You walk past the red awning on East 54th Street and you might miss it. It’s tucked into the Hotel Elysée, a building that looks like a million other limestone structures in Midtown Manhattan. But inside? It’s different. Monkey Bar NYC isn't just a restaurant; it’s a living, breathing time capsule that has managed to survive the fickle nature of New York nightlife for nearly a century. Most places in this city have the lifespan of a fruit fly. This place has outlasted wars, recessions, and about a dozen different fashion eras.
It's loud. The lighting is low. There is a specific kind of hum in the air that only exists in rooms where deals are being made and secrets are being spilled. Honestly, if these walls could talk, they’d probably be subpoenaed.
The Mural, The Myth, and The 4-Star Refresh
For decades, people came for the murals. Ed Sorel’s iconic illustrations of Jazz Age celebrities—think F. Scott Fitzgerald and Dorothy Parker—wrap around the dining room like a warm, booze-soaked hug. It gives you the feeling that you’re crashing a party from 1930. But by the late 2010s, the vibe had grown a bit dusty. It was the kind of place your grandfather took his mistress, or where a corporate lawyer went to hide.
Then came 2022.
The 4 Charles Prime Rib team, led by Brendan Sodikoff’s Hogsalt Hospitality, took the reins. They didn't gut the place—thank god—but they polished it until it gleamed. They kept the soul and fixed the food. Now, trying to get a table at Monkey Bar NYC is basically a full-time job. If you aren't hovering over Resy at the exact moment slots drop, you’re eating at the bar. If you can even find a stool there.
What’s Actually On The Menu?
Let’s be real: you aren't coming here for "innovative molecular gastronomy." You're coming for a burger that costs more than your first car's insurance payment but actually tastes like it's worth it.
The menu is a love letter to American tavern classics. You’ve got the Double Cheeseburger, which is a direct descendant of the legendary 4 Charles burger. It’s thick. It’s messy. It’s salty in all the right ways. Then there’s the prime rib. They offer different cuts—the English Cut is thin and delicate, while the King’s Cut is basically a weapon.
📖 Related: Blue Bathroom Wall Tiles: What Most People Get Wrong About Color and Mood
- The King’s Cut: A massive slab of salt-crusted prime rib.
- The Wedge Salad: It’s cold, crisp, and smothered in enough blue cheese to make a doctor nervous.
- Truffle Pasta: Because it's Midtown, and people like to spend money on truffles.
The drinks are where things get dangerous. The martinis are served ice cold. They don't mess around with "craft" garnishes that look like a salad. It’s a lemon twist or an olive. Simple. Strong. If you have three, you aren't making your 9:00 AM meeting the next day. You just aren't.
Why Everyone Is Obsessed With The Vibe
There is no windows. That’s the secret. Once you’re inside Monkey Bar NYC, time ceases to exist. It could be 6:00 PM or 2:00 AM. You lose track. This lack of connection to the outside world is exactly why the elite love it. It’s private without being a "private club."
The seating is mostly plush red leather booths. These are the gold standard of New York seating. You can huddle with three friends and feel like you're in a conspiracy. It’s intimate. It’s also incredibly loud, which paradoxically makes it easier to have a private conversation. Your neighbors can't hear you over the clinking of silverware and the roar of the crowd.
The Resurrection of Midtown Cool
For a while, everyone said Midtown was dead. They said the "cool" kids only went to the West Village or the Lower East Side. Monkey Bar NYC proved them wrong. It brought back the idea of the "power dinner." You’ll see guys in $5,000 suits sitting next to people in vintage leather jackets. It’s a mix that shouldn't work but somehow does.
The service is old-school. The staff knows the menu backwards. They aren't "checking in" on you every five minutes with a scripted line. They’re professionals. They watch from the periphery and appear exactly when your glass is empty. It’s a lost art in the era of QR code menus and distracted servers.
