into a thriving business. You can also look into the National Cowboy & Western Heritage Museum in Oklahoma City, where Montford was inducted into the Hall of Great Westerners in 2020. This gives you a more formal look at his contributions to American agriculture beyond just the family stories.