You walk past the sleek, glass-fronted condos and the high-end boutique shops that have taken over most of Boerum Hill. Then you see it. The neon sign. The weathered wood. The smell of salt air and stale beer. Honestly, Montero Bar and Grill shouldn't still exist. In a city that treats its history like a disposable napkin, this place is a defiant, nautical-themed miracle.
It’s old. Like, "opened in 1947" old.
While the rest of Brooklyn was busy getting artisanal and expensive, Montero's just... stayed. It’s a merchant marine bar at heart. It was a place for sailors who had just docked at the nearby piers to grab a drink and maybe forget the sea for a few hours. Today, the ships are mostly gone, replaced by the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway and luxury high-rises, but the spirit of the waterfront is jammed into every corner of this room.
The Vibe That Money Can't Buy
Walking into Montero Bar and Grill feels like stepping into the belly of a wooden ship that’s been converted into a living room. It’s cluttered. There are life rings, model ships, and dusty maritime photos everywhere. It’s not "curated" by an interior designer. It’s just stuff that’s been collected over eight decades.
The lighting is dim. Red. Moody.
You’ve got the old-timers who have lived in the neighborhood since the Truman administration sitting next to 23-year-olds who just moved to New York and want a cheap PBR. That’s the magic. Nobody cares who you are or what you do for a living as long as you aren’t a jerk. It's one of the few places left where the "Old Brooklyn" and "New Brooklyn" actually talk to each other without it being awkward.
The bar is famous for its karaoke. But forget those polished, high-tech karaoke rooms you find in Midtown. At Montero, the "stage" is basically a clearing in the middle of the floor. There’s a guy named Steve who has been running the show for years. He’s a legend. He knows the regulars. He knows who can actually sing and who’s just had three too many whiskies.
🔗 Read more: Is Barceló Whale Lagoon Maldives Actually Worth the Trip to Ari Atoll?
When the karaoke starts, the energy shifts. Total strangers start singing along to Billy Joel or Bonnie Tyler. It’s loud. It’s chaotic. It’s perfect.
Why People Get Montero Bar and Grill Wrong
A lot of people think this is just another "ironic" dive bar. It isn't.
A real dive bar isn't a choice; it's an evolution. Montero Bar and Grill wasn't designed to look gritty. It’s gritty because it’s survived decades of economic shifts, the decline of the shipping industry, and the rampant gentrification of Atlantic Avenue. Most "dives" these days are just expensive bars with cheap-looking wallpaper. Montero is the real deal.
People also think it’s just a weekend spot for tourists. Wrong again. If you go on a Tuesday afternoon, you’ll see the heartbeat of the place. It’s the local haunt for people who work in the trades, writers who need a quiet corner, and the Montero family themselves.
The bar was founded by Pilar and Joseph Montero. It stayed in the family. That’s why it feels different. There’s a sense of stewardship here. You’re not just a customer; you’re a guest in a family-run establishment that has weathered more storms than the ships on its walls.
The Legend of the Nautical Decor
Everything you see on the walls has a story. Those model ships? Many were built by hand or brought in by actual sailors. The lifesavers aren't props from a movie set. Honestly, if you spent enough time looking at every photo and plaque, you’d probably learn more about Brooklyn’s maritime history than you would at a museum.
💡 You might also like: How to Actually Book the Hangover Suite Caesars Las Vegas Without Getting Fooled
It’s cramped. If the bar is full, you’re going to be bumping elbows with your neighbor. Get over it. That’s the point. In a world where we spend all our time behind screens, the forced physical proximity of a place like Montero Bar and Grill is a feature, not a bug. It forces human interaction.
What to Actually Drink and Do
Don't come here looking for a smoked rosemary old fashioned or a craft beer with a label you can't pronounce. Keep it simple.
- Get a beer and a shot. It’s the unofficial uniform of the bar.
- Bring cash. They might take cards now (depending on the day and the mood), but having cash is just easier and keeps the line moving.
- Listen more than you talk. If you sit at the bar and find yourself next to a regular, ask them about the neighborhood. You'll get better stories than anything on Wikipedia.
- Respect the karaoke queue. Steve has a system. Don't try to bribe your way to the front. Just wait your turn and cheer for the person who is inevitably butchering "Don't Stop Believin'."
The prices are shockingly reasonable for Brooklyn. You can actually have a night out here without feeling like you need to take out a second mortgage. That’s getting harder and harder to find in this zip code.
The Fight to Stay Alive
It hasn't been easy. There was a time when the future of Montero Bar and Grill was in serious doubt. Development pressures in Brooklyn are intense. When you have a small, two-story building sitting on land that could easily support a massive luxury tower, the developers circle like sharks.
But the community rallied. There have been various efforts over the years to preserve the bar, and so far, it’s holding its ground. It’s a landmark of human experience rather than an official architectural one. If New York loses Montero, it loses a piece of its DNA.
The bar survived the pandemic, which was no small feat. It survived the 70s, which were arguably rougher. It’s tough. Like the sailors it used to serve, it knows how to take a hit and keep floating.
📖 Related: How Far Is Tennessee To California: What Most Travelers Get Wrong
Final Practical Tips for Your Visit
If you’re planning to head down to Atlantic Avenue to check it out, keep these things in mind.
First, the weekends are packed. If you want the full "crazy karaoke" experience, Friday and Saturday nights are your best bet, but be prepared for a crowd. If you want to actually see the artifacts and talk to the bartender, go on a weekday before 7:00 PM.
Second, be cool. This isn't a theme park. It’s a neighborhood institution. Treat the staff with respect and don't treat the regulars like they’re part of a museum exhibit.
Third, explore the area. You’re near the Brooklyn Heights Promenade and Brooklyn Bridge Park. A walk along the water followed by a few drinks at Montero is the quintessential Brooklyn afternoon.
Your Next Steps
- Check the hours: They generally open in the afternoon, but it varies. Check their social media or just walk by—the neon sign is the only reliable indicator.
- Carry a $20 bill: Even if they take cards, a cash tip is always appreciated in an old-school joint.
- Pick your song early: If you’re going for karaoke, have your song ready. Don’t be the person scrolling through your phone at the mic while the whole bar waits.
- Look up: Some of the coolest maritime memorabilia is hanging from the ceiling or tucked away in the rafters.
Montero Bar and Grill is a reminder that while the world changes, some things are worth keeping exactly the same. It’s dusty, it’s loud, and it’s one of the best places in New York City. Go there before some developer decides the world needs another $15-per-juice shop instead.