You've been there. It’s the bottom of the ninth, you’ve got a runner on second, and you perfectly time a high-fastball with Shohei Ohtani. The crack of the bat sounds like a cannon shot. In any world governed by the laws of physics, that ball is landing in the bleachers. Instead, it’s a routine flyout to center field. Or maybe you're pitching, and even though your input is "Perfect," the CPU somehow fouls off twelve straight sliders in the dirt like they’re prime Tony Gwynn.
It’s frustrating. Honestly, it's enough to make you want to put the controller through the drywall.
The default settings in mlb the show 25 sliders are designed to appeal to everyone, which usually means they satisfy no one. They try to balance the "fun" of an arcade game with the "depth" of a simulation, and the result is often a middle-ground mush that feels scripted. If you want the game to actually represent the sport—where hits into the gap stay in the gap and pitchers actually struggle with command—you have to get your hands dirty in the settings menu.
The Myth of the Perfect Preset
Most people jump straight into a Franchise and leave everything on "All-Star" or "Hall of Fame" thinking the difficulty preset does all the heavy lifting. It doesn't. Presets only change the window of success for your inputs; they don't fundamentally change how the AI behaves or how the ball interacts with the environment.
The community often talks about "Slideritis," a condition where you spend more time in menus than on the mound. It's a real trap. You change one thing, it breaks another, and suddenly you’re tweaking settings every three innings. But there is a logic to it. You have to understand that the game is a series of mathematical checks. When you move a slider, you aren't just "making it harder," you’re shifting the probability of an outcome.
Why the CPU is Basically Cheating (And How to Stop It)
The biggest gripe in MLB The Show 25 is the CPU’s foul ball frequency. It’s absurd. You can have a 68-overall bench warmer fouling off 99 MPH heaters on the black. To fix this, you have to look at CPU Foul Frequency.
- Default: 5
- Realistic adjustment: 2 or 3
Lowering this doesn't make the CPU worse; it makes them more realistic. In real life, if a batter is fooled, they swing and miss. They don't magically clip the ball every single time to stay alive. By dropping this, you’ll see more realistic strikeout numbers and, more importantly, lower pitch counts for your starters.
Then there's the CPU Solid Hits slider. If you feel like the AI is hitting "bloop" singles that somehow carry for 400 feet, this is the culprit. Dialing this back to 4 helps eliminate those "cheap" home runs where the exit velocity doesn't match the swing quality.
Hitting Sliders: Finding the Sweet Spot
Hitting is the hardest thing to do in sports, and the game tries to mirror that. But sometimes it feels like the "Timing" window is a moving target. If you’re playing on a higher difficulty like Hall of Fame or Legend, you might find that even "Good" timing results in a lot of weak pop-ups.
- Human Contact: If you're struggling to just put the ball in play, bump this to 6.
- Human Power: Leave this at 5. Increasing power often leads to a "Home Run or Bust" meta that gets boring by May in your Franchise.
- Human Timing: This is the big one. If the game feels "heavy," move this to 6. It gives you just a fraction of a second more to react to the high heat.
The Pitch Speed Dilemma
Everyone has different reflexes. Some guys can track a 102 MPH Outman fastball on Legend without breaking a sweat. Others struggle with a 90 MPH sinker. In mlb the show 25 sliders, the "Fastball Pitch Speed" and "Offspeed Pitch Speed" settings are your best friends.
If the game feels too slow and you’re constantly "Too Early" on everything, turn the speed up. It sounds counterintuitive, but increasing the visual speed of the pitch can actually help your brain sync up with the animations. Try moving both speed sliders to 6 or 7. It makes the 100 MPH heat feel terrifying, just like it should.
Reclaiming the Outfield: Fielding and Baserunning
Have you noticed that outfielders in this game move like they’re all Olympic sprinters? Even a 40-speed lumbering first baseman seems to cover the gaps with ease. This is why you see so few doubles and triples compared to real MLB stats.
To fix the "vacuum" fielding, you need to lower Fielder Run Speed to 3 or 4.
This single change transforms the game. Suddenly, those line drives into the right-center gap actually reach the wall. You’ll see your runners sliding into second for a double instead of getting thrown out by a mile because the center fielder covered 100 feet in three seconds.
While you're at it, look at Fielder Reaction. Dropping this to 4 makes the ratings actually matter. A Gold Glove winner will still get a great jump, but a guy with 50 fielding will hesitate for a split second. That’s the nuance that makes a 162-game season feel diverse instead of repetitive.
Pitching Consistency and Accuracy
If you use Pinpoint or Meter pitching, you might feel like you have too much control. If you're "Perfect" every time, you never walk anyone. Real baseball is about the walks you give up as much as the strikeouts you earn.
- Human Pitching Consistency: Drop to 4.
- Human Pitching Accuracy: Drop to 4.
These small tweaks ensure that even if you nail the interface, the ball might still catch too much of the plate or miss slightly outside based on the pitcher’s individual attributes. It brings the "ratings" back into the equation, rather than it just being a test of your thumb skill.
The "Dynamic" Trap
A lot of players use Dynamic Difficulty, thinking it will find the perfect level for them. Here’s the problem: the game’s logic for moving you up or down is often reactive, not proactive. You’ll have one blowout game where you score 12 runs, and the game vaults you into a difficulty where you can’t buy a hit.
The pro move? Use Dynamic Difficulty until you find a level where you’re having competitive, 3-2 or 5-4 games. Once you find that "feel," go into the settings and see what difficulty it has reached (e.g., All-Star +). Then, hard-set your difficulty to that level and disable the dynamic slider. This stops the "rubber-banding" feel where the game tries to force you into a slump just because you had a good week.
Manager Hook and Injuries: The Long Game
If you’re a Franchise nerd, you need to look at the Manager Hook slider. At the default 5, CPU managers tend to leave their starters in way too long, or conversely, pull them after one bad inning. Moving this to 6 or 7 usually results in more realistic bullpen usage, especially in the modern era where starters rarely go past the sixth.
And please, turn up the Injury Frequency.
The default setting makes your players feel like Iron Men. A realistic MLB season is a war of attrition. Putting this at 6 or 7 forces you to actually use your 40-man roster and care about your Triple-A depth. It sucks when your star shortstop goes down for two months with a strained oblique, but that’s the drama that makes a championship run feel earned.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Career
Don't try to fix everything at once. If you overhaul every slider in one go, you won't know which change actually fixed the problem or made it worse.
Start by loading into a "Custom Practice" or a "Play Now" game with a neutral match-up—think Dodgers vs. Braves. Play three innings with your current settings. Then, only adjust the Fielder Run Speed and CPU Foul Frequency. Play another three. Notice the difference in how the field opens up and how the at-bats progress.
📖 Related: Why How to Make an Arcade Cabinet is Easier (and Harder) Than You Think
Once the "physics" of the game feel right, then you can move on to the "balance" sliders like Contact and Power. Remember, the goal of mlb the show 25 sliders isn't to make the game easy. It's to make the game honest. You want to lose because you hung a curveball, not because the AI decided it was time for a "scripted" comeback.
Take your time with it. Every monitor has different input lag, and every player has different thumbs. Your "perfect" settings won't be found on a forum; they're found through trial and error over a dozen games. Get the speed right first, then the fielding, and the rest will fall into place.