How To Actually Get A Table
Getting into Monkey Bar NYC is the biggest hurdle. People complain about it constantly on TikTok and Reddit. Here is the reality of the situation:
👉 See also: BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse Superstition Springs Menu: What to Order Right Now
Resy is your only hope, but you have to be tactical. They release tables 21 days in advance at 9:00 AM. If you log on at 9:05 AM, you are looking at a 10:30 PM reservation on a Tuesday.
- Set an alarm. 8:59 AM. Be logged in. Have your credit card saved.
- The Bar Strategy. They do keep some space for walk-ins at the bar. If you show up right when they open—usually 4:30 PM or 5:00 PM—you have a fighting chance.
- Notify Me. Don't ignore the "Notify" button on Resy. Cancellations happen, especially in NYC where people’s plans change at the last second.
The Truth About The Price Tag
Is it expensive? Yes. Ridiculously so. You can easily drop $200 per person without trying very hard. A side of creamed spinach is going to cost you more than a whole meal at a fast-casual spot.
But you aren't just paying for the calories. You’re paying for the theater. You’re paying for the fact that you’re sitting in a room where Joe DiMaggio and Ava Gardner used to hang out. You’re paying for the lighting that makes everyone look ten years younger. In a city that is becoming increasingly sanitized and corporate, Monkey Bar NYC feels like a piece of the "Old New York" that everyone claims to miss.
Common Misconceptions
A lot of people think you need a suit to get in. You don't. While the "Smart Casual" dress code is suggested, the "Smart" part is doing more work than the "Casual." You don't need a tie, but maybe leave the flip-flops at the hotel.
Another myth: it’s just for tourists. Not true. While the Hotel Elysée upstairs brings in out-of-towners, the dining room is packed with locals. It’s a favorite for the media crowd, fashion editors, and finance types who want a steak without the stuffiness of a traditional Peter Luger-style house.
Looking Forward: The Future of the Legend
Sodikoff and the Hogsalt team have a track record of taking historic spaces and making them relevant again. They did it with Au Cheval in Chicago and 4 Charles in the Village. With Monkey Bar NYC, they’ve managed to capture lightning in a bottle. They’ve respected the history—the murals are still there, the monkeys are still hanging from the lamps—but they’ve updated the execution.
✨ Don't miss: Bird Feeders on a Pole: What Most People Get Wrong About Backyard Setups
The food is consistent. That’s the hardest thing to achieve in New York. You go there six months from now, and that prime rib will taste exactly the same. That reliability is what keeps people coming back, even if they have to fight the Resy bots to do it.
Actionable Tips for Your Visit
If you manage to snag a reservation, don't rush. This is a place for a three-hour dinner.
Start with the Shrimp Cocktail. It sounds basic, but the shrimp are massive and the cocktail sauce has enough horseradish to clear your sinuses. For the main, if you’re with a group, get the Prime Rib and the Burger and share. It’s the only way to experience the full range of what the kitchen does best. And whatever you do, order the Chocolate Pie for dessert. It’s rich, dark, and decadent enough to be its own food group.
Lastly, talk to the bartenders. Many of them have been in the industry for years and have the best stories about the neighborhood. Just don't ask them for a table if the host already said no. They can't help you there.
To experience Monkey Bar NYC properly, you have to lean into the excess. Order the extra martini. Get the truffle fries. Forget about the bill until tomorrow. In a city that's always rushing toward the next big thing, spending a few hours in a red leather booth under a mural of 1920s legends is about as good as it gets.
Next Steps for Your NYC Night Out:
- Check Resy exactly 21 days before your desired date at 9:00 AM sharp to secure a prime-time booth.
- Review the current "Tavern Menu" online before arriving, as seasonal specials for the prime rib cuts often rotate.
- Plan your transportation to arrive 15 minutes early; Midtown traffic on 54th Street is notoriously unpredictable, and they generally only hold tables for 15 minutes.
- Budget approximately $150-$220 per person including drinks, tax, and tip for a full dinner experience.