Honestly, I was skeptical. When Sony San Diego first announced they were bringing their massive baseball sim to the Nintendo Switch a few years back, most of us figured it’d be a laggy, blurry mess. Fast forward to now, and MLB The Show 24 Switch is out here proving that "playable" is an understatement. It’s a full-blown miracle of compression.
You aren't getting 4K grass textures. Let’s just get that out of the way. If you want to see the individual beads of sweat on Shohei Ohtani’s forehead, go buy a PS5. But if you want to grind out Diamond Dynasty missions while sitting on a plane or hiding from your boss in the breakroom? This version is a beast.
The Handheld Trade-off
The game looks kinda rough on a big 4K TV. Docked mode stretches those 720p-ish textures until they scream. But on the Switch OLED screen? It’s crisp enough to track a 102 mph four-seamer. The developers clearly prioritized the frame rate where it matters—the interaction between the pitcher and the hitter.
There’s a specific kind of magic in having the entire MLB ecosystem in your pocket. You get the same Diamond Dynasty programs, the same "Storylines" content, and the same rosters as the "big" consoles.
✨ Don't miss: Just Dance 2017 song list: Why this tracklist still hits today
What’s New (and What Actually Works)
The headline feature this year is definitely the expansion of the Negro Leagues Storylines. Season 2 introduces legends like Hank Aaron, Josh Gibson, and Toni Stone. On the Switch, these historical segments feel like watching a documentary on a vintage TV. The grainy film footage actually masks some of the hardware’s limitations. It’s immersive.
Then there’s the "Road to the Show" addition: you can finally play as a female ballplayer. The narrative beats are mostly told through text messages and menus, which, frankly, is a relief for the Switch hardware. It doesn't have to render complex cinematic cutscenes every five minutes. It just lets you play ball.
Performance Reality Check
I’m not going to lie to you—the menus are sluggish. Navigation can feel like wading through molasses if the servers are acting up.
- Frame Rate: Mostly sits at a stable 30 FPS during gameplay.
- Resolution: Dynamic, but stays around 720p in handheld.
- Loading Times: Significantly longer than the SSD-powered consoles.
If you’re a competitive "Ranked Seasons" player, you might struggle against opponents on high-end monitors. The input lag is small, but it’s there. Basically, if you’re playing at a World Series level in Diamond Dynasty, the Switch is your secondary machine for grinding CPU missions, not your primary competitive rig.
Is the Switch Version a "Watered Down" Port?
Surprisingly, no. Usually, sports games on Nintendo hardware are "Legacy Editions"—basically last year's game with a new sticker on the box. Think FIFA (or EA Sports FC). But San Diego Studio didn't do that.
They kept cross-progression. This is the game-changer. I can play three innings on my Xbox at home, save, and pick up exactly where I left off on my Switch during my commute. Your stubs, your cards, and your Diamond Dynasty progress all follow your account.
📖 Related: Eva Rosalene and Neil Watts Explained: Why To the Moon is Actually About Them
The Technical Hurdles
It isn't all sunshine and home runs. The fans in the stands look like cardboard cutouts from a 1996 PC game. The hair physics? Non-existent. Sometimes the lighting transitions between innings can make the players look like they’re made of plastic.
Also, the file size is a bit of a beast for a Switch game. You’re looking at a roughly 20GB+ download even if you buy the physical cartridge. Nintendo’s internal storage won't cut it; you’ll need a decent microSD card.
Why You Might Actually Prefer It
There is something inherently "arcadey" and fun about playing baseball on a handheld. The joysticks on the Joy-Cons aren't as precise as a DualSense, but for casual Franchise mode play, it’s perfect.
I’ve found myself finishing entire seasons on the Switch because I can play a quick three-inning game while the coffee is brewing. On a PS5, the "ritual" of turning on the TV and sitting on the couch makes it feel like a Commitment. On the Switch, it's just... there.
Actionable Advice for Switch Players
If you’re diving into MLB The Show 24 Switch, do these three things to make your life easier:
- Turn off "Cross-Play" for Online Ranked: If you’re playing competitively, don't match up against PS5 players with 120Hz monitors. Keep the playing field level by playing against other Switch users.
- Use a Pro Controller: The Joy-Con analog sticks have a very short travel distance. It makes hitting with the PCI (Plate Coverage Indicator) incredibly twitchy. A Pro Controller gives you the precision needed to catch up to high heat.
- Stick to Handheld: The game genuinely looks better on the smaller screen. The pixel density hides the low-resolution textures that become glaringly obvious on a 50-inch TV.
The Switch is in its twilight years. We all know a "Switch 2" is lurking around the corner. But for now, having a 1:1 port of the best sports sim on the market is a win for Nintendo fans. It’s the full experience, warts and all, and it’s arguably the most "productive" way to play if you’re trying to finish those massive Diamond Dynasty programs.
To get the most out of your experience, ensure your console's firmware is updated to the latest version to minimize those annoying "server transition" crashes that plagued the launch week. If you're running low on space, archiving older titles like The Show 23 is a must, as the 2024 edition requires a hefty chunk of your memory for the live content updates.